Flying Fox Legend and Tang Dynasty Strange Things Record are the two most popular costume dramas recently, one is Jin Yong's martial arts masterpiece and the other is a suspense detective drama. It can be said that each has its own characteristics, but the difference between the two is very obvious.
From the plot point of view, Tang Dynasty Strange Event Record is obviously more advantageous.
Flying Fox Legend is of course wonderful, but Jin Yong 's works have been popular for decades after all, and all the plots and burdens are well known to the audience, and there is no sense of secret. The screenwriter of Feihu Story is not very clever. Not only did he change the original work beyond recognition, but he also had many mistakes in the details, which was difficult to convince the majority of Jin Yong fans.
For example, the plot of selling vegetables in Miao Renfeng is the biggest failure of the whole play. For some reason, Lin Shen's version of Miao Renfeng, as a Qing Dynasty knight, actually combed a Ming Dynasty hair accessories, and even went to the vegetable market to sell vegetables in a big way. When did the golden-faced Buddha, who was invincible in the world, fall into this situation?
The Tang Dynasty's strange story is different. The novel detective story, the general of the Central Army with a huge force and the disciple of Di Gong who is extremely smart, work together to uncover the answers one by one. It is tense, exciting and interesting, logically tangible, and the costumes and props are even more exquisite, and the details are meticulous.
In terms of shaping the protagonist's character, it is also the record of strange events in the Tang Dynasty that is more attractive.
Hu Fei in the Legend of Feihu is generous, heroic, free and unrestrained, humorous, and a hero with a very charming personality. But the screenwriter changed him to a dumb and stupid ordinary person, with no shining points on his body, and his martial arts are ordinary, so it is difficult for the audience to feel his outstanding qualities and bring them into it.
The two heroines are even more disappointing. Yuan Ziyi has changed from being smart and cheerful to being taciturn, Cheng Lingsu has changed from being smart and unparalleled to being a little jasper, and its charm value has been greatly reduced.
The record of strange events in the Tang Dynasty is different. The protagonist Lu Lingfeng was arrogant and stubborn when he first appeared, but he was still chivalrous. In the face of setbacks, he can bend and stretch, and gradually becomes reasonable through repeated investigations of cases, and his personality defects can be compensated. The protagonist is growing up. Although his martial arts are not as invincible as Li Yuanfang , he is also a temporary choice. The battles with bad people again and again made people very satisfied.
From the perspective of the rhythm of the story, the Tang Dynasty's Strange Event Record is better. The adaptation of the Feihu Legend of
is too slow. A novel with a sense of family and country has turned into a popular TV series where a foolish child talks about love. The screenwriter still doesn't think it's enough and keeps creating conflicts between the male and female protagonists. For example, Hu Fei wrote to Yuan Ziyi, hoping to make an appointment to meet outside the city and explain the misunderstanding clearly. But the screenwriter had to make many twists and turns. He first asked Hu Fei to wait, and then asked Yuan Ziyi's stupid junior sister to go back and forth to inform him, and persuaded Yuan Ziyi to accept the other party's kindness. Yuan Ziyi beat Muyu for a while and finally went to see Hu Fei under the advice of his master. The drama that can be explained in a few minutes was delayed for more than ten minutes, but it did not show much substantial content.
The Tang Dynasty's strange events are very different, the pace is so fast that it is flying. The Legend of Feihu can be viewed twice as fast as possible, without delaying understanding the plot at all. However, the Tang Dynasty's strange events cannot be accelerated. The amount of information is too large, and the places that can be saved will definitely not cause unnecessary troubles. For example, the beggar provided a detail in the stone bridge pattern, and saw that the one who killed Lu Gongfu was a monk. Lu Lingfeng immediately investigated the monk who had contact with Lu Gong again, and as a result, the monk's suspicion was eliminated through verbal retelling. The plot is dense but not complicated, so the audience won't feel bored after watching it.
Of course, although the new version of Feihu Legend has many shortcomings, it is not a bad drama. The performances of several secondary characters are remarkable. Although the plot has many inconsistent logic and inconsistent logic, as an online drama, there is nothing to be picky about. In general, it is fairly standard. But compared with the Tang Dynasty's strange events, it is undoubtedly much worse. If the new version of Flying Fox can reach 6.7 points, then the Tang Dynasty's Strange Event Record can reach at least 7.6 points.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-