text丨No. 2 explorer
Edit丨No. 2 explorer
As one of the four great classics, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", I think everyone should be familiar with it.
When we were young, in addition to Zhuge Liang , also had the most "fans" of Guan Yu . always believed that Zhuge Liang was wise in the world and Guan Yu had high martial arts.
And in the first chapter, the author Luo Guanzhong only uses these 30 words to describe Guan Yu's image:
The body is nine feet long and the beard is two feet long; the face is like a heavy date, and the lips are like grease; Danfeng Eyes , lying silkworm eyebrows: dignified and majestic.
In the film and television drama, there are many characters who play Guan Yu, some of them are funny and some are domineering. Who do you think is the most classic actors of Guan Yu?
No. 10: Chen He ( Love Apartment Extra)
Chen He became a household name with a movie "Love Apartment".
And his role as Guan Yu is also an extra scene in this drama.
He was wearing a green armor and stood there without anger.
I believe 80% of people will say: It’s really similar!
looks really unmatched, but as soon as he opens his mouth, the filter of "Jun Erye" will be broken.
No matter how similar the appearance looks, he is still the same " Zeng Xiaoxian " inside, with a strong comedy color.
The later stage of "June Guan" was staged such a funny scene as eating instant noodles.
Although this sitcom can make people smile, for most viewers, it will still feel uncomfortable if the classics in their hearts are spoofed like this.
So, for those who like the original work, Chen He's version of Guan Yu can only be ranked last.
ninth place Fang Lishen ( Yueguang Treasure Box )
Maybe many people are not familiar with the name Fang Lishen, but those who listen to Cantonese songs will probably have heard of his works.
In the early days, he was a member of the Hong Kong swimming team. Later, because of his handsome appearance and good figure, he was discovered and entered the entertainment industry to develop.
In the movie "Yue Guang Treasure Box" filmed by many big names such as Zheng Zhongji, Sun Li, , Athena Chu , , , , , , , "Guan Yu" played by Fang Lishen is surprising.
Although Fang Lishen’s handsomeness cannot be denied, the role of “Guan Yu” he played is still a bit meaningless.
And this movie itself is mainly nonsense and funny, and the scene of various characters being spoofed in it is still vivid in everyone's mind.
Even "June Guan" is no exception.
Who would have thought that after " Martial Saint " put down his big knife and took off his armor, he would have the hilarious side of "sneaking reading" "Spring and Autumn"?
Of course, in the heart of the "original party", Guan Yu is still quite unrecognized.
No. 8 Han Geng (True Three Kingdoms Unparalleled)
Han Geng was the first artist to develop in South Korea and the first Chinese idol in the history of the Korean circle.
was invited to participate in the singing of " Beijing Welcome You " the second year after returning to China, which was evident at that time.
Like many artists who entered the film and television industry after returning to China, he also participated in the shooting of many movies as an actor.
In most people's impression, most of the movies made by this handsome idol are romantic love dramas.
You may not have imagined that he actually played the majestic Guan Yu.
is just as everyone imagines. Idols are idols after all.
If we look at the game perspective, the restoredness of Guan Yu in "The True Three Kingdoms" is still very high.
But if you look at it from the perspective of "Three Kingdoms", it is really hard to describe.
Han Geng is too thin in the movie, and his figure is not tall enough and his image in the book is too different.
Some people even joked: Guan Yu is nine feet tall, while Han Geng is probably only seven feet tall.
Another thing that makes people feel very distorted is his eyebrows. In the original work, the long eyebrows that fall into the temples become a "caterpillar" in the movie.
greatly reduced Guan Yu's image. I have to wonder if the makeup artist is "lazy"? Guan Yu's image like
really makes people unable to help but give him a "bad review". Many people called Han Geng "destroy the classic" after Supreme Treasure .
No. 7 Ng Mengda (The Deer and the Cauldron)
Ng Mengda, the "No. 1 Green Leaf in Hong Kong", I believe everyone knows it, right?
He and Stephen Chow starred in one classic after another, which is an indelible memory in the hearts of a generation.
He also had Guan Yu's appearance in "The Deer and the Cauldron" co-starring with Stephen Chow.
In order to assassinate Obai in the play, he dressed himself up as the statue of Guan Yu placed on the stage.
I have to say that the moment he appeared, it was hard to tell whether it was a real person or a god.
He wore Peking Opera phoenix crown on his head, his face was like a date, and he held Qinglong Yanyue Knife in his hand, and his majestic look was like "Jun Erye" himself.
But the next second I opened my eyes and immediately swept away the previous majestic image.
Although "Uncle Da"'s image in the play is still mainly funny, this majestic appearance still kills Chen He, Han Geng and others in seconds.
Relatively speaking, this version of Guan Yu can be regarded as a classic of the generation.
It’s a pity that “Uncle Da” is a good actor who everyone praises cannot withstand the invasion of “disease” and left us early.
, who has created so many classics, will definitely be famous for his film history and will always live in our hearts.
No. 6 Basenzabu (Red Cliff)
Basenzabu The actor may not know many people, but he is a complete "old actor".
His appearance is very rough and suitable for this kind of heroic figure.
has been selected by the director to play the role of "Genghis Khan" many times, so he was awarded the title of "Genghis Khan Professional" .
It is precisely the successful portrayal of so many heroes that the director of "Red Cliff" John Woo finalized his casting of Guan Yu.
However, after the movie was released, people of found that this was a bit far from their imagination ", the second brother, ".
Compared with Guan Yu who was nine feet tall, with a date-like face, majestic and even a little conceited, his face became more honest and loyal, and lacked some of Guan Yu's own pride.
However, compared with Han Geng's Guan Yu, the Basenzabu version of Guan Yu is still quite successful.
In addition, the entire movie also includes exciting performances from big names such as Tony Leung and , Lin Chi-ling and . No matter from which perspective, it is a visual feast for the audience.
No. 5 Dillon (Seeing Dragons of the Three Kingdoms)
I believe everyone knows the status of "Shaw Group" in Hong Kong film and television companies back then.
, and Dillon's status in Shaw Brothers is a well-known "living signboard". With him, he has a box office guarantee.
is not only handsome, but also a master with unique skills and an orthodox descendant of Wing Chun.
When playing a hero, he is simply a true performer. Whether in or outside the play, his integrity is recognized in the circle.
However, this is the Di Long version of Guan Yu who started the "second spring of career" by playing a hero, but is called Guan Yu, who is "the most unlike Guan Yu" by .
In fact, he really can't blame him for this matter. After all, he was over fifty years old when he played Guan Yu at that time.
Dielong, who could not stop the baptism of time, gained a little fat figure, which made Guan Yu's face look like a fat man of 200 pounds.
plus the stylist of this crew is a bit awkward, reduces Guan Yu's most iconic beard with a "beard two feet long" to less and shorter.
Fortunately, Di Long's acting skills are excellent enough, so he saved the image of Guan Yu, who has a flawed look.
Therefore, this version of Guan Yu has also been well received by the audience.
Some people may complain that the stylist is not serious enough to restore the character, but in fact, Guan Yu's stylist below is even more outrageous.
fourth place Donnie Yen (Guan Yunchang)
When it comes to Donnie Yen, it should be known to everyone.
He was born into a martial arts family and was respected by a group of martial artists in the Hong Kong circle as "Dan Ye".
His martial arts scenes are simply unspeakable. In the movie circle, he is the most famous except for Jackie Chan and Jet Li .
I remember that such a capable actor should be no problem for playing Guan Yu, but I didn’t expect that the results of this movie are really hard to describe.
Even he himself commented that this movie is a bad movie.
In terms of styling, Donnie Yen is limited by his height and cannot show Guan Yu's majestic appearance as he is nine feet tall.
is not only a flaw of the actor himself, but also a stylist who directly lost Guan Yu's iconic beard . Not only that, the setting of a face as color as a date is also completely gone.
In the plot, the many fighting scenes set by are all in the field of fighting, , and Guan Yu has almost no manifestation on horseback fighting for thousands of miles.
What's even more outrageous is that He actually was forced to surrender to Cao Cao as the main line, has no national justice or chivalrous courage.
plot disrespects the original work at all, not to mention that Donnie Yen, who plays Guan Yu, says that he has never read the original work at all and does not understand what the real Guan Yu looks like.
So its failure becomes inevitable. Donnie Yen also took the blame for the movie.
Therefore, the adaptation of classic works should be based on respect for the original works.
instead of using an irrelevant plot to get the popularity of the classic name.
Third place Li Tianye (Martial God Zhao Zilong)
Li Tianye has been working in the film and television industry for many years, and there may be many people who don’t know him.
If you have watched " Antique Bureau Zhongji ", you must know the character Fang Zhen.
That's right, he is Li Tianye.
I believe many people have watched "The God of Martial Arts Zhao Zilong", where Li Tianye played the role of Guan Yu.
Although the whole drama revolves around the protagonist of Zhao Yun and , the performance of the character Guan Yu in the drama is also eye-catching.
It’s a pity that the rhythm of the whole drama is so tight that Guan Yu doesn’t have many scenes, and most of them are posing in a pose. Several scenes after
have been reused.
Although there are not many scenes, his Guan Yu style is still very restored to the characters in the book compared to other actors who play Guan Yu.
He has done all these things, such as being tall and being arrogant if he is covered with grease with his lips.
The second place Yu Rongguang (New Three Kingdoms)
Many martial arts actors are now shining in film and television dramas, and stars such as Jet Li and Donnie Yen are also household names.
Yu Rongguang's acting skills and skills are not weaker than them at all, but they are often forgotten because of their low-keyness.
has been working diligently for many years since his debut, and is a low-key person. He has starred in more than 100 films and TV series, and is known as the number one "strong guy in the mainland".
His role as Guan Yu in "The New Three Kingdoms" is a classic in the hearts of many people.
As a Peking Opera martial artist, he is more than one step higher than others in his understanding and shaping of Guan Yu.
fully integrates some movements in Peking Opera (such as stroking beards) into film and television, and portrays the characters closer to the original work and more vividly.
I wonder if you have noticed that He often "squinted his eyes" when he played Guan Yu.
I don’t know whether this action is intended to fit the character’s intentional or unintentional performance, but it left a deep impression on people.
Some people can’t help but joke: is the legendary “single-slit eye”?
is teasing, and also indirectly illustrates the audience's attention and recognition of Guan Yu's image.
So, he is ranked second, no one should have any objections, right?
The first Lu Shuming (94 version of the Three Kingdoms)
The existence of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" must be indispensable in the most classic films and TV series of that year.
. Among the multiple versions of the Three Kingdoms, the 94 version is undoubtedly a classic among the classics.
Naturally, Guan Yu played by Teacher Lu Shuming has also become the most classic character among all Guan Yu.
As one of the iconic characters in "The Old Three Kingdoms", the Guan Yu he portrayed in is undoubtedly the closest to Guan Yu in everyone's mind.
Like Yu Rongguang, he has been in contact with Peking Opera since he was a child and has a deep understanding of the character Guan Yu.
In terms of style, he is exactly in line with the description in the book, and he usually closes his eyes slightly like Yu Rongguang.
When the critical moment comes, opened his eyes, his eyes were full of murderous aura, interpreting Guan Yu's domineering aura to the fullest.
so that people nowadays, when they think of Guan Yu, his figure appears in their minds. in our hearts, he is the only Guan Yu.
It’s a pity that this old actor had left us a few days ago.
Since he left, there is no longer any connection to Yu in the world.
Conclusion
It can be seen that if you want to successfully play Guan Yu, you must have good looks, temperament and acting skills to be online to be deeply rooted in people's hearts. These actors above
and have their own advantages and advantages. So which Guan Yu do you think is the most classic?
