2020 National Bank version, domestic 1st/2nd section milk powder Hengping, stupid dad has all updated, and you can enter "1 section" and "2 section" in the background of WeChat public account.
In this issue, we are going to update the third paragraph of the national bank version of .
The stupid dad’s view is that after 1 year old, the main source of nutrition for the baby is to eat, and milk powder is only a supplement. Therefore, the choice of three-stage milk powder does not need to be too tangled. This evaluation and ranking are for your reference.
Routine reminder : The article is longer, if you don’t want to see detailed data analysis, you can directly look at the score summary below, or pull to the end of the article to see the total score and summary; if you want to know more details, choose more targeted, Please be patient to read the full text.
Rating summary
① Royal United States Su Jia children ② love him US Zhuo Cui Kai Fu
③ Wyeth Wyeth Kai Fu Daikin tank ④ Blue Diamond
⑤ promise Neolink PRO version
Benchmark description
1, the current version of the National Bank 3 milk powder Hengping , For non-organic milk powder, excluding goat milk powder, organic milk powder and formula powder for special medical purposes.
2. The evaluation of nutritional value is mainly based on the current national standard for milk powder GB 10767-2010 "National Food Safety Standard for Older Infants and Toddlers Formula", and also refers to the "National Food Safety Standard for Early Childhood Formulas" issued in September 2018 "(Draft for comments).
3. The evaluation is carried out from the following 6 indicators: raw materials, energy, vitamins, minerals, enhanced formula, brand trust, and the final scores are 17%, 17%, 17%, 17%, 17%. , 15%.
4. This milk powder evaluation is an independent evaluation, definitely not an advertisement or advertisment! The evaluation results are for your reference. You need to consider your baby's actual situation when purchasing. As long as your baby adapts, you don't need to be too entangled. The evaluation version of
is the same as paragraph 2. In the third paragraph of this period, the Hengping still selected 37 national milk powders with higher sales and brand awareness for evaluation.
The specific milk powder name and product packaging diagram are as follows:
Below, we officially start milk powder evaluation.
milk source & milk-based raw material comparison
(information source: National Market Supervision and Administration, brand promotion page, public information, product packaging, official customer service)
Summary: There are 1 models of 3 models 1zzzzz
z0, and 35zzzzz0. Milk source from the "Golden Milk Source Belt" of 40-50 degrees south/north latitude ( New Zealand , Europe, the United States, etc.). In these places, the pasture environment, dairy cow breeds are better, and the dairy cow breeding and management, and raw milk safety control are stricter. Generally speaking, milk sources in New Zealand and Europe are slightly better than those in the United States.The other two milk powders, Ai's mother Shangyun uses Korean milk source, which is relatively inferior to the above milk source; Nestlé Nengen's milk source information is not clear.
2, in terms of origin, 33 models are imported from foreign original cans. Abbott Classic Enmeili,Wyeth S-26 Baby Music, Mead Johnson Platinum Rui Quanyue, and Nestlé Neng En , are imported milk sources and are produced in China.
3, milk-based raw materials, that is, the main raw materials of milk powder, there are 9 models using fresh milk (raw milk, skimmed/full-fat milk) + wet process or dry-wet composite process , the freshness of the milk powder raw materials Better, get extra points.
Another 15 models use fresh milk + dry process, 8 models use milk powder (skimmed/whole milk powder), and 5 models use fresh milk + milk powder.
4, 37 models of three-stage milk powder, 14 models add vanillin, ethyl vanillin, vanilla bean extract and other food flavors (marked in yellow in the chart). The flavor of
makes the milk powder smell more "milky", which may aggravate the baby's taste and easily cause the baby's partial eclipse, which is not conducive to the development of light eating habits. It is not recommended for people under 1 year old. The stupid dad over 1 year old thinks that the requirement can be lowered a little bit, so the deduction for flavors in paragraph 3 will be less than before.
basic nutrition
carbohydrates
Summary:
1, the current national standard of China does not give the g/100 reference requirements for the new G/100 standard of J in the 3rd paragraph of the J carbohydrate content in the J-1.8 The carbohydrate content of
37 three-stage milk powder meets this range.
2 and 17 milk powders are added with sugars such as maltodextrin , corn syrup solids, glucose syrup, white granulated sugar , etc. The details are shown in the red letters above.
In milk powder, lactose is the best source of carbohydrates for babies (unless the baby has lactose intolerance), especially for babies under 1 year old. The main effect of the above sugar addition is to provide energy, but the nutritional value is not as good as lactose, and it also reduces the proportion of lactose in milk powder. White sugar may also cause baby tooth decay and fatness. Z20z are all deducted items .
The draft for the new national standard proposes that the content of lactose in the three-stage milk powder should not be less than 50% of carbohydrates, and there is no restriction on the use of white sugar, so in this regard, stupid dad will reduce the intensity of deduction.
fat
Summary:
1, the fat content of 37 models of three-stage milk powder meets Chinese national standards.
2 and 16 milk powders are added with palm oil / palm oil , which may have a saponification reaction with calcium, affect calcium absorption and increase the chance of constipation, belongs to the deduction item .
protein
Summary:
1, the protein content of 37 three-stage milk powder meets the Chinese national standard.
2, some milk powders are added with high-quality proteins such as lactoferrin , A2-β casein, etc., which will be analyzed in the featured enhanced formula section below.
Vitamins & Minerals Comparison
37 three-stage milk powders are added with all the essential vitamins and minerals required by the current Chinese national standard, and the content is in compliance with the regulations.
Among them, Royal Mei Su Jiaer, Nestlé Ruibo Nengen/Nengen, Maccome Leguan/Lexiang, without manganese ; Mead Johnson Platinum Rui/Lanzhen/Platinum Jump, without selenium .
Manganese and selenium are optional components of three-stage milk powder in the current Chinese national standard and the draft of the new national standard, and they are also in line with the national standard if they are not added. Babies over 1 year old can get them through daily meals, so don’t worry too much about this. . The specific vitamin data of
37 milk powder is as follows. The specific mineral data of
37 milk powder is as follows. Comparison of
enhanced formula
DHA/ARA
Summary:
z1, the content of the baby’s intelligence development is better than 0.3% of the total visual fatty acid and 0.5% in the milk powder.
Among 37 three-stage milk powders, 15 have a richer amount of DHA, and gets extra points (above the red line in the chart).
2, most of the three-stage milk powder has greatly reduced the ARA content, and even no longer added, pay attention to it.
3, Xibao , Beixi, Beiwei, does not add DHA/ARA.
Conventional fortified formula
Summary:
1. Conventional fortified formula, that is, although it is not an essential ingredient in the current Chinese national standard, most of the milk powder, carnitine, levofol, carnitine, zz , Nucleotides and dietary fiber . Refer to the draft of the new national standard for solicitation of opinions and the relevant data of breast milk in Asia. Adding conventional enhanced formulas does not add extra points, and points are added only when a certain amount is reached.
2, 37 types of three-stage milk powder added conventional fortified formula content all meet the Chinese national standard.
3, 23 milk powders are rich in choline and , 32 milk powders are rich in taurine , and 19 milk powders are rich in nucleotides , which get extra points (marked as +).
4, 23 milk powders lack one or more conventional fortified formulas (marked as ×). Among them, Nestlé Ruibo Nengen, Nestlé Super Qinengen, Bevita, without any conventional strengthening formula.
Special fortified formula
Summary:
1. Special fortified formula, that is, only part of the milk powder is added with nutrient fortification substances, including: lactoferrin, β-carotene, OPOz2, βz-carotene, OPOz2 Protein, etc. Add special strengthening formula to get extra points.
2, lactoferrin : is a kind of breast milk core immune protein, has antibacterial, antiviral, and regulates the body's immune function.
37 three-stage milk powders, 10 have lactoferrin added. Among them, Royal Mei Su Jiaer and Mead Johnson Lan Zhen added much higher than the others.
3, OPO: It is a structured fat that mimics breast milk lipids, which can optimize the absorption of calcium and fatty acids and help relieve baby constipation. Z2z
37 three-stage milk powder, 12 of which have OPO added. Among them, the amount of OPO caused by Hepu Nuokai is slightly higher.
4, CPP (casein phosphopeptide) : It can promote the absorption and utilization of divalent minerals such as calcium, iron and zinc. Z2z
37 three-stage milk powder, 6 of which have added CPP. Among them, Hyproca's CPP addition amount is higher.
5, 15 models add lutein , 14 models add β-carotene , which helps to protect eyesight and promote eye health.
6. There are 13 milk powders added with probiotics , which can promote the balance of intestinal flora to a certain extent and help babies better digest and absorb.
7, Wyeth Qifu Dajincan, a2 to the beginning, using A2-β casein , which is said to be closer to the protein structure of breast milk.
8, Royal Mei Su Jiaer, Aita Metso Extract, added natural milk fat , can optimize the absorption of calcium and fatty acids, to prevent baby constipation to a certain extent.
9, Wyeth Kaifu Blue Diamond, NuronenPRO version, contains gsMO milk-derived ganglioside , which may help support infant immunity and promote tissue and organ development to some extent.
10, Aptamil Classic, Noyon Classic, Mead Johnson Platinum Core, Mead Johnson Platinum Core Fully Jump, Bevita, Xibao Beixi, does not add any special enhanced formula .
Brand trust
Summary:
1. Brand trust refers to the image that a brand shows to consumers in research and development, product quality control, and integrity, which require long-term accumulation. Brand trust also has a crucial influence on consumers' choice of milk powder. The evaluation of
brand trust is composed of 4 aspects: brand history, whether there has been a safety accident within 3 years, whether it has been randomly inspected and unqualified within 3 years, and whether it has been punished/notified within 3 years. Among the
2 and 37 three-stage milk powders, loves the beauty, Nuotron, Abbott, Wyeth, Mead Johnson, Maxcarat, Xibao, Nestlé, Baby and Me , nine brands with a history of more than 100 years.
3, safety incidents , in the past 3 years (December 2017 to December 2020, the same below), Abbott was recalled twice in Canada due to corruption and bacterial contamination; Nestlé in Chile and Germany There have been incidents of excessive bacteria and excessive mineral content in milk powder; a factory under Hepu Nuokai has an Enterobacter sakazakii contamination risk incident, belongs to the deduction item .
4, sampling , in the past 3 years, xibao has failed sampling inspections in Beijing and Hong Kong, Blue River has a sampling failure, belongs to the deduction item .
5, penalties/notifications: , Mead Johnson, Nestle, Gao Pei , have been notified by the State Municipal Supervision Bureau due to defects in production or management, etc.; a2, Abbott, Mead Johnson , have been punished for illegal advertising; Abbott, Mead Johnson, and Xibao have been notified overseas due to product labeling and packaging errors, and belongs to the deduction item .
(The data above PS only represents historical records, and does not mean that there is a problem with the current brand sales of milk powder.)
general comment
Based on the above analysis, Stupid Dad has integrated the milk source, milk-based ingredients, basic nutrition, enhanced formula, brand trust, etc Indicators, 37 models of China Bank’s version 3 milk powder were carefully scored (full score is 100 points). The former Royal
① United States Su Jia children
② love him Metso extraction
③ Wyeth Kai Fu Daikin tank
④ Wyeth Kai Fu Blue Diamond
⑤ promise Neolink PRO version
: specific scores in the following figure: former
composite score of five columns formula is Among the five, Wyeth Kaifu Big Golden Pot, Wyeth Kaifu Blue Diamond, and Royal Mei Su Jiaer are relatively expensive, around 400 yuan; the price of Aita Metso is more than 300 yuan, and Nuoyou can PRO version The price is about 230 yuan.
Compared with the National Bank version 3 Hengping published by Stupid Dad in the previous two years, some milk powders have added unqualified/notification/recall records due to brands ( Abbott, Mead Johnson, Xibao, Blue River , etc.). Points deducted; some brands' problem records are overdue for 3 years (a2, Nestlé , etc.), no deductions will be given.
Compared with the first paragraph/2 paragraphs of the National Bank version updated this year, Mead Johnson, Abbott and other series have been deducted due to the addition of white sugar and flavor, causing the ranking of the third paragraph to decline.
Bao moms can comprehensively compare the bonus items and precautions of each milk powder, and combine the baby’s own growth and development needs, the baby’s acceptance of milk powder, the family’s economic status and other factors to choose and buy. As long as the baby adapts, it doesn’t need to be too Tangled.
The last thing to remind is , some of the three-stage milk powder has problems such as missing optional ingredients, adding flavor/palm oil/white sugar/maltodextrin .
In fact, babies over 1 year old can get most of the nutrition from their daily meals, so the lack of certain optional ingredients is not a big problem. As for flavors/palm oil/white sugar/maltodextrin, etc., don’t choose if you don’t want your baby to come into contact with it prematurely; if it is contained in milk powder or other foods that your baby has eaten before, and your baby accepts it well, then you can choose; There is no problem with 2nd milk powder.
finally attaches the current price list of 37 three-stage milk powder. The price may vary on different platforms at different times, for your reference only.
Well, the Hengping of the National Bank version 3 milk powder is here. The domestically produced section 3 will also be updated in the near future, so stay tuned!
If you want to find more related articles, or if you have any questions, you are welcome to follow the "Baby Evaluation" WeChat public account (id: baobaopingce) and leave a message in the background. Stupid Dad will answer you separately.
History
1,32 money the National Bank version of a comprehensive evaluation of milk
2,38 domestically produced milk powder comprehensive evaluation
3, he loves the United States and five versions of milk powder comprehensive evaluation
4, 23, United States Su Jia children milk powder comprehensive evaluation
5, 33, Mead Johnson milk powder comprehensive evaluation
6, a2 milk powder comprehensive evaluation
7, 66 milk bottle & pacifier evaluation
8, baby sunscreen evaluation
72 baby rice noodles evaluation11, 13 baby vitamin D evaluation
12, 20 pull-up pants evaluation
.......
for the headline of "Baby Evaluation"; Official account (ID: baobaopingce), enter the corresponding keyword query in the background.
About "baby evaluation", please click "learn more" below to understand. Welcome to the stupid dad .
welcome to pay attention to "baby evaluation". With 7 years of experience in product comparison and testing, we don’t use opportunistic tricks, and use scientific and rational methods to provide reliable consumer advice.
