TV series " Mountains, Rivers, Moonlight " will be finalized tonight. The drama claims to be a historical drama, but after it was launched, it disappointed everyone a little. Fortunately, starting from episode 16, the plot has become better.
If the plays in the harem in the play and the elements of home-cooked plays and completely delete other scenes, the play's reputation will be better.
No matter what, I have been following this drama from the beginning to the end. Although it cannot be called a historical drama, in the recently aired TV series, the cast and content quality of the drama are still remarkable.
Through this drama, I revisited the history of in the early years of the Ming Dynasty , and wrote several comments on the drama, and discussed the plot and characters with netizens who like the drama. It felt very good.
During the process of watching the drama, I discovered many historical bugs in the drama, so I took a look at them one after another. Today, I compiled them into a text for friends who love the drama to compare and appreciate.
Qinwang Zhu Ren 's concubine, is the sister of KukuoTimur . Historically, the name is Guanyinnu, and the name in the play is MinminTimur, and the name in the Chinese name is Wang Yuemin.
In the play, the King of Qin took good care of the Wang family. Even if Zhu Yuanzhang forced them to divorce, he refused. He was still worried about the Wang family until he died of illness.
But in history, the King of Qin actually did not like this Mongolian princess Wang at all. The one he really likes and loves is his concubine Deng.
In the play, Zhu Xiongying and Zhu Yunwen are about the same age, and they read and play together, but in history, Zhu Xiongying is three years older than Zhu Yunwen.
Lan Yu in history did not die because of Zhu Yunwen's calculations, but because of his arrogant, unlawful and disciplined, forming cliques, and the actions of Zhu Yuanzhang to clean up heroes in order for Zhu Yunwen to hold the throne firmly.
In history, the Crown Princess Chang had already passed away in the eleventh year of Hongwu.
In November of that year, she had just given birth to her second son, Zhu Yunhuang, and died that month. It is likely that he died of postpartum disease.
And in the play, the time has been Hongwu for twenty years, and Chang is still alive.
Historically, it was not Tiexuan , but Liu Sanwu .
In history, it was not Tie Xuan, but an old minister named Liu Sanwu.
In the 25th year of Hongwu, after the death of the prince, Zhu Yuanzhang summoned his ministers to discuss the matter of appointing a crown prince. Zhu Yuanzhang said: "The King of Yan is as handsome as me, how about he established himself?" Many officials dared not speak. Only Liu Sanwu stepped forward and advised him, "The emperor's grandson is rich and his son is the son of the generation. His son died, and he is in charge of the rituals. He immediately appointed the King of Yan and where is the two kings of Qin and Jin?" Zhu Yuanzhang refused to answer after hearing this and cried in. Later, Zhu Yunwen was made the crown prince.
Zhu Xiongying died of illness in June 1382 (the first day of May 15th year of Hongwu), and at this time, his mother, Crown Princess Chang, had already passed away four years ago (the eleventh year of Hongwu).
In the play, when Zhu Xiongying died, his mother Chang was still alive.
and Queen Ma died of illness in August of the 15th year of Hongwu, three months later than Zhu Xiongying.
In the play, Queen Ma got sick because of taking care of the hero who had smallpox. She also went a few days after the hero went there.
In history, Empress Ma was 51 years old, Chang was 24 years old, and Zhu Xiongying died prematurely at the age of 8.
7
empty seal case and Hu Weiyong case are not the same case, but the two major cases in the early Ming Dynasty.
Hu Weiyong case is mainly to crack down on Huaixi clique group and regain the power of the prime minister, while the empty seal case is an economic case. In order to save trouble, "Moonlight in the Mountains and Rivers" did not specifically express the empty seal case, but directly combined the two cases.
The so-called empty seal means to pre-stamp the document and fill in the specific content when needed.
Zhu Yuanzhang believed that officials could use blank document books to cheat and embezzle, so those who use blank document books with official seals must be severely punished. This case involves a large number of people, known in history as the "empty seal case".
8
Zhu Di actually became the first commander of the Jinyiwei!
The first commander of the Ming Dynasty's Jinyiwei was Mao Xiang. Hu Weiyong The major case of involvement after his death was his masterpiece. Later, the case was concluded and he was killed by Zhu Yuanzhang to calm public anger.
The second commander Jiang Yan . He found evidence of Lan Yu's rebellion. He was sentenced to death by Zhu Yuanzhang after the Lan Yu case.
9
The first episode of the drama, Lan Yu led his troops to conquer Mobei, and calculated the time, it should be the second northern expedition in the early Ming Dynasty. Throughout history, he has always been the general of Xu Da .
. In the play, it was changed to Lan Yu leading the army. After he and Li Wenzhong failed, the emperor sent Xu Da.
in the play Li Jinglong , brave in war, properly commanded, did not jealous of his subordinates, nor did he deliberately let go. In history, Li Jinglong was jealous of talented people and had made mistakes in command, and was afraid that his subordinate Qu Neng would steal the merits.
Historically, when Li Jinglong was about to attack the city, he urgently ordered Quneng to retreat, resulting in the delay of the opportunity to fight.
, but in the play it is changed to Princess Yan personally led people to defend the city, repelled Qu Neng's attack and closed the city gate. In history, Princess Yan did go up to the city to personally guard the city, but it was not the reason why Qu retreated.
Zhu Di seized Ningwang 's cavalry elite. In history, he used wisdom, but in the play, he changed to a hard fight.
In history, Zhu Di pretended to be pitiful and went to join his seventeenth brother, King Ning. King Ning treated him with good wine and food because of his brotherly relationship. Zhu Di's subordinates had secretly bribed and persuaded the generals under King Ning. In the end, Zhu Di showed up and forced King Ning to lead his troops to rebel with him. He also promised that after the matter was completed, he would divide the world equally.
But Zhu Di refused to admit his resignation as emperor. Not only did he not want to share the world with King Ning, he didn't even want to give King Ning a good fief. King Ning wanted to re-elect a wealthy land in the south, but Zhu Di refused and finally re-elected King Ning to Nanchang .
However, in the play, Zhu Di brought 100,000 elite troops to fight hard, defeating Ning Wang. This is nothing more than highlighting Zhu Di's courage.
Twelve
History, Tie Xuan and Zhu Di had no selfish relationship, but in the play they were portrayed as a pair of close friends.
3
In the play, Yao Guangxiao and Tie Xuan actually became a master-apprentice relationship. And in history, the two have no intersection at all.
4
In the play, Yao Guangxiao and Liu Bowen are actually friends, and in history, they may not know each other, let alone become friends.
5
History, Tie Xuan refused to surrender to Zhu Di, and even scolded Zhu Di as a traitor who was a traitor who sought power and usurped the throne. Zhu Di was so angry that he executed Tie Xuan Lingchi and put it in a pan. Tiexuan's parents were exiled to Hainan, his eldest son was exiled to the army, his second son became an official slave, and his wife and daughter were sent to the Jiaofangsi as official prostitutes.
In the play, in order to highlight Zhu Di's emphasis on feelings and kindness, even if Tie Xuan did not surrender, Zhu Di was reluctant to kill Tie Xuan, and just wanted to exile him and his family. However, Tie Xuan himself was determined to die, so Zhu Di reluctantly issued an order to kill him to fulfill his loyalty and righteousness.
History, when Tie Xuan saw Zhu Di, he vowed not to kneel down, but in the play, Tie Xuan knelt down as soon as he was brought to Zhu Di.
In history, Xu Da was humble and cautious, never spoke much, and was strict in the army, making him feel like a mountain of depressedness and high prestige. However, in front of Zhu Yuanzhang, Xu Da was always respectful and cautious, and never regarded himself as a child.
However, in the first episode of "Mountains, Rivers, Moonlight", Xu Da and Zhu Yuanzhang called each other brothers, and called him their name directly, exposing Zhu Yuanzhang's scandal when he was a child in front of Queen Ma, and in front of Zhu Yuanzhang, he openly belittled King Yan Zhu Di, claiming that he looked down on such a son-in-law.
I have to say that the style of the show at the beginning was too home-style. The director may want to show that although Zhu Yuanzhang is the emperor, he also attaches importance to family and friendship and has a daily life-like side. But the play is too strong, which damages the drama's serious atmosphere.
This is the end of the historical bug analysis of the drama. Although there are some historical flaws, the drama is still a good drama.
Douban score is only 5.4 points, which is really a bit low. I think at least one pass score can be given. And I gave it four stars.
Maybe many netizens, after watching one or two episodes of "Moonlight", hurriedly gave a one-star and two-star evaluation. I think that if you don't watch the complete drama, you will give a low-scoring evaluation, which is neither objective nor comprehensive, and is also unfair to the drama.
Everyone got low scores, but don’t scare the directors so much that they dare not shoot historical dramas anymore. Then, don’t we historical drama lovers lose the opportunity to watch a good drama?
