Hello everyone, this is Jianman Club!
htmlThe "poisonous textbook" incident that became "widely known to the whole people" in May finally came to an end before the start of school in September. Wu Yong , Lu Jingren , etc. were "invited" to remove the illustrations from the textbooks for primary and secondary school students without any benefit transfer. In the design work team, at the same time, 27 people from the People's Education Society were ineffective in compiling teaching materials, and corresponding measures were taken.Correspondingly, the work of redrawing the illustrations of the People's Education Society's primary school mathematics textbooks was finally completed before the start of the school year. Many parents were previously worried that "there will be no textbooks available," but now they can feel relieved. It's just that many people have completely opposite opinions about the new edition's illustrations.
Some people think that the new illustration format is simple and very suitable for primary school students, while others think that the content is not deep enough and is not as good as the ink painting style of many years ago.
Different opinions on the new version of the illustrations
Since the illustration problems appeared in the textbooks, the relevant departments immediately started the work of redrawing the illustrations of the primary school textbooks to ensure that the children can use the brand-new textbooks before the start of school in September. Now there is still some time before the start of school. In about a week, the compilation of the new textbook has been completed, and the cover and illustrations of the new textbook have been unveiled in advance.
's neat pictures and image design that conforms to Chinese aesthetics have refreshed many people's minds, and their eyes that have been poisoned by "drug textbooks" have become brighter again. After
saw the new version of the textbook, many netizens expressed their opinions. Some expressed support for the efficient work and today's painting style, believing that there are still designers in China who "can draw".
Some people also strongly expressed their nostalgia for the previous ink painting style teaching materials in the comment area. They believed that the previous teaching materials had Chinese characteristics in terms of content and painting style, and were truly "Chinese characteristics" suitable for children.
Simple new version VS ink painting style
After the issue of teaching materials was exposed at that time, many netizens actually recommended illustrations by some authors based on today's "characteristics of the times". Many of these works have excellent painting styles, which are not only vivid and interesting, but also It brings a lot of Chinese elements and has been sought after by many people for a while.
And judging from the feedback from netizens, many people are very supportive of the selection of these paintings into the teaching materials. However, judging from the final results, these more distinctive illustrations were not selected in the end.
After this incident, what impressed most people the most was the comparison between the old ink painting style teaching materials and today's new teaching materials, which made them feel nostalgic and outstanding. For many people, it was a microcosm of an era, the "best student era". Compared with today's rapidly developing society, the textbooks at that time were more "characteristic".
However, some netizens expressed their support for the new version of the textbook. One of the more objective points is that the characters in the new version of the textbook are all kind and lovely primary school students, which is a style we are familiar with.
It also serves as a supplementary guide to the content to be learned. For teaching materials, illustrations should not be dominant . In fact, some people mentioned this when the problematic textbooks appeared. The illustrations themselves are only to increase children's understanding of the textbooks and to add a certain degree of interest. They should not be regarded as the "main theme".
officials also explained the redrawing process of the illustrations. Both the creative team and the entire process have been strictly controlled. The most important thing is to let the children use appropriate teaching materials before the start of school.
"Chinese Characteristics" should not be rushed
It is undeniable that the former ink painting style teaching materials did have important significance to many people, and they also had a special status in artistic style. Nowadays, many people miss those textbooks and the “Chinese characteristics” in them.
But for the newly redrawn version of the textbook, the most important thing is to make it simple first and reduce the impact of illustrations on the textbook. Only by starting with simplicity can we get a good start.
Moreover, there are also problems in the content of some teaching materials and teaching aids, which need to be reviewed and corrected one by one.
Whether it is to give full play to Chinese characteristics or build cultural confidence, being too eager is not necessarily a good thing. Now that the official has launched a comprehensive "reform" mode, it will definitely get better and better in the future!
