Zhou Yu, Lusu , Lu Meng , Lu Xun are the four commanders under Dongwu Sun Quan in different periods. The four have their own characteristics and their talents are different. If you want to compare comprehensive abilities, you need to make a comparison from four aspects: military ability, employment ability, strategic ability, and comprehensive abilities.
1. Zhou Yu
1. Military capability: 90 points.
Zhou Yu's military capabilities are mainly reflected in the Battle of Chibi and the Battle of Nanjun . The strategic significance of these two battles is very great, directly preventing Cao Cao from unifying the world and changing the history of the Three Kingdoms. The Battle of Chibi and Nanjun are both classic battles of winning with less and winning with more in the Three Kingdoms period, and they are both the achievements of Zhou Yu's leader in defeating Cao Cao.
Since Cao Cao began to lead his troops to start his business, although he has suffered some setbacks occasionally, he has always been victorious. Cao Cao started to raise an army from Yanzhou, the four battles in the Central Plains, and spent ten years to recover the entire Central Plains. Then he defeated the powerful Yuan Shao in the Battle of Guandu, and then took another seven years to unify the entire Hebei, with its power at its peak.
Zhou Yu
Cao Cao went south Jingzhou At first, it was very smooth. Jingzhou directly surrendered, which made Cao Cao's ambition to unify the world began to expand. In the Battle of Red Cliff, the comparison of the power between the two sides was so great, but before the war, Zhou Yu saw Cao Cao's weakness and calculated the calculation for Sun Quan, believing that Cao Cao would be defeated. Zhou Yu had three reasons:
1), Cao Cao had worries, and there was still Ma Chao , and Han Sui's power did not obey Cao Cao.
2), Cao Cao abandoned the cavalry and used his weaknesses to fight us with the navy.
3), Cao Cao came from afar, and he must be unacceptable to the local environment.
This is Zhou Yu's military ability. He could see the weaknesses of a powerful enemy and was already sure before the war. He had a foresight to defeat Cao Cao later. In the Battle of Red Cliff, Zhou Yu adopted Huang Gai's plan of surrender and fire attack, and used Huang Gai to pretend to surrender Cao Cao as a breakthrough point, and then ordered Huang Gai to attack Cao's camp with a fire ship on the day of surrender, and eventually defeated Cao Cao in one battle.
Zhou Yu won the Battle of Red Cliff and the Battle of Nanjun
After the Battle of Red Cliff, it was the Battle of Nanjun. Zhou Yu continued to lead the Sun and Liu coalition forces to siege Cao Ren in Nanjun. After more than a year of war, Cao Ren retreated. Zhou Yu was also injured in this battle, but Zhou Yu still endured the pain and patrolled the camp with injuries to motivate the soldiers. This is the ability as the head coach, and finally won the Battle of Nanjun. This is Zhou Yu's military ability.
2. Employment ability: 95 points.
Zhou Yu listened to the opinions of his subordinates in the Battle of Chibi and Nanjun, and then implemented them correctly and defeated the enemy. This is Zhou Yu's employment. For example, Huang Gai proposed a plan of fraudulent surrender + fire attack to Zhou Yu. As the head coach, we must first judge whether this plan is feasible? How to implement it? How can we ensure success? There is a lot of work to be done from the proposal to the implementation of the strategy. We must constantly coordinate personnel and prepare materials. These are Zhou Yu's work.
is the same in the battle of Nanjun. Ganning suggests that Zhou Yu sneak attack Yiling. Zhou Yu agreed after consideration. After that, Cao Ren sent five or six thousand cavalry to attack Yiling. Zhou Yu followed Lu Meng's advice and sent Lingtong to guard the camp, sent Lu Meng to rescue Yiling, and finally defeated Cao Ren's army, and finally won the victory of the battle of Nanjun and captured Jingzhou Nanjun.
Zhou Yu, Lu Su, Lu Meng, Lu Xun
From a series of processes, Zhou Yu, as the main general, can use people correctly and coordinate the work of his generals, and his ability to employ people is also good.
3. Strategic ability: 80 points .
Because Zhou Yu listened to the opinions of his subordinates in the Battle of Chibi and Nanjun, he won the war because Zhou Yu's own strategic ability was reduced. Although as the head coach, strategy is not a specialty, it can also be seen that Zhou Yu's shortcomings are strategy, so Zhou Yu's strategy style is lower than others.
4, comprehensive talent: 265 points .
Zhou Yu is a man from a great family, tall and handsome, and proficient in music and military affairs. Chen Shou commented on Zhou Yu in " Three Kingdoms " this way:
"Three Kingdoms Scriptures Zhou Yu, Lu Su Biography of Lu Meng": Zhou Yu and Lu Su Jian's arbitrary and wise appearance are indeed geniuses.
Chen Shou said that Zhou Yu and Lu Su made quick decisions and performed beyond their talents, and were outstanding talents in the world.
Lu Su and Zhou Yu
2. Lu Su
1. Military capability: 80 points.
2. Employment ability: 85 points.
3. Strategic ability: 95 points
4. Comprehensive ability: 260 points.
Lu Su is a politician and strategist, but not a military strategist. Lu Su has the highest strategic ability and vision among the four. As early as around 200 AD, Lu Su believed that the Han Dynasty could not be revived and suggested that Sun Quan occupy the Yangtze River and govern the Yangtze River with Cao Cao. This may be the earliest world strategy in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, which was 7 years earlier than Longzhong's strategy.
Lu Su was able to detect the rapid changes in the situation at the critical moment when Cao Cao went south and Liu Biao died of illness, and took the initiative to ask to go to Jingzhou to find out the news. This kind of political sensitivity is beyond the reach of others. At the same time, Lu Su was also the first person to promote the Sun-Liu Alliance, and the person who contributed the most to the Sun-Liu Alliance.
Lu Su's strategy is basically correct. If Sun Quan implemented it completely according to his strategy, it would be very likely that the three families would not return to Jin later, but would continue to maintain the situation of the Three Kingdoms. It was precisely because Sun Quan sneaked into Jingzhou a few years after Lu Su's death. On the surface, Sun Quan seized Jingzhou and obtained political benefits, but in fact it broke the balance of the Three Kingdoms, weakened the power of Shu Han, and led to the first destruction of Shu Han decades later.
Lu Su and Lu Meng
Shu Han fall, and Eastern Wu will surely die. This is a relationship of the loss of lips and teeth. Only Lu Su understands this truth in the entire Eastern Wu. No one understands this. Only Lu Su has the farthest vision. Others cannot compare with others. Lu Su did not lead troops to fight during the Three Kingdoms period. The only time was during the Xiangshui confrontation, and he confronted Guan Yu in Yiyang. Lu Su went to the meeting with Guan Yu as a weak scholar. He was alone and had no fear. This is Lu Su.
Lu Su is an outstanding talent in Chen Shou's eyes who is ranked alongside Zhou Yu. This alone is an affirmation of Lu Su. Lu Su's strength is strategy, followed by personnel, and then military. During his tenure as governor, he was at least not worse than Lu Meng.
3. Lu Meng
Military capability: 85 points.
employability: 85 points.
strategy ability: 85 points
comprehensive talent: 255 points.
Lu Meng was promoted from a low-level officer step by step by step by step by step. Lu Meng is a very diligent and loves to study. Originally, Lu Meng was an uneducated person. Although he was brave and capable in combat, not many people looked down on him. For example, Lu Su looked down on Lu Meng. Later, during the conversation between the two, Lu Su learned that Lu Meng was constantly studying and studying, so he looked at Lu Meng with admiration and said the allusion of "Scholars should look at each other with admiration". At the same time, there is also the allusion of "Wu Xia A Meng".
Lu Meng
Lu Meng's military capabilities are mainly reflected in strategy. For example, in the confrontation between Xiangshui, Lu Meng led his army to attack the three southern counties of Jingzhou, and they were all captured by strategies rather than hard attacks. Especially Lingling Prefect Hao Pu was unwilling to surrender, so Lu Meng found Hao Pu's friend and wrote a letter to Hao Pu. The content of this letter was to fool Hao Pu, saying that Liu Bei cannot be used, and our army has increased. If we do not surrender, it means we do not know the situation. Hao Pu was really scared by Lu Meng, so he surrendered.
Lu Meng is best at fooling the enemy. Hao Pu is an example. Guan Yu, Shiren , Mifang are also examples. Lu Meng deceived Guan Yu by pretending to be sick in exchange for Guan Yu's defense against Eastern Wu. When he captured Jingzhou, Lu Meng used the strategy of crossing the river in white clothes to sneak attack Jingzhou, persuaded Shiren and Mi Fang to surrender, and then treated Guan Yu's soldiers well, dismantled Guan Yu's soldiers, and won the victory of the battle of Jingzhou.
"The Romance of the Three Kingdoms Zhou Yu, Lu Su, Biography of Lu Meng": Lu Meng is brave and scheming, knows military strategies, and is treacherous, Hao Pu, and Qin Guan Yu, the most wonderful thing. Even though he was lightly killed, he finally restrained himself. With the power of a national soldier, how could he be just a military general?
But Lu Meng also has a short-sightedness. He thought that seizing Jingzhou would make Eastern Wu stable for a long time, but he did not expect that the three families would return to Jin later. Overall, Lu Meng's overall strength was good, but among the four major governors, he was still not as good as the other three.
Zhou Yu and Lu Meng
4, Lu Xun
Military capability: 95 points.
employability: 95 points.
Strategy ability: 95 points
Comprehensive ability: 285 points .
Lu Xun's military capabilities are mainly reflected in Fight of Yiling and Fight of Shiting . Lu Xun's performance in theFight of Yiling was perfect, and they both won by strategy. Liu Bei launched theFight of Yiling very smoothly at first, which makes people suspect that this was Lu Xun's strategic retreat, lengthening Liu Bei's supply line. Then Lu Xun used the dangerous terrain to block Liu Bei, making Liu Bei powerless to advance and no way to retreat.
Then Lu Xun took advantage of the two mistakes made by Liu Bei and launched a fatal attack. One was that Liu Bei gave up the navy, and the other was that Liu Bei set up camp in the dense forest. After Lu Xun discovered it, he quickly completed the preparation for the general attack on Liu Bei. The navy was surrounded by Liu Bei's army, and then attacked Liu Bei's army stationed in the dense forest with the main fire. Liu Bei's entire army was wiped out. This was all Lu Xun's contribution, and the strategy came from Lu Xun, who was the chief strategist of the entire battle, which was Lu Xun's strength.
Lu Xun
Lu Xun also commanded and defeated Cao Wei's famous general Cao Xiu , but he gave up the opportunity to expand the results of the war. Even so, he can be regarded as the most talented person in Eastern Wu. Lu Xun is a politician and military strategist. He not only has strong military capabilities, but also has strong political capabilities. He has the highest comprehensive capabilities, stronger than Zhou Yu. No one calls Zhou Yu politician or military strategist, but Lu Xun is.
You can also see the abilities of the two people from Lu Xun's biography. Lu Xun is the only one in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms who is a separate biography like Zhuge Liang , while Zhou Yu's biography is with Lu Su and Lu Mengquan. This treatment is the same as Zhuge Liang, which is the embodiment of ability. Chen Shou commented on Lu Xun in "The Three Kingdoms" like this:
"The Three Kingdoms Biography of Lu Xun": Lu Xun was in great strength in the spring and autumn, and his reputation was not yet established. If he defeated it, he would be as good as his ambition. I have both extraordinary strategies and accused the power of knowing talents, so I can help great things. When he was loyal and sincere, he was worried that the country would be destroyed and that he would be a minister of the country.
Chen Shou said that Lu Xun was a minister of the country and a pillar of the country. He was equivalent to Zhuge Liang's status in Shu Han. This is not comparable to Zhou Yu. Zhou Yu was just famous and had a stronger influence than Lu Xun. Speaking of comprehensive abilities, Zhou Yu was not as good as Lu Xun.
So the comparison of Zhou Yu, Lu Su, Lu Meng and Lu Xun's talents is:
Lu Xun is the strongest, Zhou Yu is second, Lu Su is again, and Lu Meng is last.
