On the afternoon of November 2, 2016, Chen Shifeng, Liu Nuanxi’s ex-boyfriend, came to Liu Nuanxi’s residence to look for her. At this time, Liu Nuanxi was sleeping in the room and did not hear any movement outside the door at first.
Until the knocking sound gradually became louder, but when she wanted to see who was outside, the peephole was blocked by someone, and the two quarreled at the door.
Chen Shifeng begged in every possible way, hoping that the two could resume their relationship, but they were rejected.
In Liu Nuanxi's words, she already has a new lover, and her relationship with Chen Shifeng cannot return to the past. She hopes that he will stop pestering her.
The paranoid Chen Shifeng was very dissatisfied with this. In anger, he sent a threatening text to Liu Nuanxi, "If you date him, I will do whatever it takes."
On November 22, 2022, six years later, Liu Nuanxi appeared in front of the cameras of many media to be interviewed before the second trial of Jiangge’s mother sued Liu Nuanxi (formerly known as Liu Xin) for infringing Jiang Ge’s right to life.
This time she reorganized the language logic and explained the development process of things that year from her own perspective.
Jiang Ge's case has always attracted the attention of the general public. People are looking forward to what Liu Nuanxi will say before the trial.
Liu Nuanxi appeared in front of the camera
Liu Nuanxi appeared in front of the camera with a natural tone and a relaxed expression. She accepted interviews from many media calmly. In her memories, she was more like an objective and innocent bystander.
That night, Jiang Ge, who had finished her work early, was waiting for her at the subway station. After an hour and a half, Liu Nuanxi finished her work and rushed to the subway station to meet Jiang Ge.
The two of them went to the rental house at home together. When passing by the fence , considering that Liu Nuanxi was in menstruation and was anxious to go home to change sanitary napkins, Jiang Ge asked her to hurry in first, "Hurry up and open the door to change sanitary napkins. I also want to squat in the toilet."
After hearing this, Liu Nuanxi and Jiang Ge gradually separated and walked upstairs one after another. When they reached the envelope on the second floor, Jiang Ge stayed for a while while she put down the umbrella and touched the key to open the door.
At this time, due to the influence of the automatic closer, the door was closed.
When Jiang Ge was about to return home, Chen Shifeng appeared. He stood behind Jiang Ge, covered her mouth with his hand, and quickly picked up a knife and stabbed her neck multiple times, eleven or two times.
Jiang Ge's call came to the room through the door. Liu Nuanxi wanted to open the door, but as soon as a little space was opened, the door was affected by the rebound force and closed again.
Liu Nuanxi wanted to open it, but failed, and Chen Shifeng also left because the handle of the knife in his hand suddenly broke.
The on-site staff was very confused about what she said about the door not being able to open, and Liu Nuanxi also answered on the spot. In her mouth, this situation occurred mainly because of the structure of the Japanese door.
"The door feels very heavy when you push it. If you don't push it, it will close quickly."
On the other hand, she also defended her behavior after returning to China, "I didn't think about confronting her at the beginning. I have been enduring it and letting her vent. I know she is very sad and cannot let go. .
So no matter what she says, I am enduring it, but what kind of situation is it like to endure it now?
Anyone can accuse me of anything, and I really can’t live anymore. "
The public opinion on the Internet has also made her into a low mood, and the abuse is endless.
Just when he didn't know how to face and deal with it, a netizen appeared.
This netizen also gained her trust and even asked Liu Nuanxi to tell him her social platform account and account password, granting him permission to manage the account.
But she also said that everything that happened after the account was not her intention, and she did not want to insult or hurt Jiang Ge’s mother.
The recent discussion on the Internet about the exposure of photos of Jiang Ge's body also troubled her. She did not admit the connection between this matter and her.
also pointed out that before the dossier was in her hands, the contents began to circulate on the Internet platform, "I definitely did not leak this."
The emergence of new materials
On November 22, the second trial of the case was held at the Intermediate People's Court of Qingdao City, Shandong Province, which lasted for 2 hours, and Liu Nuanxi also submitted a new certification material to the court.
Liu Nuanxi appeared in court as the appellant and her entrusted litigation agent Hu Guiyun.
Jiang Ge’s mother did not appear at the scene this time due to physical reasons.
"Due to specific subjective and objective reasons, attorneys Huang Leping and Li Jing and I will not participate in this afternoon's court hearing. We have made explanations to the collegial bench."
And for Jiang Ge’s mother, she has said everything she needs to say, “We have fully expressed our opinions and propositions to the collegial panel on the facts and legal issues related to this case before.”
Liu Nuanxi, who appeared at the court hearing, spoke in the personal statement section and could not control her tears for a moment.
During the appeal process, the defense lawyer argued for her that Chen Shifeng’s original murder target was not Liu Nuanxi, but Jiang Ge, because their private interactions and disagreements in conversation led to the intensification of their conflicts.
Moreover, they also obtained the criminal judgment results and related information about the case in Japan, and quoted the contents of 6 judgments to point out that Chen Shifeng himself had a very high intention to kill Jiang Ge.
Whether it is from the analysis and summary of evidence, or the criminal facts and sentencing reasons, the existence of this kind of murderous intention can be seen.
They believe that these materials can become effective inferential evidence that affects the measurement of tort liability.
According to Liu Nuanxi, there is another piece of evidence that is very beneficial to her, which is Chen Shifeng's answer about abortion fees when the Japanese court heard this matter.
According to Liu Nuanxi’s account, this original file recorded things that Liu Nuanxi did not know before, namely the six private meetings and conversations that Chen Shifeng mentioned between him and Jiang Ge.
On October 14, 2016, Chen Shifeng, who was recording data in the laboratory and preparing to write a paper according to school academic arrangements, met Jiang Ge who came to see him.
The appearance of his girlfriend's roommate made him confused. He didn't know what happened to Liu Nuanxi.
He simply packed up his computer, went out and walked to Jiang Ge, who was standing in the corridor, and asked her what she wanted to do today.
Jiang Ge's answer surprised him because she said that Liu Nuanxi recently found out that she was pregnant with Chen Shifeng's child, but considering the reality, she had no intention of keeping the child.
Therefore, an abortion operation is needed, and the cost of the operation should be borne by Chen Shifeng, so Jiang Ge came here to ask for the operation fee for his roommate.
Jiang Ge was filled with indignation and felt unworthy of his friend. He severely scolded Chen Shifeng and said that the cost of the operation was about 200,000 yen and asked him to get the money quickly.
The quarrel between the two became louder and louder, and the classmates passing by looked at the two curiously.
Chen Shifeng didn't want to continue discussing this topic here, so he agreed with Jiang Ge, and the two went to Chen Shifeng's home to get money, which was about 8 minutes away.
According to Liu Nuanxi’s account, it was here that Jiang Ge took away 100,000 yen and 348 yuan in RMB from Chen Shifeng.
Chen Shifeng’s family received 100,000 yen from his mother in Japan, and 348 yuan in cash was because he returned to China on October 6 and had some remaining money.
This statement also appeared during the first court hearing, but there was a lack of support from the original files at that time. This is what Liu Nuanxi focuses on this time.
Five days after the two met, Liu Nuanxi received two braised chicken legs from Chen Shifeng, saying that they were used to replenish her body and could be shared with her roommate Jiang Ge.
Liu Nuanxi did not expect that he would make these and send them over, but she did not want to accept these chicken legs. She did not want to see him. She regarded this as harassment and told him to leave quickly. If he did this again, he would call the police.
Chen Shifeng wanted to say something but did not continue. He forcefully left the chicken legs and left.
Discussion of the original dossier
There was no dossier before, but this time it was supplemented. Liu Nuanxi said that because she only appeared in court as a witness in the case when she was in Japan, she could not get dossiers about other people.
However, the Tokyo District Prosecutor's Office considered that although the matter was over, it caused a lot of discussion and enthusiasm after they returned to the country, so they handled the matter specially, and Liu Nuanxi obtained parts of the file that had not been obtained before.
During the interrogation and cross-examination in Japan, the prosecutor also asked Liu Nuanxi and Chen Shifeng about related issues. Chen Shifeng admitted the abortion fee and mentioned that he had not asked Liu Nuanxi whether she was pregnant.
Liu Nuanxi insisted that it was precisely because the two met in private six times and broke up on bad terms that they were both emotionally angry and disgusted.
The conflict over the cost of abortion during this pregnancy also intensified, and the two argued for more than 20 minutes.
Liu Nuanxi deduced that it was after this incident that Chen Shifeng was blocked by Jiang Ge, so Chen Shifeng came over on the night of the incident to ask Jiang Ge about his girlfriend's pregnancy.
Liu Nuanxi also pointed out that during the trial, Chen Shifeng admitted these contents.
Liu Nuanxi even used this as evidence to say that Chen Shifeng's target was Jiang Ge, not herself.
As Chen Shifeng said in the dossier, some impressions about Jiang Ge: "She walked in aggressively wearing shoes. I think she just said to Jiang, 'You must take off your shoes before entering the house.'
Jiang Ge said in the message that when he made some words and deeds that made Liu Nuanxi unhappy, he hoped Liu Nuanxi could speak out and communicate with her.
also said that these actions were not intentional or intentional, but just an impulsive reaction.
Liu Nuanxi replied, "Why did you suddenly say this?" However, the two did not have further discussions, and Liu Nuanxi's mobile phone has always retained this content.
Liu Nuanxi also mentioned that she and Chen Shifeng were already in a relatively peaceful state at that time, and the two even agreed to meet and chat the next day. Therefore, Chen Shifeng actually had no motive to kill him on the day of the incident.
It is difficult to confirm Chen Shifeng’s motive for killing and whether it was a deliberate killing, but Liu Nuanxi defended herself.
"First, if it was aimed at me, when I went up to the second floor and put some distance between me and Jiang Ge, it was the best time for Chen Shifeng to strike, but he did not do so;
Second, after Chen Shifeng hugged Jiang Ge from behind, he directly hit the vital point with a sharp knife. If it was to kill me, why did he stab him once and then again after realizing that it was not the case? One knife?
Third, I opened the door in the middle, and Chen Shifeng could have rushed in and attacked me, but he did not do so. "
But this statement was too "reasonable" and unbelievably reasonable. Wang Zhian of "The Situation" stood up to refute her words.
Chen Shifeng admitted that he had related matters about abortion fees during his last communication with the police, and there was no relevant explanation in the three previous statements.
During the trial in Japan, Master Chen, as the defendant, can read the files provided by the prosecutor and learn from them what evidence is used to prosecute him.
Therefore, his words are probably not the truth, but a new statement to defend himself. He can reorganize his response words based on these evidences, and the prosecutor does not have time to find new evidence to reply to his new statement.
He tried hard to mitigate his crime, describing himself as manslaughter due to emotional control, rather than intentional killing, and finally changed the killing target, and explained that he did not say it before because he lacked courage and was afraid to face it.
In fact, on the day of the incident, when Chen Shifeng learned that Liu Nuanxi had a new relationship, his emotions were already out of control.
He returned to school, took a knife from the laboratory, and sent her a threatening text saying "I will risk everything".
Considering Chen Shifeng's personal financial situation, it is difficult to give out the money generously, and he is not 100% sure that Liu Nuanxi is pregnant and preparing to have an abortion.
Because he himself received sponsorship from others, his daily part-time income was very small. When he and Liu Nuanxi shared a house, Liu Nuanxi also borne the rent of 30,000 yen.
At the same time, he was not sure when he asked about the abortion cost, so he changed it from the exact 14th to around this date.
At the same time, Wang Zhian also said that these statements in court were only used by Chen Shifeng to refute the prosecutor's personal opinions. Under Japanese law, these words will not be regarded as evidence.
Regardless of his words and deeds during the interview in front of the camera, the truth of the matter is still waiting for the court to hear. After 2 hours of trial, the news of the adjournment came.
The outcome of the case will be announced at another date.
On November 22, 2022, Liu Nuanxi was interviewed after the court adjourned. There was nothing unusual about her expression, as if the matter had nothing to do with her.
"On the night of the crime, Chen Shifeng went to find Jiang Ge, and his target was also Jiang Ge." Liu Nuanxi said confidently in front of the camera.
We cannot be sure whether the words in her mouth are true or false. At present, the only thing we can do is to wait for the day when the truth comes out.
Although the matter is not over yet, I believe there will be a day when responsibility will be determined.
-End-
editor | Zhang Ah Zhang, Shu Shu
text | Mingzhou
