Liu Feng's death, is he deserved the crime or not dying?

"Three Kingdoms·Liu Feng Biography" records: Shen Yi rebelled against the seal, and returned to Chengdu. After the seal is over, the first master will invade Lingda without saving the feather. Zhuge Liang was concerned about the fierceness of the seal, and after changing the world, it would be difficult to control it. So she was sealed and self-decided. Feng Tan said: "Hate not to use Mencius's words!"

Liu Bei gave Liu Feng to death for two reasons: one is that the bullying of Mengda caused Mengda to surrender and lost the third county of Dongdong; the other is that the battle of Xiangfan did not send troops to rescue Guan Yu, then can these two counts be the reason for Liu Feng's death ? In other words, in Liu Feng's death, was he deserved the crime or not dying?

"The Legend of Three Kingdoms: Liu Feng Biography" records: Feng Xun Duoda preached a dispute with Da Yu. Da was afraid of sin, but also annoyed, so he resigned from the first master and led the surrender to Wei.

mentioned here two reasons why Meng Da surrendered to Cao Wei: First, he was bullied by Liu Feng and was robbed of advocacy (this is a kind of honor, often used to reward meritorious officials, and ordinary people cannot get it, so Liu Feng is a little jealous. ); The second is to persuade Liu Feng to rescue Guan Yu, for fear that Liu Beiqiu will settle accounts.

Actually, there is another more important reason, and that is that Fazheng, who had an irreversible relationship with Mengda, died before that. Liu Bei almost obeyed the Fazheng. If the Fazheng is still there, Liu Bei's punishment for Mengda will not be too severe. Meng Da didn’t have to defect to Cao Wei at all. The death of Fazheng was the root cause of Meng Da’s defection. Liu Bei used Liu Feng to bully Meng Da as the reason why the Dongsan County changed hands.

"The Legend of Three Kingdoms: Liu Feng Biography" records: Since Guan Yu encircled Fancheng and Xiangyang, he called Feng and Da, and ordered the troops to help themselves. Feng and Daci are attached to Shanjun, unshakable, and will not accept Yu's fate. Huiyu is defeated, the first master hates it.

Liu Feng did not send troops to rescue Guan Yu in the battle of Xiangfan. This is really wrong, but there are a few points to note: First, Liu Feng said that "the mountain county is first attached, unshakable, and will not accept Yu's order." Refused to send troops, Liu Not long after Feng and Mengda took over the third county of the East, the local powers of the third county, such as the Shen brothers, are extremely powerful. It is true that the hearts of the people are not attached. The force in Liu Feng's hand can only guarantee to deter the third county. Once the troops are divided to rescue Guan Yu It may cause instability in Dongsan County.

Second, the Kingdom said that Guan Yu retired to Maicheng to ask for help from Liu Feng. In fact, it was not. In the official history, Guan Yu asked Liu Feng to send troops to respond to his military actions when he was besieging Cao Ren in Fancheng. It was also unexpected that Sun Quan would attack Jingzhou with his alliance, Fu Shiren and Mi Fang would surrender without a fight. Of course, Guan Yu withdrew from the front line and returned to Jingzhou. At this time, Liu Feng should indeed send troops, but Liu Feng can’t be completely blamed because the battle situation has changed. It was too fast. It took only more than a month from the withdrawal to the defeat. The main force of Liu Bei's Yizhou army in the entire Xiangfan battle was silent. The reason was that no one had thought that Guan Yu, who had been Megatron China, would be defeated so quickly!

Third, does Guan Yu Jiajieyue have the right to control Meng Da and Liu Feng? Really may not be there! Dongsan County originally belonged to Hanzhong in Yizhou. After Liu Bei succeeded, it still belonged to Yizhou, and did not belong to Jingzhou or Guan Yu's jurisdiction. Also, judging from Liu Bei's transfer of Nanjun prefect to Mi Fang, Liu Bei still has certain restrictions on Guan Yu's power. Yes, although Guan Yu was given the right to leave the festival, but it may not be handed over to Guan Yu as well. In terms of affiliation, Liu Feng is not a direct subordinate of Guan Yu, and he does not follow Guan Yu’s military order. There is nothing wrong.

Liu Feng’s death was actually related to Zhuge Liang’s contribution to the flames, and Meng Da wrote a letter to persuade Liu Feng to surrender after he surrendered with troops, but Liu Feng sternly refused, and the outnumbered Dongsan County changed hands again. So although Liu Feng is guilty, he does not die. If he were not the eldest son adopted by Liu Bei, Liu Feng would not have been given death.