is not better than the best than the best, but the classics have never been surpassed!
There is still a big gap between Guan Yu of Rongguang and Guan Yu of Lu Shuming . Although Yu Rongguang's performance is also domineering, it is far from as good as Lu Shuming's performance.
Guan Yu, who is the one! After his death, a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty was also known as " Bearded Gong ", "Guan Gong", "Wu Sheng" and other famous titles.
From the perspective of this historical image character, it is obvious that Lu Shuming will play more well, and because he starred earlier, the role of Guan Yu created by Lu Shuming has almost become the audience's understanding of Guan Yu's image.
From the perspective of general and majesticism, Lu Shuming played more in line with Guan Yu's prototype
Guan Yu was a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty. It is reported that he was nine feet tall and had a very majestic figure. Lu Shuming's height of 1.86 meters and his strong figure fully highlight Guan Yu's powerful image.
On the contrary, Yu Rongguang is 1.81 meters tall. Although he is quite tall, he is obviously not as big as Lu Shuming. So, judging from the simple body shape, Lu Shuming's performance is indeed more in line with the original work.
Guan Yu, played by Lu Shuming, is heroic. When he puts on the battle robe, he is so handsome and shows his style as a general. Yu Rongguang still seems to have some shortcomings in this regard.
From the perspective of expression and style, Lu Shuming's performance is also more appropriate
Not everyone wears a green hat, wears a green battle robe, and then keeps a long beautiful beard, and then holds Qinglong Yanyue Sword in hand, and becomes Guan Yu. Although the shape is quite similar, it is difficult to match perfectly in expression.
Like Guan Yu, played by Lu Shuming, his pair of phoenix eyes, coupled with these different eyes, does have the charm of "beautiful bearded man". Yu Rongguang's expression was more about shaping his eyes, and he always felt that he had less emotional investment.
From the perspective of the style of the style, Lu Shuming's clothes will be more prominent. In the new version of the Three Kingdoms, the clothes and hat of Guan Yu played by Yu Rongguang seem to be relatively dark, and it seems that they lack the style of a general from beginning to end.
Although Guan Yu seems to wear armor less often, as a commander, even if he does not wear armor on the battlefield, his battle robe should be quite bright and upscale. However, this has a lot to do with the crew's design.
Of course, in terms of arrogance and pretentiousness, Yu Rongguang will play slightly better
Guan Yu played by Yu Rongguang in the New Three Kingdoms, the deepest impression that it should be his arrogance. The squinting eyes and a disdainful look was indeed very arrogant, but it also had a little bit of heart.
This should be a "pretending to show off" and pretending to be too far. After Lu Bu, Guan Yu regarded all the heroes in the world as "every man", and Yu Rongguang seemed to have performed well, but his arrogant look even made the audience feel a little disliked this role.
I believe Guan Yu in history is not that arrogant. Although he also has moments of arrogant, he is not that kind of petty image. Therefore, Yu Rongguang will indeed be slightly better in the play, and Lu Shuming should also say that he is willing to give up the disadvantage.
In fact, in addition to being arrogant, Guan Yu, played by Yu Rongguang, will be more outstanding in fighting, especially the scene of playing with a knife, which can indeed be said to be the first sword in the Three Kingdoms. Of course, this is also reflected in the entire New Three Kingdoms.
However, classics certainly have classic characteristics. Whether from historical characters or from original novels, Guan Yu is indeed more appropriate to the prototype in the old version of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".
Moreover, in early TV dramas, whether it is " Journey to the West ", " Dream of the Red Chamber ", " Water Margin ", etc., they did a perfect job in the plot and character portrayal, and thus became a classic of a generation.
Of course, there are also many dramas, and after many remakes, they are also well shot in many cases, but it is still difficult to surpass the classics in the end. As for the role of Huang Rong in "The Legend of the Condor Heroes", both Weng Meiling and Athena Chu versions have performed very well, but Weng Meiling's version should be more classic.
Although as the new "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Guan Yu played by Yu Rongguang cannot surpass Lu Shuming's classic version, compared with Guan Yu's image in online dramas, movies, etc., Guan Yu played by Yu Rongguang can also be said to be quite good. He can almost be said to be the "second-in-command" in Guan Yu's role.
Comprehensively with the image of Guan Yu, in terms of style, expression and general's style, Guan Yu played by Lu Shuming is still more classic, and every performance is quite in place. Guan Yu, played by Yu Rongguang, has an average plot, but his arrogance is first-class, and the fighting scenes are also more exciting.
So, overall, Lu Shuming's Guan Yu will be more vivid, and Yu Rongguang's Guan Yu will be more arrogant. It can only be said that each has its own characteristics. One is the classic, which has long become an insurmountable benchmark; the other is the "New Three Kingdoms", the fighting scenes will be more exciting, and countless likes.
I am a entertainment Xiaolianer. Welcome to leave a message to discuss and like to follow !
