The battle between Guan Yu and Lu Bu will be quite different from the perspective of "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and the real history.
1. In the novel, Lu Bu is the number one warrior of the Three Kingdoms. The three brothers Liu Bei, Guan Yu, and Zhang Fei fought together with Lu Bu. After the 80th round, Lu Bu could not stand it and fled. If he fights alone, Lu Bu would have at least hundreds of rounds to defeat Guan Yu.
2. From the real history, Lu Bu's force should be inferior to Guan Yu. Guan Yu defeated Lu Bu within about thirty rounds.
1. The battle
Lu Bu in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is portrayed as "Lu Bu in the People, Red Rabbit in the Horse". Before the Hulao Pass, they fought alone against the Allied Forces of Dong and defeated such fierce generals as Fang Yue, Mu Shun, Wu Anguo, and Gongsun Zan.
later fought against Zhang Fei for fifty rounds. Guan Yu fought Lü Bu in a hurry, and after another thirty rounds, he failed to defeat Lü Bu. Liu Bei stepped forward again to help, and the three brothers surrounded Lu Bu and fought like a lamp. When the battle was not long, Lu Bu couldn't stand it, so Pegasus returned.
If you are talking about fighting alone in front of the battle, you can decide between the male and the male by martial arts and physical ability, in "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms", no general is Lü Bu's opponent. Stronger than Guan Yu, slightly stronger than Zhang Fei (Zhang Fei fights Lv Bu undefeated in 50 rounds alone), and probably will lose after more than a hundred rounds.
2. Historical record comparison
In real history, there is no record of direct fighting between Lu Bu and Guan Yu.
In 198 AD, Lv Bujun and Liu Beijun fought, but Lv Bu did not participate. It was his general Gao Shunzhi who "trapped the camp" as the main force. Zhang Liao led the troops to defeat Liu Beijun and captured Liu Bei's. His wife and daughter forced Liu Bei to turn to Cao Cao.
This can only prove Gaoshun's top commanding ability. Lü Bujun was stronger than Liu Beijun at the time, but it cannot be said how high Lü Bu's martial arts.
1, Lv Bu
said in the history books that "they are arrogant and powerful, and they are called pilots", but there are very few cases of fighting against others.
"Heroes" records: Guo Bang is in the north of the city. After opening the city gate, the generals were slammed and said, "Also, the soldiers will decide the outcome." Bang and Bu Nai fought together alone, Bu Nai stabbed Bang with a spear, and Bai Sui rode forward to rescue Bang, Bang and Bu Sui each had two strikes.
If the above is true, Lu Budan challenged Guo Bang, who was born in the second-rate military commander of the Three Kingdoms, Ma Thief.
Lü Bu has few victories in personal matches, but his losses are relatively high:
"The Book of the Later Han·Dong Zhuo Biography": Zhuo Zi went out and Jian fought between the tombs, and Zhuo lost, but he stationed in the pond and gathered his troops in Shan. Jian entered the Xuanyang gate of Luoyang, hit Lv Bu even more, and went away.
Dong Zhuo personally led troops to fight Sun Jian, but he was hit hard by Sun Jian. He left Lv Bu for cover and moved to Mianchi and Shancheng. Sun Jian launched his army to attack Luoyang and went to battle with Lü Bu. Lü Bu was finally lost and defeated. Sun Jian's army entered Luoyang.
"Three Kingdoms·Wei Shu·Wu Di Ji": Autumn September, Taizu returned to Juancheng. The distribution to Chengshi was broken by Li Jin, a county resident.
In 194 AD, Lu Bu was defeated by Cao Cao and passed by Chengshi City on his way to retreat. Due to insufficient military rations, he planned to enter Chengshi City to collect food. Li Jin led the local people to attack the Lu Bu army. Lu Bu was unwilling to fight and took his remnant and defeated general to seek refuge with Liu Bei in Xuzhou. The above two defeats of
are both the result of the collapse of the army and the low combat power when the army is defeated. However, it is also verified from the side that Lu Bu's martial arts can not be able to reverse the situation, while Guan Yu's record is the opposite. The victory or defeat of the battle!
2, Guan Yu
"Three Kingdoms": Yu sees Liang's cover, rides the horse among the crowd, beheads his head and returns it, and the generals can't be the one, so he solved the white horse siege.
Yuan Shao was the most powerful separatist warlord at the time, and Yan Liang's status as the general of the army added Guan Yu's martial arts legend. There were many generals who were good at cavalry rushing into the formation in later generations, but few of them were able to kill such a high-level commander in the army.
In the Three Kingdoms era, Guan and Zhang were already recognized as "enemies of ten thousand people." The overall evaluation of Guan Yu is higher than that of Zhang Fei. Regarding the sudden formation of generals, Guan Yu had a feat of cutting Yanliang, and Zhang Fei had no similar record.
"Song Book": Andu rode straight in, cut it back, everyone at the time was like Guan Yu's cut Yanliang, not too late. In the next two to three hundred years,
often used Guan Zhang as an example when commenting on their contemporaries. And Guan Yu cuts Yan Liang thisThe feat has been mentioned several times individually, which shows how much the generals at that time respected it.
and "everyone was like Guan Yu's slashing Yanliang, it is not too late", it also shows that this feat is commendable. In fact, if you only consider the value of force, the only military commander who can be so respected in this and future generations is Wu Sheng Guan Yu.
Therefore, comprehensively considered, if Guan Yu and Lu Bu had a single chance in history, Guan Yu could defeat Lu Bu in 30 rounds.
