Revealing the weapon of Guan Yu in the real history is not the Qinglong Yanyue Sword, but it is stronger than it

There are many magic weapons in "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms". Lu Bu's Fangtian painted halberd, Guan Yu's Qinglong Yanyue knife, Zhang Fei's Zhangba snake spear, Cao Cao's Yitian sword, and Qingyan sword are all famous and popular. Talk about it. What

wants to tell you today is Qinglong Yanyuedao.

Qinglong Yanyue Knife, with great fame, is Guan Yu's weapon in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms. According to the book, the Qinglong Yanyue Sword weighed eighty-two jin. Guan Yu used it to kill many generals and became famous. Therefore, later generations also called the Qinglong Yanyue Sword a Guan Sword. After Guan Yu was killed, the Qinglong Yanyue Sword was taken away by Soochow General Pan Zhang. Later, Guan Yu's son Guan Xing killed Pan Zhang to avenge his father and retaken the Qinglong Yanyue Sword.

Like the long beard, Qinglong Yanyuedao has almost become a synonym and symbol for Guan Yu. However, "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is a novel after all, not a history book. It was written at the end of the Yuan Dynasty and the beginning of the Ming Dynasty. It is thousands of years away from the Three Kingdoms era. Except for the character names, geographical names, and main events, which are basically the same as in "Three Kingdoms", the rest Much of the content is fabricated by the author, far from historical facts.

So, here comes the question. In real history, Guan Yu does have a man, and did his weapon, the Qinglong Yanyue Sword, really exist in the Three Kingdoms period?

According to historical research, the Qinglong Yanyue Sword used by Guan Yu mentioned in the novel did not have this kind of weapon during the Three Kingdoms period, but it really appeared in the Song Dynasty, called Yanyue Sword, and was first seen in the "Wu Jing Zong Yao Qian" Collection·Apparatus Map. "Wu Jing Zong Yao" was written in the fourth year of Renzong Qingli in the early Northern Song Dynasty (1044 AD). It was China’s first military and weapon encyclopedia edited by the government. Among the eight knife shapes used in the army, the Yanyue knife is among them.

​​is a heavy weapon with a long handle. The Moon Knife has great power for chopping. However, it is not popular on the battlefield because of its heavy weight and high manufacturing cost. It is more used in military exercises, arrays and drills to show military might, or become a palace. In the early Qing Dynasty, the guards of guards and the ceremonial weapons of the halogen book even became the props for the martial arts assessment. The appearance of

was late, and the actual combat ability was poor. Various signs indicate that Guan Yu's weapon in real history is not the Qinglong Yanyue Sword, but other weapons.

"Three Kingdoms" records: "Cao Minister Zhang Liao and Guan Yu are the pioneers, and Yu sees Liang's spurs, spurs the spurs among the crowd, and beheads them." Chen Shou's "thorn" makes people have many things. Doubt, if it is a knife, it should be the terms "splitting" and "slashing", while the word "stab" should be used for weapons such as 槊 and spear. Therefore, many people speculate that Guan Yu should use weapons such as lances and spears.

However, this argument is actually untenable. During the Three Kingdoms period, the most popular short weapon on the battlefield in China was the ring head knife. Everyone knows that the ring head knife is a straight knife. It not only has excellent chopping ability, but also has great piercing power. It is an armor-piercing weapon. The enemy loses combat effectiveness.

In addition, from historical records, thorns are often described in the use of swords. The "Han Shu. Su Wu Zhuan" records that the Han Dynasty sent Su Wu as an envoy to the Huns. When the Huns forced Su Wu to surrender: Even though he was born, how can he return to the Han!" The sword can be pierced by himself.

Therefore, it is unfounded to say that Guan Yu definitely does not use a knife. Therefore, our conclusion today is: Guan Yu did not use the Qinglong Yanyue Knife, but it is most likely other long-handled broadswords or ring-headed knives, or weapons such as wands and spears. Regardless of whether it is a ring-head sword or a lance or spear, its practical value is much stronger than that of the Qinglong Yanyue knife (the ring-head sword is the "ancestor of a hundred swords" in China and the first war knife in ancient times. In fact, even Guan Yu has other weapons, He must have used the ring first sword, because the ring first sword was the most popular short soldier in the Three Kingdoms period).

Note: This article is from the Internet. This account is a signed account of NetEase News & NetEase's "Each Attitude".

Weapon name: Xiongnu weapon, Qi’s army, Ming Dynasty firearm, western spear, gun and spear, shield culture, bayonet, Fangtian painted halberd, stirrup, Chinese cavalry, security waist knife, white chariot, iron ruler, saber, octagonal sword, Japanese saber