Liangshan is an independent anti-government organization. No matter how bad the court is, it is impossible for such an armed team to exist hundreds of miles away from Kyoto. If you fail to destroy it once, you can do it ten more times. What is the loss of soldiers and generals? Will losing one million soldiers hurt Song Huizong his own hair?
is a hero in Liangshan. He deals with attacks again and again. Can he not hurt a soldier or general every time he wins a big victory? Shi Wengong also shot to death Chao Gai ? Are you thinking too ideal? And just the strategic depth of "800 miles of water" is a defeat in Liangshan.
Whether to die against the court or sacrifice one's life for the country, I'm afraid most people still have to choose the latter.
In fact, some heroes represented by Yang Zhi and Lin Chong were simply forced to go to Liangshan because they had no way to serve the country and could not find a job in the court and the officialdom. Shi Jin also wanted to join the old generals under the command of the Gonggong, "seek a background and seek happiness for half a lifetime", but refused the invitation from Zhu Wu and others.
died in battle in the battle, and sacrificed his life for the country and died. After their death, the emperor still "sighed" and issued an order to "give each apology", "If there are descendants, they will go to the capital and inherit the official title according to their names; if there are no descendants, they will rely on the title of temple to enjoy sacrifices where they are located", which can be regarded as realizing the ideal of "enclosing a wife and a son" in Song Jiang - not only Song Jiang, but also Yang Zhi, Wu Song , and Lu Junyi have all mentioned "enclosing a wife and a son". This is at least the common ideal of some Liangshan heroes.
The original idea of recruitment was opposed by many people. But in addition to the "lofty" ideal of changing dynasty and generations of Li Kui "Brother Chao Gai became the great emperor and Brother Song Jiang became the little emperor", most people oppose it because they are afraid that "the civil and military officials in the dynasty are mostly evil and deceived by the holy conspiracy" and that "recruiting peace is not helpful": it is not that they do not want to recruit peace, but because they are afraid that the recruitment will not be successful. When the specific operation is implemented, the number of voices of opposition gradually decreases. Even the Lu Zhishen , which proposed "I'll give up, I'll go and take advantage of it tomorrow", did not surrender obediently afterwards?
" Water Margin " is a tragedy , but the protagonist of the tragedy is the entire Liangshan cause, and the resistance action that died in the middle. And for every hero, not everyone's ending is tragic.
Is Song Jiang’s revenge right or wrong? If he insisted on resisting, but was finally wiped out by the court and wiped out the entire army (Isn’t this the result of Fang La?), how would you answer this question?
After all, the Northern Song Dynasty was destroyed by external troubles, not by the uprising of the people. Even literary works cannot tamper with this fact.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-