***TalkOP Seaway-One Piece Forum-One Piece Discussion Area****
Author ID: Yizhou Yangfan
First release date: 2022.9.19
************ Reprinting is prohibited without permission****************
A At this time, Luffy still shouted "Yamato Man" that night Momonosuke held a celebration. At the same time, the green bull attack occurred; B At this time, Luffy did not call Yamato, and it is not clear whether Luffy changed his words at this time; after
Previous note:
1 The motivation for this post to open the post comes from this post: 1059 Luffy's reaction is destined to be the tenth person again
2 Because Luffy's definition of partners is broad, the title specifically refers to partners who can invite them to board the ship.
3 Multi-picture warning.
The goal of this post: By analyzing the backtracking scenes about Yamato in episode 1059, try to find the time node when Luffy accepts Yamato to board the ship.
preparation:
simply found a few sections of the process of Luffy changing the character's name and trying to find out the rules.
Empress : 
Before the empress promised to send Luffy to the prison, Luffy, who originally called the empress "Snake Girl", still called her wrong name after being reminded by the empress (some translated as "Hammock", I personally think "Hammock" is more funny). But after the empress fulfilled her promise, Luffy called out the empress's name for the first time:
Before the incident, Han Maoke, and afterwards Han Kuke . So we can also see that our captain Luffy is a boy who knows how to be grateful and responsible.
Pokmus :
Since Luffy met the boss of the Cat Viper, he has always called Pokmus "Pokmus". Even if someone has told Pokmus the name, he doesn't care.
At this time, I saw Pochmus show his ability and became a "turtle viper". In short, I have never called it right.
After that, at Luffy's insistence, Pochmus took on the task of introducing the Straw Hat Group to the World. After arriving at the chocolate island, Pochmus was kidnapped by Becky , but before that, he carved a message on the toilet wall to warn the straw hat group:
At this time, Luffy could have called Pochmus' name correctly. Pochmus' previous promise should be to take the straw hat group to cake island . Although it was forced to interrupt the situation, it was already fulfilling its promise to guide the straw hat group to enter the waters of the All Nations.
Pedro :
Before leaving Zowu , Luffy called Pedro "Perro Pero (licking)"
and Luffy called Pedro's name for the first time. After arriving at Cake Island, Pedro recommended himself and Brooke to steal historical text for Luffy
The night before, Pedro told Luffy about his previous adventure career and asked him to get the redstone for Luffy.
summarizes based on the above three examples. If Luffy wants to change the name of a character (specifically referring to the name of a character), two conditions need to be met: has a certain time span, and something special happens (benefiting Luffy) .
A certain amount of time can make Luffy more familiar with the other person during the process of getting along (such as the days and nights of being alone with the empress, a shared sailing experience with several fur tribes), and special events can impress Luffy (such as the empress took Luffy into the prison while the fur tribes helped Luffy achieve various goals in the world). Of course, there may be other conditions for different roles, but the above two analyses are basically enough.
Now let’s take a look at Yamato:
Lufei woke up. At this time, when he learned that Yamato woke up and went on a hunger strike for prayer, Luffy thanked:
green bull was driven away by red-haired , which was the 1059 Yamato’s decision:
, the straw hat group rested in Wano Country: C The straw hat group set sail, Luffy officially called "Yamato"
The process of listing it is intuitive. A and C are both clear at the front and back, but when in the intermediate state B, Luffy's attitude is not stated.
has a view that when Yamato decided to stay in Wano Country in Chapter 1059, Luffy had agreed to Yamato become a partner because she was too beautiful. . . No, it was not done because she had her own ideas.
, and at the same time, there is a view that Luffy’s attitude towards a character being a crew member is related to his attitude towards the character becoming a member.
combined, we can conclude that Luffy’s name to Yamato in stage B in is highly likely related to this time node Luffy’s attitude towards Yamato on board . But Luffy didn't give this answer here.
I tend to think that Luffy in the B stage will not change from "Yamato Man" to "Yamato" . That is to say, it was not because Yamato decided to stay behind Luffy to give up the recruitment, but Luffy did not think about "Yamato joining the gang" incident. It was just Yamato talking to himself, and Luffy was following the flow at this moment. The reasons are as follows:
First Comparing the two conditions we summarized at the beginning,
"a certain time span": the last time Luffy called "Yamato Man" was only less than a day after , the interval was too short, and the theme of that day was a banquet, so there was a high probability that there would be no time to communicate outside the theme;
"Special Event": "Green Bull Attack Incident", Yamato showed her attitude of protecting Peaches and protecting Kazuya, but this is her consistent setting since her appearance. Luffy saw her contribution on Ghost Island. The Green Bull incident was just a continuation, which was not "special" enough for Luffy (in fact, Luffy still did not change his name when he understood Yamato's activity on Ghost Island and the post-war halt-off for her blessings);
In short, did not have enough weight for most of the day to make Luffy change the factor of Yamato's name . nd
When the information was first released, it was said that Sanji Luffy was trying to keep it, but there was no spokesperson in this situation. After reading the original version of Japanese , I think that all three dialog boxes are from Sanji, and there are two reasons: 1. represents the "vertical wave" symbol used in the tone. The three boxes are consistent, showing a strong regret, which is consistent with the dialog box of Sanji behind:
, and Luffy's words are all ellipsis , showing a relatively stable mood: . Only Sanji shows exaggerated body movements, which fits the dialogue tone with "vertical waves"; Luffy's body did not move and was still playing skewers, just turned around.
That is to say, only Sanji was trying to keep Yamato from beginning to end, but Luffy didn't. 3 A auxiliary basis, as Luffy's "biwings", against the backdrop of Sanji Zoro 's left and right sentence "Yamato", Luffy seemed very deliberate without calling Yamato's name.
inevitably gives people a kind of thing. Everyone is already very familiar with Yamato, but Luffy feels unmoved .
Attachment: You can compare Luffy's performance when he really hopes his partner will board the ship.
(objective conditions are different, only for end-related associations)
In summary, I think that as of the time when Yamato will decide to inform Luffy, Luffy has not thought about inviting her as a partner.
I guess, what really made Luffy change his name and accepted Yamato was the "days" between B and C. This period of time meets the conditions of "a certain time span", and the other is that there is a possibility of "special events". I think the special event here is Yamato and Luffy sharing their memories of being with Ace (when talking about Ace, they may also talk about themselves), which also made Luffy understand that Yamato and Ace are not ordinary understanding, but a deep understanding of recognition and bonding based on this. With her fate with Ace and her previous actions, Luffy's understanding of Yamato became much deeper, which made Luffy truly accept Yamato.
To sum up, I think when Yamato made the decision on the night of the 1059 celebration, she herself had not yet met some of the conditions that could make Luffy accept as her partner. But Luffy accepted her when she officially set off for voyage, which was closely related to Ace .
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ I was surprised by the comic after turning it over. In fact, Luffy called out Galot's name for the first time without going through the process of changing the words.
is where Luffy caught poisonous fish. How could this happen to
? In the early stage, the rabbit only had a sense of presence when it appeared in smuggling. Is this level enough to be remembered by Luffy? After thinking about the previous plot again, I probably understood. Perhaps it was because when he appeared in smuggling, the rabbit put on a "carrot" all over the ground, and even Luffy almost died on the spot due to stealing food, which impressed him. Hearing her friends call her "Carrot". At this moment, the "Luffy's naming rules" reached an unprecedented agreement with the actual situation, and Luffy naturally remembered Garot's name.
I think Luffy can remember Galot's name at once and it is just a coincidence in the plot, but when Luffy's way of calling the name has become an indicator of certain things, we can wait for the subsequent plot to reveal whether this coincidence has a deeper intention.
Before this I would like to list some of the details I have noticed. I forgot where the setting was given for the first time Galot's age appeared, but it shouldn't be marked when she first appeared. That is to say, when she first appeared, she was just a female character with cute elements to the readers. It just so happens that there are two characters on the Straw Hat Group who have "special interactive skills" for women. Let's see if there is a chance to communicate with each other. As a result, the "lady indicator" of the two gentlemen was completely unresponsive to Galot. During
, Sanji's "Galuqiu" whose motivations were not simple, he had never seen Galot use it, and even his heart-shaped eyes never appeared;
Brooke's very elegant "fat greetings", which Galot appeared when he was present, but the object was only the old customer Nami
The station highlighted a clear distinction.
specifically mentioned here. When Brooke drove the rabbit back to the Sunny episode 862, he arranged for Brooke to "fat greetings" to Gallot twice to
. No matter which time the comic, Brooke did not say a word, which was wronged.
so the "special treatment" of the two gentlemen to Galot, now we know that it should be because of age. Although 15 years old and 20 or even 18 years old are not a few years apart, it is the relationship between adulthood or not, and should be divided into different age stages.
This is also the reason why I have always insisted that if a new partner is a woman, then he must be different from Nami Robin in terms of age, because it is related to the uniqueness of her interactions with other partners.
With the new plot updated, there seems to be some explanation for the age of Boni . At that time, we can pay attention to the specific performance of the two gentlemen.
’s final conclusion represents your good wishes. Whether readers agree with the previous "Sanji Year" or not, next year will be indeed the "Year of the Rabbit". I don’t know if Neon has a saying about her zodiac year, and I hope Oda will do its best.
