Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three "Lilac Flower Tie" we can see: one is in the Wuxi Museum, one is

2025/07/0705:40:36 hotcomm 1946

Yang Ningshi (873-954), whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and was active in the Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three th dynasty period.

Yang Ningshi is regarded as an important figure in the history of Chinese calligraphy. The "Four Masters of Song Dynasty" are deeply influenced by him. His representative work " Lilac Flower Tie " is known as the fifth in the world.

Now, there are three "Lilac Tie" we can see:

One piece in Wuxi Museum,

One piece in Lanqianshan Pavilion, Taiwan (storage Taipei Palace Museum ),

One piece in Lanqianshan Pavilion, Taiwan (storage Taipei Palace Museum ),

One piece is missing.

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

"Lilac Flower Tie" Luo Zhenyu's collection of

Why is the last "Ignored" also listed here?

Because Luo Zhenyu collected this "Jiuhua Tie" (hereinafter referred to as Luo Ben) in the late Qing Dynasty, he used Koluo version photocopy to enter it into the "Baijuezhai Cai Celebrity Book".

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three 945, this "Lilac Flower Tie" was lost at the residence in Luo's Northeast, and its whereabouts are still unknown.

But because there have been photocopy before, we can still see its pictures online today.

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

"Lilac Flower Tie" Lan Qianshan Library

"Lilac Flower Tie" (hereinafter referred to as Lan Qianshan Library) of Taiwan Lan Qianshan Library has a collection of seals by Qing Dynasty literati Gao Shiqi . Gao Shiqi once recorded this work in "Jiangcun Suxia Lu".

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

"Jiuhua Tie" collection of Wuxi Museum

"Jiuhua Tie" (hereinafter referred to as the Qing version), also known as the "Qing Mansion Collection", was originally a collection of the Qing royal family.

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

Qianlong's inscription

Because Gao Shiqi had used calligraphy and painting appreciation for Kangxi Emperor, there is a saying:

The collection of the Qing royal family was an orchid version. When Gao Shiqi was appreciating it, he thought that this work was really good, so he took the risk of beheading and dropped a package with the copy. This copy was the Qing version.

Later, Qianlong appreciated this Qing version, so we can see Qianlong's inscriptions in the Qing version.

Although Gao Shiqi is at risk of beheading, people today generally believe that Robben's "Lilac Flower Tie" is the original work.

However, some people say that the one who was replaced by Gao Shiqi from the palace at that time was Robben, and both Langben and Robben were leaked from his house. Below

, let’s take a look at the comparison of these three copybooks line by line.

▍First line

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

In the first line, you can focus on the word "Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three ":

The first line is

First point, the Lanben and Qingben are more of a circle, while the Robben circle has square.

Secondly, looking at the bottom of the song, Lanben and Qingben are more square, while Robben takes the sideways.

▍The second line

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

The second line can be seen ""Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three 1. This is also the different words that can be seen at a glance by Robben:

First of all, when we look at the blank space in the words, the Lanben and Qingben are more regular and average, while the contrast between the sparse and density of Robben is more obvious;

Secondly, when we look at the horizontal fold on the right, Robben's treatment of this stroke is also significantly different, more charming and ostentatious.

▍The third line

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

The third line can be looked at the word "". The left and right are dense, right and right are light.

▍Fourth line

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

The fourth line might as well look at "shy"words:

First of all, from the density of the space in the words, Robben is still denser and the contrast is more distinct;

Secondly, look at the long stroke, Robben is more straighter and more powerful.

▍Fifth line

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

The fifth line has a clear difference. Robben's word "口" is incomplete, while Lanpa and Qingpa are clear.

▍The sixth line

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

The sixth line tells the difference on a seal, Qingben Wei is a seal under the word " Qianqing Palace Treasure Appreciation" which fully explains its origin.

▍Line seventh line

Yang Ningshi, whose courtesy name is Jingdu, was from Huayin County, Huazhou. He was a great calligrapher who lived after the chaos in the late Tang Dynasty and moved during the Five Dynasties. Now, there are three

The seventh line, and the last line, here is the most conspicuous feature of Robben.

Lanben and Qingben have some signatures with the words "condensing style". Although it is not complete, Robben has no.

above is a brief introduction to the three versions of "Lilac Flower Tie"

For more knowledge, please sign up for our Sports Book Course

The teacher will teach you to write "Lilac Flower Tie" in the class

After writing, you will naturally have more knowledge

text | Report autumn salted fish gui

typography | Hu Xiaoxue

hotcomm Category Latest News