On February 17, the third season of "Youth With You" and the fourth season of "Creation Camp", two popular domestic talent shows, were broadcast at the same time. This time can be seen as a head-on pit between the two top talent shows.
As we all know, the popularity of "Youth with You 2" in 2020 crushes "Creation Camp 2020", and even the debut hard candy girl 303 is not as good as THE9. At that time, many viewers who liked "Creation Camp" complained about "Creation Camp 2020". They felt that "Youth with You 2" had taken advantage of the early launch of the broadcast, so that it sucked away the heat of "Creation Camp 2020" and caused it now Situation.
However, this time the two major drafts were broadcast at the same time, "Creation Camp" still fell short. As can be seen from the current variety show popularity rankings, the third season of "Youth with You" is still ahead of the fourth season of "Creation Camp". Maybe this time there are still many viewers who feel unconvinced, but judging from the broadcast effects of the two programs, "Creation Camp 2021" is not wronged at all (because the program name is too long, "Blue 3" and "Creation 4" are used instead. ).
1. The mentor lineup "Blue 3" crushes "Creation 4"
I believe audiences who have watched the two programs should know that this time, "City 3" and "Creation 4" are both Come prepared.
"Blue 3" invited LISA mentors who performed well in the previous season, while the other mentors were replaced by Wilber Pan and Li Ronghao, the PD was replaced by Li Yuchun, and the assistant teacher was Yu Shuxin, who made his debut in the previous season. This lineup is luxurious. Compared to the previous season, it is an upgrade.
"Creation 4" also put a lot of effort this time, invited the famous domestic actor Deng Chao, the last season of "Sister Riding the Wind and Waves" performed well in tranquility, the more popular singer Zhou Shen in recent years, Zhou Zhennan, who successfully debuted with the first place in the finals in "Creation Camp 2019", Liu Yiyun, teammate of Song Qian's FX team, and the last assistant coach is Zheng Naixin who debuted in "Creation Camp 2020".
From the lineup of mentors,The foreign mentor Liu Yiyun of "Genesis 4" is obviously against LISA, Zhou Shen against Li Ronghao, Zhou Zhennan against Pan Weibo, Zheng Naixin against Yu Shuxin.
As for Deng Chao and Tranquility, from a professional point of view, they are basically mascots to absorb heat.
Although many people may not like to hear that, it is a very funny thing to comment on singers and jumpers as Deng Chao and tranquil actors.
Let's talk about Zhou Zhennan and Zhou Shen as mentors. Both of them have surnames Zhou, but they have different reviews. Zhou Shen has gained popularity in recent years with his superb singing skills, and his ethereal voice has the feeling of overwhelming the sky. Zhou Zhennan has only just made his debut for 2 years, and he is far from Zhou Shen in terms of fame and strength.
Not only that, Zhou Zhennan was also called the "son of Lai Lai" by netizens. The reason was that Zhou Zhennan’s father’s company had financial problems and commercial disputes, so that Zhou Zhennan was involved, so Zhou Zhennan’s joining will inevitably give " Genesis 4 brought a negative impact.
Of course, netizens will still be unconvinced just to say that the mentor lineup of "Genesis 4" is crushed, so take a look at the opening shows of "Creation 3" and "Genesis 4" mentors. In "Blue 3", Li Ronghao, Pan Weibo, and LISA burned the audience as soon as the opening. The full 30 minutes thrilled the trainees present. Some people were even more excited and left tears. This is "Qing 3" The strength of the instructor. On the other hand, in "Genesis 4", all the instructors and teaching assistants spent only 10 minutes in total. This is really overwhelming.
2. The reform of the competition system is slightly lower
If the gap in the lineup of the mentor is obviously a problem of the mentor's own strength, then the change in the competition system highlights the unqualified professional level. Both "Genesis 4" and "Chen 3" were originally rated by their instructors. However, this season "Genesis 4" took a different approach. It actually required players to score. The extra points of the instructor are not important. It seems that It is to weaken the role of the mentor. Look at the tutor Deng Chao and tranquility,It seems to make people understand something, is it because the instructors are not professional enough, so the players are allowed to score themselves?
On the other hand, in "Blue 3", Li Ronghao and Pan Weibo are both well-known singers, and LISA is also known for dancing, plus Li Yuchun, the originator of the domestic audition debut, so "Blue 3" has everything Ability to continue the previous rating system, and the instructor will give points and ratings, which demonstrates that the competition system reform of "Chuang 4" is slightly lower.
3. Foreign players become the only bright spot
The lineup of tutors has been criticized by others, and the reform of the competition system is slightly low-level. Isn't there any advantage in "Genesis 4"?
of course, because this time "Genesis 4" still has a big change, such as the joining of a large number of foreign players.
Many netizens may have discovered that this season's "Chuang 4" domestic players are generally low in appearance. In fact, this defect is related to too many talent shows in previous years. Men's group talent shows such as "Idol Trainee", "Youth Have You", and "Creation Camp 2019" have selected too many high-value artists to debut. This has also become a barrier to the appearance of domestic players.
This time, "Genesis 4" took a different approach and invited a large number of foreign players, which made up for the lack of appearance of the players. These foreign players not only have superb looks, but they also crush domestic trainees. This is a visual feast for the audience.
Take Riki for example, he is a world-class choreographer, and he has choreographed many groups of SM. Such a person is a child abuse, or a dimensionality reduction attack.
Of course, there are advantages and disadvantages. The wonderful performance of foreign players indirectly made domestic players faceless. This seems to verify Zhang Yixing’s words in the talent show, "You want to be a singer so much, you have to use your strength and works. If you don’t have one, why are you? Come here?".
Watching the performances of domestic players on stage, and then looking at the performances of foreign players, don’t be uncompetitive.It is impossible to imagine how many foreign players will be selected to make their debut in "Genesis 4" this time. This is simply a tragedy.
Of course, everything has to be better. After all, "Creation 4" is also a talent show, and it has to compete with "Blue 3" in ratings and popularity. The addition of foreign players can bring enthusiasm and attention to "Genesis 4" and improve the level of stage performance, which is enough. As for who can make his debut, it depends on the domestic players themselves.
.
