*This article is original
milk from [ donuts family education ]. Have you drunk the right one?
There are many types of milk in supermarkets and the brands are diverse. Moms are so confused, right? Which one is more cost-effective? Is the most expensive one the best?
Today, donuts will take you to Carrefour. We will buy all the milk we can buy, and compare it horizontally. When the time comes, mothers will know who will be longer and who will be shorter! This time we are divided into two categories: fresh milk and fermented yogurt. Today we will first compare fresh milk!
First popularize a concept.
step1. Fresh milk ≠ Pure milk
So for children to drink, donuts recommended fresh milk , which is more nutritious and has a better taste! The difference in appearance of
is as follows:
This sample was purchased from Shanghai Jinqiao Carrefour. To be fair, we only selected the most basic fresh milk of , not including skim milk , not including lactose-free milk , not including low-fat milk .
So, this time, Quanquan only conducts multi-dimensional horizontal comparisons of the fresh milk sold in Carrefour supermarkets! When paying the bill, the revenue manager will also collapse!
First talk about your feelings. The fresh milk area is basically dominated by local milk in Jiangsu, Zhejiang and Shanghai. The Mengniu , Yili , Wandashan and so on in the fresh milk area, basically has no market share. Our own home has always been drinking Guangming Youbi. Guangming Suixin orders are delivered to home every morning, and drink the freshest ones. I feel that the cost-effectiveness is quite high. Let's see what the data is!
The milk delivery model should be a regional advantage of Guangming. It turns out that when I was in the Northeast, the local "Wanjiabao" also had this model. I personally like it very much. It was very similar to when I was a child, my mother opened the door to get milk every morning. At that time, it was bottled. When I took it back, I poured it into a special pot and placed it on the stove to boil it to kill sterilization.
The milk at that time did not have such high-end sterilization technology as today, and the shelf life was basically only half a day. A bowl of milk, a fried dough stick, a wonderful morning!
get back to the topic. There are 7 varieties of regular fresh milk in the freezer above. I bought all of them! There are seven varieties in total, as follows:
From the outside, I prefer "Zhiyou" and "Qiandao Lake Ranch". Because it has a screw cap, it is not easy to spill if it can't be finished in one breath. It will not cause bacteria to go into the cracks in the refrigerator. I don't understand why other families don't take this approach? Especially "Guangming Fresh Milk" and "Yoube", which are also under Guangming, can independent operation between sub-brands also learn from each other's strengths and weaknesses, right?
has said Guangming several times, and I seriously declare that this article is not a Guangming soft advertisement! Guangming didn't give a penny!
step3. Cheers to milk, the evaluation officially begins!
We start from three aspects: 1) product information; 2) nutritional components; 3) sensory evaluation . The comparison between the first two is based on data list, and the last item is completely tested by the professional level of the great masters of donuts. They are always subjective, welcome to take a look!
Part 1: List of information about the seven brands of whole-fat fresh milk products:
Due to limited experimental funds, try to choose a small bottle of donuts when purchasing!
is quite impressive. Except for "Asakura Vipshop" which is a northern brand, the others are from Jiangsu, Zhejiang and Shanghai. It can be seen that the fresh milk market has geographical advantages. Due to the cold chain transportation cost of , it is difficult for fresh milk from far-reaching areas to enter the local market!
Some imported stores can also see some fresh milk from Europe, America and Australia. The shelf life is from the "7 days" of packaging and spraying abroad, and it has been artificially modified to "30 days". This is reported by CCTV-2 in the morning news. This is a common violation of the rules. , so if you buy foreign milk, you would rather buy room temperature milk than fresh milk.
Another highlight is the price of the column chart ! The positions in the highest are "Bright Zhiyou" and "Asakura Vipshop" .
"Guangming Zhiyou"'s brand positioning is high-end milk. According to internal employees of Guangming, Zhiyou's milk source is from Guangming's own farm. France imported low-temperature membrane filtration and sterilization technology. Because of the low temperature, it retains more nutrition. It is probably expensive here!
Another "Asakura Vipshop", forgive Donut for being ignorant, never seen it before. It doesn't matter, let's ask Google ! (Du Niang has a bad reputation recently, so just climb over the wall.)
The relevant news found on Google is: Asahi Vipshop milk source is directly managed by Japanese technicians. The brand "Aahi Vipshop" is "Aahi Beer Co., Ltd. ", "Suzumo Chemical Co., Ltd." and "Itochu Commercial Co., Ltd." were established in Shandong Province in 2006. Well, it turns out that is a Japanese brand . No wonder some people say that this was only sold in Jiuguang.
From the product information, whole-fat fresh milk is not a product that requires complex processing. The raw materials are all "raw milk". Therefore, the quality of comes from the milk source itself. Under
, let the data speak and see how their quality is?
Part 2: A list of nutritional ingredients of seven brands of whole-fat fresh milk products:
Different colors represent different brands, and then sort out from 6 dimensions, 7 levels: 6 dimensions, protein, fat, carbohydrate , sodium, calcium. The closer the dimension is to 7, the higher the quality, the closer the dimension is to 1, the lower the quality.
For example, the most eye-catching orange-red line represents "Qiandao Lake Ranch" . Its energy, protein , fat, carbohydrates, and content are all the highest among the seven brands, so the large box occupies the outermost periphery of the radar chart. However, because the sodium content is relatively high (low sodium is healthier), there is a dimension that is deflated. It is speculated that this brand uses technical means to evaporate some of the moisture from the source milk, so the concentration of other nutrients in the milk will be greater, but inevitably, the sodium concentration is also high.
Another more eye-catching thing is the "Meiji Chunyi" represented by the blue line. The indicators of 6 dimensions are relatively balanced , and they are all close to the periphery. This brand is also a Japanese brand and baby milk powder is also quite famous.
Donuts were also the first choice for this brand of milk when they were Singapore . After returning to China, they began to support domestic products to drink domestic brand milk.
"Bright Fresh Milk" and "Asakura Vipshop" do not indicate the calcium content, and donuts don't know why? So much so that both brands have strange shapes in the radar chart. It doesn’t matter, I don’t have these two brands anyway!
After reading the rational data analysis, let’s take a look at the emotional part:
Part 3: Seven brands of whole-fat fresh milk produce 6 sensory scores
Donuts are moving!
After careful comparison, rigorous inspection and careful observation, the score was given from 6 angles including status, color, smell, taste, milk taste, sweetness, , etc. of 7 types of milk.
comprehensive sorting sensory score is calculated as follows:
Hahaha, it was really unexpected. The average performance of " flavors all strictly selected ranch" rushed to the front like a dark horse, ranking first with "Qiandao Lake Ranch" !
According to the great gods, the taste has a fragrant peanut smell (others say it is green grass smell, and then I quietly watched them fight).The lowest score of
is "Guangming Fresh Milk", and a great god said that every time I drink "Guangming Fresh Milk" from this blue box, I will have diarrhea! Why is it so bad that someone still buys it? There is only one answer: people who don’t know the truth think that the price will be cost-effective? The price is indeed very low, but the quality is also very low! So the cost-effectiveness is also very low!
Part 4: Comprehensive cost-effectiveness evaluation based on price, nutrition, senses, donut review
Dangdangdang! The result is here!
Do you know which brand of Circle was last chosen? Follow "Donut Family Education" quickly, and the answer will be revealed in the next issue of "Donut Major Yogurt Reviews"!
pure dry goods, welcome to forward them personally, so that more mothers know how to choose the most suitable fresh milk for their babies!
*This article is original by [Donut Family Education]. If you need to reprint, please contact authorization. WeChat official account: cnparenting_com
Donut
Science | Interesting family education community
The most classic parenting micro-class sharing
The most fun parenting activity course
The most cutting-edge expert parenting information
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-