Although it has mixed reviews, in my opinion, "The War of the Roses" is still worth pursuing.
Because most of the cases in the story can find corresponding shadows in life. However, the case that touched me most deeply was the case of "nanny's inheritance".
The story line is very simple -
Han Dongqing made two wills before his death, leaving his inheritance to Wu Sisi, his apprentice who had been taking care of him. The other was a notarized will and gave another house to his daughter Lu Minghua. Lu Minghua wanted to compete with Wu Sisi for the inheritance. , Wu Sisi asked Gu Nian to defend her.
Before the lawsuit started, Lu Minghua led people to Wu Sisi's house to make a fuss and wanted to take away all the calligraphy, paintings and artworks collected by Han Dongqing during his lifetime.
The reason why this happened was that Lu Minghua believed that Wu Sisi used some kind of charm method on her father to defraud her father of the will and family property.
(Frankly speaking, when we read this, many of us thought the same as Lu Minghua. After all, Lu Minghua is Han Dongqing’s biological daughter, and Wu Sisi is just an outsider. She did not leave the inheritance to her own daughter, but to an outsider. , somewhat unjustifiable. )
This situation was already very complicated. After arriving in court, Lu Minghua first called Han Dongqing's girlfriend Liu Xiangnan to testify in court, hoping to further establish the evidence chain that Wu Sisi defrauded the will.
Not only that, a woman named Liao Xiuhua in the auditorium stood up and claimed that she was also Han Dongqing's daughter and wanted a share of Han Dongqing's inheritance.
With an ex-girlfriend, two biological daughters with different surnames, and a nanny, the case becomes more complicated.
To the surprise of many people, the person who ultimately won the case was Wu Sisi. Neither of his two biological daughters took Han Dongqing's inheritance from Wu Sisi.
Screenshot of the TV series "The War of the Roses"
Needless to say, Liu Xiangnan and Han Dongqing were not married, and she did not share the regret of the separation. The greatest value of her appearance was to help Lu Minghua testify and prove that Wu Sisi's will was illegal.
But many people don’t understand that Liao Xiuhua and Lu Minghua lost the lawsuit.
All of this starts with Han Dongqing's two marriages (it has to be said that the old man's love luck is really good, with two wives and a girlfriend, and he has had emotional interactions with at least three women).
Many years ago, after Han Dongqing and Liao Qingfen divorced, they gave Liao Qingfen a sum of money.
After Liao Qingfen got the money, she returned to her hometown and opened a small shop, and her life was good.
Although there is no direct explanation in the story, from the conversations between the lawyers and people on the road, it is not difficult to find that since Han Dongqing and Liao Qingfen divorced, there should be no contact between them.
To use an impersonal saying, although Han Dongqing is Liao Xiuhua's biological father and Liao Xiuhua is Han Dongqing's biological daughter, in real life, they are strangers with no relationship.
Because when Han Dongqing and Liao Qingfen divorced, their property during their marriage had been divided, so Liao Qingfen did not have the right to inherit Han Dongqing's inheritance.
Their father-daughter relationship is, to a certain extent, no different from children adopted into other families. With the divorce of their parents and the division of property, the connection between them was severed. After all, under normal circumstances, her child support should be included in the divided property. Although
is unwilling to accept this statement, according to the relevant legal provisions, this is indeed the case.
Of course, it would be a different matter if Liao Xiuhua took care of and supported Han Dong when he grew old, regardless of past grudges.
Screenshot of the TV series "The War of the Roses"
Lu Minghua's situation is almost exactly the same as Liao Xiuhua's.
Later, Han Dongqing and Lu Qiaohua got married and had a son and a daughter, but they didn't want their son to pass away, leaving only Lu Minghua as their daughter.
Never thought that many years later, the marriage of Han Dongqing and Lu Qiaohua came to an end. The two divorced, and Lu Minghua followed his mother.
Of course, when Lu Qiaohua and Han Dongqing divorced, their property should have been divided.
Because his parents were divorced, Lu Minghua did not want to recognize Han Dongqing as his father.
Han Dongqing makes purple clay teapots . Although he is divorced from Lu Qiaohua, he still wants Lu Minghua to inherit his craftsmanship. Lu Minghua is very disgusted with his father's request and has complained to Han Dongqing many times in the office. He also had many disputes with his father over the purple clay pot, which was very unpleasant (I think, even in the office, Lu Minghua mentioned this matter many times, so the relationship between them should not be as simple as unhappiness).
Therefore, Han Dongqing has also stated many times that he will not leave his inheritance to Lu Minghua.
According to the drama, after the relationship between father and daughter broke down, Lu Minghua basically never visited Han Dongqing, let alone supported his father.
The interesting thing is that because Wu Sisi had another job in life, Lu Minghua and the others decided that Wu Sisi did not take good care of Han Dongqing, but used other methods to coerce Han Dongqing into making the will.
(Of course, Wu Sisi also gave an explanation for this problem. It was because Han Dongqing taught her how to make purple clay pots and turned from a nanny into an apprentice. Han Dongqing offered to let her find another job.)
Of course, Han Dongqing was right Lu Minghua is not completely heartless. Because in the second will he made, he still left a property to Lu Minghua.
Screenshot of the TV series "The War of the Roses"
Wu Sisi took care of Han Dongqing for eight years. In the first two years, she was a full-time nanny. Because of her hard work, she was appreciated by Han Dongqing, so she became Han Dongqing's apprentice.
In the past eight years, Wu Sisi tried his best to take care of Han Dongqing, but Lu Minghua never fulfilled his responsibility of supporting him.
Therefore, before his death, Han Dongqing left two wills, leaving his main inheritance to Wu Sisi and Lu Minghua. A house was left behind.
Regarding the final verdict, many people did not understand why Han Dongqing would rather leave his inheritance to an outsider than to his biological daughter.
For this reason, I also checked online and found out that the inheritance does not have to be inherited by the children. According to relevant legal provisions, if there is a will, it will be handled according to the will inheritance or bequest ; if there is bequest and support agreement , it will be handled in accordance with the agreement. handle. In other words, testamentary inheritance takes precedence over legal inheritance .
From this we can conclude that there is no problem with the court's decision.
As mentioned in the barrage, if it is said that children have the right to inherit inheritance, does it mean that they can inherit inheritance even if they do not support their parents, or even if they abuse their parents?
is just a side story, and it does not fully unfold the relationship between Han Dongqing and Lu Minghua, father and daughter, so we don’t know the full picture of their daily life together.
But in my intuition, if Lu Minghua could be more filial and often visit and accompany his father, Han Dongqing would not have done such a good job.
Of course, the reason why Han Dongqing did this may also be because of Wu Sisi's apprentice status. After all, for some industries, apprentices are much more important than children.
Because children only inherit the bloodline, while apprentices inherit the spirit.
Screenshot of the TV series "The War of the Roses"
In real life, things like old man Han Dongqing are rare.
But I think that if you want to take something, you must give it first, and the same should be true between parents and children.
You grow up with me, and I grow old with you. The obligation between mother and child is two-way.
When children are young, parents raise them, provide them with food, clothing, and education. When their parents are old, children should repay their parents in the same way.
In my hometown in the countryside, people attach great importance to the inheritance of incense, but no matter how many children there are, there are often only one or two who really stay with their parents to take care of them.
Fortunately, the folk customs in my hometown are relatively simple. After the old man passes away, most of the family property will belong to the one who stays to take care of his parents, and most of the other children will not jump out to fight for it.
In recent years, due to the impact of the economic tide, more and more young people have gone out to work, leaving their parents at home.
Many people are too busy to take care of their parents themselves, so they have to ask others to take care of them. But I think that as a child, even if you can't take care of your parents all the time, you should go home often and have more phone calls with your parents even if it's not possible. .
Only in this way can parents feel their children's filial piety.
If, like Lu Minghua, he ignored his father when he was alive, and then jumped out to fight for the family property after his father passed away, it would be somewhat unjustifiable.
I think Han Dongqing saw this clearly and left a will in advance.
In fact, even without the will, Lu Minghua would not be able to get all the inheritance, because according to relevant laws, she and Liao Xiuhua have equal inheritance rights.
No matter how cruel the reality is, personally, I still hope that every elderly person will be able to provide for themselves in old age, instead of having their children sue for inheritance issues after the elderly person dies.
Screenshot of the TV series "The War of the Roses"
(It is not easy to be original, please indicate the source if reproduced.)
Of course, when Lu Qiaohua and Han Dongqing divorced, their property should have been divided.
Because his parents were divorced, Lu Minghua did not want to recognize Han Dongqing as his father.
Han Dongqing makes purple clay teapots . Although he is divorced from Lu Qiaohua, he still wants Lu Minghua to inherit his craftsmanship. Lu Minghua is very disgusted with his father's request and has complained to Han Dongqing many times in the office. He also had many disputes with his father over the purple clay pot, which was very unpleasant (I think, even in the office, Lu Minghua mentioned this matter many times, so the relationship between them should not be as simple as unhappiness).
Therefore, Han Dongqing has also stated many times that he will not leave his inheritance to Lu Minghua.
According to the drama, after the relationship between father and daughter broke down, Lu Minghua basically never visited Han Dongqing, let alone supported his father.
The interesting thing is that because Wu Sisi had another job in life, Lu Minghua and the others decided that Wu Sisi did not take good care of Han Dongqing, but used other methods to coerce Han Dongqing into making the will.
(Of course, Wu Sisi also gave an explanation for this problem. It was because Han Dongqing taught her how to make purple clay pots and turned from a nanny into an apprentice. Han Dongqing offered to let her find another job.)
Of course, Han Dongqing was right Lu Minghua is not completely heartless. Because in the second will he made, he still left a property to Lu Minghua.
Screenshot of the TV series "The War of the Roses"
Wu Sisi took care of Han Dongqing for eight years. In the first two years, she was a full-time nanny. Because of her hard work, she was appreciated by Han Dongqing, so she became Han Dongqing's apprentice.
In the past eight years, Wu Sisi tried his best to take care of Han Dongqing, but Lu Minghua never fulfilled his responsibility of supporting him.
Therefore, before his death, Han Dongqing left two wills, leaving his main inheritance to Wu Sisi and Lu Minghua. A house was left behind.
Regarding the final verdict, many people did not understand why Han Dongqing would rather leave his inheritance to an outsider than to his biological daughter.
For this reason, I also checked online and found out that the inheritance does not have to be inherited by the children. According to relevant legal provisions, if there is a will, it will be handled according to the will inheritance or bequest ; if there is bequest and support agreement , it will be handled in accordance with the agreement. handle. In other words, testamentary inheritance takes precedence over legal inheritance .
From this we can conclude that there is no problem with the court's decision.
As mentioned in the barrage, if it is said that children have the right to inherit inheritance, does it mean that they can inherit inheritance even if they do not support their parents, or even if they abuse their parents?
is just a side story, and it does not fully unfold the relationship between Han Dongqing and Lu Minghua, father and daughter, so we don’t know the full picture of their daily life together.
But in my intuition, if Lu Minghua could be more filial and often visit and accompany his father, Han Dongqing would not have done such a good job.
Of course, the reason why Han Dongqing did this may also be because of Wu Sisi's apprentice status. After all, for some industries, apprentices are much more important than children.
Because children only inherit the bloodline, while apprentices inherit the spirit.
Screenshot of the TV series "The War of the Roses"
In real life, things like old man Han Dongqing are rare.
But I think that if you want to take something, you must give it first, and the same should be true between parents and children.
You grow up with me, and I grow old with you. The obligation between mother and child is two-way.
When children are young, parents raise them, provide them with food, clothing, and education. When their parents are old, children should repay their parents in the same way.
In my hometown in the countryside, people attach great importance to the inheritance of incense, but no matter how many children there are, there are often only one or two who really stay with their parents to take care of them.
Fortunately, the folk customs in my hometown are relatively simple. After the old man passes away, most of the family property will belong to the one who stays to take care of his parents, and most of the other children will not jump out to fight for it.
In recent years, due to the impact of the economic tide, more and more young people have gone out to work, leaving their parents at home.
Many people are too busy to take care of their parents themselves, so they have to ask others to take care of them. But I think that as a child, even if you can't take care of your parents all the time, you should go home often and have more phone calls with your parents even if it's not possible. .
Only in this way can parents feel their children's filial piety.
If, like Lu Minghua, he ignored his father when he was alive, and then jumped out to fight for the family property after his father passed away, it would be somewhat unjustifiable.
I think Han Dongqing saw this clearly and left a will in advance.
In fact, even without the will, Lu Minghua would not be able to get all the inheritance, because according to relevant laws, she and Liao Xiuhua have equal inheritance rights.
No matter how cruel the reality is, personally, I still hope that every elderly person will be able to provide for themselves in old age, instead of having their children sue for inheritance issues after the elderly person dies.
Screenshot of the TV series "The War of the Roses"
(It is not easy to be original, please indicate the source if reproduced.)
