Shaanxi TV News announced the investigation results
html On December 9, a video on the Internet attracted widespread attention. The video shows an accident between a white car and a motorcycle on the Xi'an Ring Expressway, causing the motorcycle to overturn. After the video was released, netizens questioned that the car was suspected of deliberately not falling on the right side of a normally moving motorcycle.
The reporter learned from the Xi'an Public Security Highway Traffic Police Brigade that the traffic police launched an investigation into the matter on December 9th, through the investigation of the relevant driving recorder and both parties. The highway traffic police found out that the incident occurred at the Hechizhai section of the Xi'an Ring Expressway. There was no conflict, grudge, or racing between the two parties before the accident. There was no subjective intention in the accident. It was caused by the car driver's illegal overtaking and poor observation. He bears full responsibility for the accident.
After the accident, the car driver stopped the car according to the procedure, placed safety signs, asked the injured and called the police. For illegal overtaking, the traffic police imposed a fine of 200 yuan on private car owners. In the accident, the motorcycle driver suffered partial body abrasions and strained ligaments. According to the investigation, the motorcycle driver entered the expressway from the Weiqu Toll Station of the Baomao Expressway. The toll station did not have a special sign for cars, so the motorcycle could drive normally. However, if you violate the law by taking the emergency lane while riding, you will be punished with 6 points deducted and a fine of 200 yuan. #Xi'an high-speed accident Mercedes-Benz driver bears full responsibility
Some questions
As a media, we know that objectivity and impartiality are the minimum professional qualities, and we will not violate this code just because it is a motorcycle media. This account has also angrily criticized those who do not abide by traffic rules and engage in speed driving and bombing the streets. But there are three questions about the result of punishment:
1. There was no conflict, grudge, racing, etc. between the two parties before the accident. There was no subjective intention in the accident. Is the logic of
tenable? Someone kicked a trash can on the road. So, it can be inferred that the trash can must have offended this person before, right?
2. There was no subjective intention in the accident, and it was caused by the driver of the car illegally overtaking and not observing carefully.
From the long distance before the Mercedes-Benz car overtook, until it hit the motorcycle, there was no obstruction or any blind spot in the line of sight between the two cars. A person is walking on the road and a telephone pole appears in front of him. What is the probability of hitting it due to poor observation?
3. According to Article 47 of " Implementation Regulations of the Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China ": "The vehicle behind shall overtake from the left side of the vehicle in front after confirming that there is a sufficient safe distance, and after necessary distance from the vehicle being overtaken, After a safe distance, turn on the right turn signal and drive back to the original lane. "[Fine standard basis] Article 90 of the "Road Traffic Safety Law of the People's Republic of China": "Motor vehicle drivers violate road traffic safety laws and regulations on roads. Anyone who violates the general regulations shall be given a warning or a fine of not less than 20 yuan but not more than 200 yuan. If otherwise provided in this law, the penalty shall be in accordance with the provisions. "[Basic of points deduction standard] Attachment to "Regulations on Application and Use of Motor Vehicle Driving License ". 3. Item 8 of Article 3 of "Scores for Road Traffic Safety Violations": "If a motor vehicle driver commits one of the following illegal acts, he will be deducted 3 points at a time: (8) Failure to overtake as required;"
Then, we Assuming that the Mercedes-Benz did not have any intentional intention and forcibly overtook from the right when it was not qualified to overtake, causing an accident, would it really not deduct a single point?
Netizen comments
Sometimes I want to talk at length, but at this time I feel that any language is pale and powerless. Since most netizens’ comments are quite excited and cannot be displayed due to platform rules, the following are excerpts from a few relatively rational comments:
1. Someone once said: A car is a mobile murder weapon in a certain aspect.The number of deaths caused by traffic accidents in a year is comparable to the number of casualties in and in World War II. Compared with motorcycles, who should be banned?
2. With this penalty case! Will there be more and more people like this deliberately driving off motorcycles in the future?
3. We know they are lying, they know they are lying, they know we know they are lying, we also know they know we know they are lying, but they still lie.
