As we all know, Jin Yong once overhauled his novels twice, and these two overhauls were also mixed with several minor revisions. Of course, Jin Yong did not have the publishing house to publish these minor revisions every time, so Jin Yong's novels still only have serialization a

It is well known that Jin Yong has overhauled his novels twice, and these two overhauls were also mixed with several minor revisions. Of course, Jin Yong did not have these minor revisions published by the publishing house every time, so Jin Yong's novels are still only There are three major versions: serialization, triplicate, and newly revised version. Generally speaking, Jin Yong's novels are actually the most readable in Sanlian, but they have the fewest new loopholes. After all, Jin Yong has changed it so many times, and there will never be more loopholes. However, due to some modifications, Jin Yong has also appeared to be rational. The fun has declined, which is why the triple version has better reviews than the newly revised version.

But in fact, in terms of fun and exaggeration, the serial version may actually be higher than the triple version, but this also causes the serial version to have the most loopholes among the three versions of the novel. The triple version can be considered a balance between loopholes and fun. the best. Swordsman is one of Jin Yong's best works. Here are the modifications of the three versions, which ones are better and which ones still have problems or bring new problems after the modifications.

Xiaoao Jianghu

Modify the reasonable parts

1. Delete and write down redundant characters

Many redundant characters have been deleted. For example, in the serialized version of Xiaoao there is a peerless master named Jingyue Sheni, Qu Feiyan After showing the stunt "Hundred Birds to the Phoenix" of Demon Cult in front of the decent masters, in order to conceal his identity, he said that he learned the one-finger Zen from his mother. This sentence scared all the masters present and felt that they would rather believe it. Yes, it was unbelievable that she didn't exist, so I stopped asking about her life experience. However, such a master didn't provide any plot arrangements, so Jin Yong's triple version deleted this person.

In addition, Qu Feiyan survived in the serialized version, but there is no follow-up. At the same time, Qu Feiyan in the serialized version is even more amazing than the later version. In addition to being weird, his martial arts is not weak. He is so young. He has mastered the Demon Cult's unique skill "Hundred Birds Pay Attendance to the Phoenix". Although his skill is not yet at an advanced level, this skill makes the top-notch masters change their colors after hearing it. Such an extraordinary little girl has no further story after Qu Yang Liu Zhengfeng died. It is obviously an omission, and it would be troublesome to add a separate story line. Therefore, Jin Yong weakened Qu Feiyan's sense of existence in subsequent versions, and "destroyed the flower with a ruthless hand", causing Qu Feiyan to die under the sword of Da Songyang's hand Fei Bin.

The Death of Qu Feiyan

The concurrent serial version of Xiaoao Ping Yi Zhi also has a senior brother named Ren Wujiang, which involves a mysterious force called Qianqiu Palace, which is opened every thirty years. There are unknown treasures in it, including the famous murderer Ping Yi Zhi. His senior brother, the white-haired boy Ren Wujiang, was determined to go, but pingyizhi was extremely afraid of his senior brother, so he gave up the opportunity. When Ren Wujiang was young, he did not dare to go to Qianqiu Palace because of his lack of martial arts. Later, he trained hard for decades Only the Dragon Elephant Palm dares to go. Ping Yizhi was still worried that his senior brother would harm him, so he repeatedly expressed his loyalty to him and said that he did not plan to go to Qianqiu Palace to see what happened. Ren Wujiang was evaluated by Ning Zhongze as having much higher internal strength than Ping Yizhi, and it is known that Ping Yizhi's internal strength performance is higher than one of the six immortals of Taogu , Yue Buqun also believed that the internal strength of one of the six immortals was better than his own Just slightly weaker.

This person's martial arts skills are undoubtedly extremely good, but there is no subsequent plot. This kind of behavior of writing a hidden line and then digging a hole without filling it is naturally more appropriate to delete this line directly. In addition to

, many redundant characters have been deleted, so I won’t introduce them one by one here.

flat one finger

2. Adjustment of the martial arts positioning of some characters

There are many adjustments to the martial arts positioning of some characters. Here we only focus on the characters who are important in the plot, such as Lin Zhennan. Jin Yong is actually a very successful businessman in some aspects. It is obvious that readers don’t like to watch masters simply abuse their food, as this does not show the strength of the master at all, so in the serial version, a character is often set to be strong first, and then let a stronger master defeat him. This is the case with Lin Zhennan . Lin Zhennan's initial martial arts skills were quite impressive, and were taught by Lin Yuantu himself. When he was sixteen years old, on Lin Yuantu's 70th birthday, Lin Zhennan was asked to demonstrate his martial arts on the spot, which amazed all the heroes present. .The praise of the heroes present may be said to give Lin Yuantu face, but Lin Yuantu doesn't even know how much his grandson weighs, right? Could it be that the grandson was allowed to go up and act like a good boy?

Of course, the serial version was basically designed to attract readers. Later, Jin Yong's reputation became too great, and there was no need for this method to attract readers, so Lin Zhennan returned to his position and was a rookie.

Lin Zhennan

In addition to Lin Zhennan, the newly revised version of Linghu Chong has some detailed modifications, which weakens Linghu Chong's strength, but actually makes the plot more reasonable. That is, before the new cultivation, Linghu Chong had the ability to sense the opponent's attack with his internal force. He didn't need to look at it with his eyes, he could sense it with his internal force. When Linghu Chong rescued the people of Hengshan who were besieged by Songshan Mountain, the old version described Linghu Chong's battle against the three people.

There was a roar of wind behind him, and three long swords struck him at the same time. Not only was Linghu Chong's swordsmanship superb, but his internal strength was also unparalleled by few in the world. [Hearing the sound of the golden blade chopping the wind, sensing the internal energy], Linghu Chong naturally knew the enemy. When he came, he swung out his long sword and stabbed the enemy's wrist. The three people were extremely skilled in martial arts and managed to dodge quickly, but the tall man still had a cut on the back of his hand and was dripping with blood.

In the newly revised version, it was changed so that Linghu Chong could clearly see the incoming attack of the three people at a glance, so he could counterattack the sneak attacks of the three. Moreover, before the new revision, Linghu Chong used his sword with his backhand without looking back while talking to Er Ding. To deal with three people, it can be seen that it relies entirely on internal force induction, but in the newly revised version, it was changed to Linghu Chong's eyes slightly squinting, but he still looked a little bit.

This modification should actually be to make the plot in Siguoya Cave reasonable later, because Linghu Chong in the cave is really dangerous because he can't see anything, and it also emphasizes that Linghu Chong is better than the dozen or so people who have practiced listening to the wind. A blind person who has the art of identifying weapons is himself blind. This is obviously contrary to the previous article that Linghu Chong has the ability to sense internal force and attack.

Linghu Chong

In addition, the serial version also arranged for Yu Canghai and Yue Buqun to practice magical skills that no one in their sect has practiced for hundreds of years. However, as the plot develops, the positioning of the two is not worthy of such With high qualifications, it was naturally deleted in the Sanlian version.

3. The Death of the Ten Elders of the Demon Sect

In the original version, Feng Qingyang said that he had killed the ten elders of the Demon Sect. He even emphasized that when Feng Qingyang said this, he seemed to have crushed ten ants to death ants It's the same understatement. Jin Yong should be saying here that Feng Qingyang is unfathomable, but Jin Yong obviously forgot that he had arranged for the ten elders of the Demon Sect to be trapped by the Five Mountains Sword Sect through conspiracy and trickery, and cursed the Five Mountains on the stone wall. The sword sect is victorious in combat and uses conspiracy and tricks. Fan Song, one of the ten elders, the "Powerful God and Demon", used his sharp giant ax and divine power to cut through mountains hundreds of feet before he died of exhaustion. This has nothing to do with Feng Qingyang. Based on this fact, wouldn't it mean that Feng Qingyang killed one of the ten elders with a despicable conspiracy, and he also lightly thought that he had killed ten ants? This is in the high-level Black Wind Qingyang, right? So the plot was modified.

4. The origin of the Sunflower Book

The Sunflower Book is an important plot clue in Swordsman. In the serialized version, the Sunflower Book was not written by a eunuch, but by a couple.

The names of the couple are unknown, but some people say that the boy's name has the character "Kui" and the girl's name has the character "花", so they are collectively called the "Sunflower Collection", but most of them are just guesses. The couple was very affectionate at first, but later they fell out for some reason. When they wrote the "Sunflower Book", they were in their prime and their martial arts skills were at their peak. After they turned against each other, they never met each other again, and a martial arts secret manual was also divided into two parts. There are two parts. The secret book written by a man has always been called the Qian Jing, and the one written by a woman is called the Kun Jing. It is estimated that Jin Yong later felt that it was unreasonable for the couple to practice martial arts in the palace, and the plot of the couple turning against each other and fighting for supremacy was similar to the story of Wang Chongyang and Lin Chaoying, so he deleted it.

Sunflower Manual

5. The origin of the Zixia Secret Manual

The serial version of the Zixia Secret Manual should have been created by the ancestor of the Huashan Qi Sect after peeking at part of the Sunflower Manual. However, because he had a low understanding of the profound martial arts such as the Sunflower Manual, he There are words left in the book: "Zixia's secret book is the beginning of entry; Sunflower's treasure book is to reach the peak". But the problem is that the two martial arts of Zixia and Sunflower are completely different from each other. The training methods recorded in Zixia's Secret Manual are typical Confucian methods of self-cultivation and character cultivation. Whether it is to ward off evil spirits or Sunflower, the character of the person after practicing will become extremely Abnormal, the two are in direct conflict. At the same time, the introductory part of sunflower or evil spirits refers to Lin Pingzhi The effect of cultivation is to greatly increase the speed without increasing the strength. Zixia magic skill is obviously not this kind of skill. On the contrary, Yue Buqun described his master's defeat with sword Zong uses the Zixia magic skill to "use clumsiness to overcome skill and use stillness to stop", so it is normal to delete the connection between Zixia Secret Manual and Sunflower Book.

6. The Star Absorbing Technique was changed to be derived from the Beiming Divine Art

In the newly revised version of the plot, the Star Absorbing Act was changed from being mainly derived from the Huigong Dafa to being derived from the Beiming Divine Art. Here are a few more words, serialized version In the Eight Parts of Tianlong, neither Bei Ming nor Star Absorbing has the ability to absorb people's inner energy. Duan Yu Absorbing people's inner energy is the Zhuhu magic skill that he learned by chance. Therefore, absorbing stars has nothing to do with the Xiaoyao sect, and the triple version strengthens Xiaoyao. faction, so the star-absorbing method was changed to mainly stem from the Huigong Dafa, but the problem here is actually quite big. The biggest difference between the Huigong Dafa and the Beiming Divine Art is that one can absorb people's internal energy, and the other can only destroy people's internal energy. Although the star-absorbing method There is a problem with internal force compatibility, but how can we say it mainly stems from chemical energy? Therefore, the new revised version completely puts aside the relationship between absorbing stars and transforming energy. It originated from Beiming, but there are problems in the cultivation of later generations.

Ren Woxing uses the power of attracting stars.

Unreasonable modifications

There are relatively few unreasonable changes, but there are still some. The first is that Ren Woxing integrates the power of attracting stars but it is still dead.

1. From forcibly transforming martial arts to integrating martial arts, Ren Woxing still died.

The new version specially improved Ren Woxing’s martial arts positioning and qualifications, allowing him to find a way to integrate the alien energy absorbed by the Star Absorbing Dafa. , and the narrator also affirmed that this is a "proper method" and once again emphasized that it is integration.

He was imprisoned at the bottom of the West Lake for twelve years without any distractions. Only then did he realize the proper way to integrate the internal strength of different schools in his body. Only by practicing this "Star Absorbing Technique" would he not be in danger of suffering a backlash.

But because the ending of the final plot kill in Let Me Go cannot be changed, this modification becomes very confusing.

2. Feng Qingyang’s seniority modification

In the original version, Feng Qingyang was the grand master uncle of Yue Buqun and the grand master uncle of Linghu Chong. He was two generations older than Yue Buqun and three generations older than Linghu Chong. Because of this , regardless of Fang Zheng, Fangsheng, Chongxu, these three people who are older than Yue Buqun, all respect Feng Qingyang extremely, calling him "Mr. Feng" and "Senior Feng Qingyang" because In the serial version, Feng Qingyang is indeed their senior, but after the revision, Feng Qingyang is younger, which makes it weird for them to call Feng Qingyang their senior.

In addition, the triple version also retains the loophole that Feng Qingyang is two generations older than Yue Buqun in the serial version, that is, when Xiang Wentian took Linghu Chong to Meizhuang, he said that Linghu Chong was Yue Buqun's master. Uncle, the successor of Feng Qingyang. According to the serial version, Feng Qingyang is two generations older than Yue Buqun. Feng Qingyang’s successor is naturally Yue Buqun’s uncle, but in the triple version, Feng Qingyang himself has been changed to Yue Buqun. Uncle Qun, shouldn't his successor be the same generation as Yue Buqun? Therefore, Xinxiu also revised this loophole and changed it to lie to Xiang Wentian and say that Linghu Chong was Feng Qingyang's distant cousin, so that he would be older than Yue Buqun.

风清阳