Employee who calls himself a hospital staff member, does the matter "disappear" as soon as it is exposed?
For a while, Yinfeng Hospital located in Lecheng, Boao became the focus of public opinion.
But Yinfeng Hospital is much "low-key" than imagined. It is just a three-story western-style building with milky white and red. The golden sign of "Boao Yinfeng Health and Care International Hospital" (i.e. Yinfeng Hospital) is hung at the door.
April 28, Yinfeng Hospital Exterior Location
If a newcomer cannot see this line of words, it is probably difficult for him to think that this is a hospital.
However, this hospital, which only obtained a practice license in March last year, was questioned that it has been "sponsored" customers to receive the nine-valent HPV vaccine since the end of 2017. After the fake vaccine was exposed, Wang Lina, Zhang Sanfeng and others who claimed to be hospital staff disappeared...
As the interview deepened, things became more and more confusing.
On the one hand, Wang Lina, Zhang Sanfeng and others were not afraid to receive vaccinated guests from all over the country in the hospital, and also used hospital assets such as departments and office computers; on the other hand, Yinfeng Hospital firmly cut off the relationship between the vaccine incident and the hospital, denied that Wang, Zhang and others were hospital staff, and emphasized that they had no knowledge of their behavior in the hospital.
Not only that, the hospital consultant even comforted the victim: "Fake vaccine is just normal saline and has no harm to the body..."
Victim: Vaccine was vaccinated by unqualified personnel
At the end of 2017, Chen Hong and his colleagues came to Boao Town to study and accidentally learned about the Boao Lecheng International Medical Tourism Pilot Zone.
Out of curiosity, the group came to the pilot area to visit. When passing by the entrance of Yinfeng Hospital, Wang Lina, who claimed to be the training director of Yinfeng Hospital, welcomed Chen Hong and her colleagues into the hospital. In the first floor exhibition hall (the hospital has closed the exhibition hall), Wang Lina introduced the hospital business displayed in the hall.
Introduction to Wang Lina provided by the victim
First introduced the hospital's neural stem cell transplant business. Wang Lina introduced at the time:
"Young girls in their 20s can store their stem cells. When they are injected into their bodies in their 40s, they can stay young forever."
Not only that, Wang Lina also introduced the hospital's "most powerful" frozen age project to them, saying that the project Yinfeng Hospital is the first case in China.
After listening to the introduction, a female colleague asked Wang Lina whether the hospital could receive the nine-valent HPV vaccine, but she did not reply on the spot.
After a while, Wang Lina said that the hospital had channels to get the nine-valent vaccine, and asked, "How many people do you need to get it?" You should know that the nine-valent HPV vaccine was not yet available in the mainland at that time, and many people could only go to Hong Kong for vaccination.
At that time, Chen Hong was told that the three shots received were Korean vaccines, and the package also gave away a physical examination for HPV screening. She received the samples in the department of Yinfeng Hospital and received her first shot on April 3.
At the beginning, Chen Hong did not care about the name of the recipient, nor did he find clues in Wang Lina and others. But later, she found that the recipient was actually the Pingdu Chengxi Gas Station in Qingdao City, not Yinfeng Hospital.
Credit card consumption record provided by Chen Hong
Due to the tense situation in China and South Korea, the drug was seized by customs, and the second shot may be in short supply and it is impossible to get the injection in time. However, the US version of the nine-valent vaccine with "reliable" channels can be issued from the United States the next morning, with only 20 places.
On March 17, 2018, Wang Lina issued a notice in the vaccine group to
Whether Chen Hong was vaccinated was a vaccine from other channels after being detained, and there is no way to know.
According to Chen Hong, after the first dose was received, Wang Lina suddenly said in the group in mid-May that the hospital carried out excellent services and that the door-to-door vaccination can be arranged starting from early June, and everyone will be asked to send her the positioning, and she will arrange it one by one.
Chen Hong's second shot was given by Zhang Sanfeng and a female employee, and the third shot was given by Wang Lina and Zhang Sanfeng. It is worth mentioning that Wang Lina herself does not have a doctor's qualification certificate at all, but she comes to the door to vaccinate consumers.
The HPV nine-valent vaccine provided by the victims
At first, the incident of home vaccination did not arouse everyone's suspicion.
Until early March 2019, the Suzhou police in Jiangsu contacted group members who had been vaccinated and informed that the vaccines they were injected were fake vaccines. The vaccines were divided into multiple batches, some were illegally smuggled, and some were produced by a factory in Siping, Jilin.
news is like a bolt from the blue. Everyone who has been vaccinated at Wang Lina was confused: Why is the promised nine-valent HPV vaccine a fake?
Some victims bluntly said that they had spent a high price to get vaccinated to prevent diseases, but now they are fear and anxiety and physical and mental exhaustion of injecting unknown liquids into the body.
After receiving the police notice, the victims immediately contacted Wang Lina, but Wang Lina said she was a victim. She was just an employee of the Medical Beauty Center department established by Qingdao Meibomen Group Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as Qingdao Meibomen) and Yinfeng Hospital. She resigned before the New Year. At present, the owner of Qingdao Meibomen, Wang Xiaodan, has been controlled by the police.
The hospital involved: It is still in business. Not only has the vaccines that have been given are fake, but even Wang Lina, who calls herself the hospital training director, "disappears", and the victims can only "group" to seek help from the regulatory authorities.
Recently, after media intervention, Yinfeng Hospital's suspected vaccination of fake nine-valent HPV vaccine was fermented.
Hainan Provincial Health Commission intervened in the investigation as early as March 24 after receiving a complaint from the leader’s message board. This incident involved 38 nine-valent HPV vaccines, and all of them were sold and vaccinated by Yinfeng Hospital involved.
At the same time, Director Chen also sent a "Notice on Investigation on the Suspicion of Illegal Vaccination of Nine-valent Cervical Cancer Vaccination to Boao Yinfeng Health International Hospital."
notice stated that the Health Commission issued the "Previous Notice of Administrative Penalty" on April 18, 2019, imposing a fine of 8,000 yuan on Yinfeng Hospital and revoking administrative penalties such as the "Medical Institution Practice License".
, but the victims expressed difficulty in accepting the 8,000 yuan fine, "This fine is not even the cost of the vaccine paid by one person at that time." Moreover, until now, Yinfeng Hospital has not come forward to understand the situation, follow-up processing or provide a compensation plan. A victim told reporters that she had come to the hospital to negotiate, but was sent by the hospital for various reasons.
After some efforts, the reporter successfully entered Yinfeng Hospital. Follow the escalator to the second floor, there was no one in the consultation desk facing the stairs. The entire row of departments on the right was empty, with only a few instruments left.
In the lounge on the left, a promotional poster of "the first 'freezer' project implementer in China" was hung in the most conspicuous place, and next to it was a promotional roll-up introduction of "Famous Neurosurgery Expert in my country".
Promotional poster of the "Frozen Man" project hanging in the lounge on the second floor of Yinfeng Hospital
There are still people entering and leaving the department behind the lounge. After the reporter expressed his willingness to interview, he was told to go to the lounge to wait. While waiting, the three ladies walked into the lounge with cotton swabs in their hands and pressed their arms.
reporter asked them if they were vaccinated, and one of the ladies replied: "What vaccine is it? We drew blood..." But they were quickly interrupted by another ladies, hinting not to talk too much. It is obvious that Yinfeng Hospital is still carrying out business activities.
The Health Commission only issued a "Previous Notice of Administrative Penalty", saying that the hospital's "Medical Institution Practice License" would be revoked, which only played a notification role, unlike the "Administrative Penalty Decision". After receiving the prior notice, the hospital has the right to conduct administrative reconsideration, so the hospital is currently conducting business normally.
Hospital Legal Affairs: Denied
for illegal vaccination incidents one after another, but the hospital’s rhetoric made it difficult for the victims to convince. They told reporters that judging from the payment and vaccine injection processes, the whole thing cannot have nothing to do with the hospital.
Yinfeng Hospital legal lawyer Wang and the general manager assistant briefly sorted out the incident they knew and presented two agreements to reporters, saying:
In November 2017, Yinfeng Hospital signed a strategic cooperation agreement with Qingdao Meibomen to cooperate in medical beauty. "Because the hospital-related medical license had not been approved at that time, there was no actual formal cooperation, it was just an intention of cooperation between the two parties."
The victims do not agree with this statement.
Yinfeng Hospital only obtained a medical license in March 2018, but two months ago, a victim received the first shot of the vaccine in the hospital. This is very different from the statement that the hospital is "only a cooperation intention". If it is only intentional cooperation, why can Wang Lina and others use hospital departments for vaccination?
According to Wang Lina above, she was previously an employee of the Medical Beauty Center Department established by Qingdao Meibomen and Yinfeng Hospital.
"Later we discovered that Qingdao Meibomen had such an act of secretly vaccinating customers, and the cooperation agreement was terminated in July and August 2018." Lawyer Wang, the legal lawyer, said.
In a "Clarification Letter" obtained by the reporter, Yinfeng Hospital directly cut off its relationship with Qingdao Meibomen and this vaccine incident.
Regarding Wang Lina and Zhang Sanfeng's previous identities, both the legal affairs and general manager assistant of Yinfeng Hospital said that the two are not employees of the hospital and the hospital has not signed a labor contract or purchased social security with them.
When the reporter showed the hospital's legal affairs a photo of Zhang Sanfeng injecting a victim's vaccine, the legal affairs said that the photos were not enough to prove that they were employees of Yinfeng Hospital. According to the current situation, the two should be employees of Meibomen, Qingdao.
The victims did not "buy" the above statement.
According to the descriptions of multiple victims, before the first shot of the vaccine was injected, Wang Lina led everyone to Yinfeng Hospital to pay the fee, and a doctor named Zhang Sanfeng injected them. Before the vaccination, cervical cancer screening was also taken in the department on the second floor of Yinfeng Hospital. Both Zhang and Wang were wearing white coats with the name of Yinfeng Hospital printed on their chests with their position name in the hospital.
A series of actions were carried out in the department of Yinfeng Hospital in broad daylight. "How could the hospital not know their existence?" Some victim questioned.
The reporter also showed the hospital's legal affairs a vaccine injection record card provided by the victim with the words "Boao Yinfeng Health Care International Hospital Medical Cosmetic Center" and a receipt with the "Boao Yinfeng Health Care International Hospital Medical Cosmetic Center Special Seal" stamped.
receipt shows that the receipt is 9,000 yuan, the note is a nine-valent cervical cancer vaccine, and the recipient is Li Xiaojuan.
The receipt document provided by the victim
, but the legal department said that the injection record card and the official seal of the receipt can be faked. Not only that, Yinfeng Hospital also had objections to the situation notice issued by the Hainan Health Commission.
notice stated that in January 2018, Yinfeng Hospital was suspected of illegally carrying out the vaccination business of nine-valent cervical cancer vaccine (nine-valent HPV vaccine). The total number of vaccinated people was 38 (of which 37 were paid customers, and the other one was Wang, who did not charge for internal benefits of the company, and the rest were charged 9,000 yuan per person).
The hospital's legal affairs denied again: "I can say with certainty that we do not exist in this situation. As for how the Health Commission verified such results, we don't know."
But the victim Xiaowen told reporters that the above-mentioned internal employees Wang or Wang Lina, when they were vaccinated with the second vaccine in the Yinfeng Hospital clinic in April 2018, when they were vaccinated with the second vaccine in the Yinfeng Hospital clinic, they saw Zhang Sanfeng vaccinating Wang Lina with the nine-valent HPV vaccine.
Hospital consultant: Fake vaccine or saline
After the Hainan Provincial Health Commission issued the notice, the local regulatory authorities have taken action.
At around 3 pm on April 28, during the reporter's interview with the hospital's legal affairs and assistant to the general manager, Qionghai Municipal Drug Administration settled in Yinfeng Hospital to investigate the relevant situation. Two people who claimed to be hospital consultants were welcomed in the conference room.
At the same time, some victims also came to the hospital, hoping to obtain solutions through communication. After receiving the Municipal Drug Administration, two hospital consultants entered the lounge to receive reporters and several victims.
A victim said that no matter what cooperation the hospital has with Qingdao Meibomen, Wang Lina and others were called Yinfeng Hospital and were wearing the hospital's clothes. "We are also here for Yinfeng Hospital to get vaccinated. I hope the hospital will respond positively to the fake vaccine incident and give a solution."
A hospital consultant who did not want to be named responded that Yinfeng Hospital is also waiting for Suzhou police to characterize the incident:
If the victim was vaccinated through Qingdao Meibomen, and the hospital cooperated with Qingdao Meibomen, then the Suzhou police will definitely have a conclusion after the investigation, which link in the entire case is involved in the hospital. The boss of Qingdao Meibomen is now controlled by the police and will have a record of confessions for the whole process.
When many victims expressed concern about the harm of fake vaccine injection, the consultant bluntly stated that the hospital learned through some channels that "fake vaccines are just normal saline and have no harm to the body."
But this cannot calm the victims' concerns - "Because the three shots were not given at the same time period, and they were not the same batch of vaccines, so we have no way to know what they were injected." Some victims said.
Another victim said that when the fake vaccine incident was just exposed, Wang Lina came to Sanya with several "Conciliation Agreement" and "Text of Understanding" to find several victims in order to play a role in reducing sentences in court, but no one signed the settlement.
In response to this, the hospital consultant proposed a solution, requiring the victims to send representatives, and the hospital contacted the government and the police to see if the vaccine can be obtained. According to him, Suzhou police have sealed many vaccines this time, and the police will test these vaccines. You can understand what the vaccine is and whether it is harmful to the body.
He also said that the entire case is expected to be completed around May 9 and 10, and will be transferred to the procuratorate afterwards, and the files of the entire case will be disclosed. Now, both the regulatory authorities and the hospital are waiting for the results of the investigation by the public security system.
But one victim mentioned a detail to reporters that after the fake vaccine incident was exposed, she came to the hospital with other victims, and the assistant general manager and a woman of the hospital received everyone.
At that time, the assistant to the general manager said that the hospital learned about the fake vaccine incident last year, so it terminated its cooperation with Qingdao Meibomen. "Even though he knew that the victim had received a fake vaccine, the hospital did not make any statement at the time and did not notify the victim of the vaccine injected with any problems," the victim said.
At present, Jiangsu police have not made a formal response to the above incident. However, after investigation, the Hainan Provincial regulatory authorities have determined that Yinfeng Hospital is suspected of illegal activities.
htmlOn April 29, the Hainan Provincial Health Commission, Hainan Provincial Market Supervision Administration, Hainan Provincial Drug Administration, and Hainan Provincial Public Security Department jointly issued the latest report on the investigation and handling of Yinfeng Hospital suspected of illegal vaccination of nine-valent cervical cancer vaccine.notice stated that Yinfeng Hospital illegally carried out nine-valent cervical cancer vaccination without obtaining vaccination qualifications, and illegally lends it to departments for external cooperation, disrupting the order of the medical market. On April 18, the local health department focused on revoking the "Medical Institution Practice License", confiscated more than 200,000 yuan of illegal gains and imposed a fine of 8,000 yuan. It is also said that if it is found out in the future that Yinfeng Hospital uses fake vaccines, it will be punished with a maximum penalty in accordance with the Drug Administration Law.
On the afternoon of April 29, the reporter came to Yinfeng Hospital again and found that the gate of the hospital had been sealed by the Qionghai Municipal Health Commission.
Yinfeng Hospital was sealed
(Chen Hong and Xiaowen are both pseudonyms in the article)
