nba playoffs are in full swing, but recently there have been rare tears in the domestic NBA media circles. The former male basketball player Ma Jian and the well-known basketball commentator (and the boss) Yang Yi about the basketball commentator’s "Basketball Commentary" Whether the players need to be basketball professionals" conducted an irrational exchange.
First, on September 18, Ma Jian commented on his correct prediction of the Nuggets tie-breaker victory over the Clippers, and commented on "xxxx comfortable?" alluding to some commentators’ prediction errors, and then referring directly to the current domestic NBA broadcast comments in communication with netizens. Monopolized by Yang Yi Company.
That night, Yang Huahua, who has always been hard-mouthed, also launched the film in person, refuting Ma Jian's views one by one.
. This is how things have happened. At present, although our domestic teams often fight on the Internet, the circle of domestic commentators has not been affected by the "rice circle culture", and generally maintains the general harmony of gentleness, courtesy and frugality. It was the first time that influential celebrities were torn apart and almost swearing.
One, you must understand the background when you eat melon-who is Ma Jian
who is Ma Jian? In 1989, he was selected as the power forward of the national team. He joined the team in the 1992 Barcelona Olympics. In 1993, he went to the United States to participate in the ncaa game in disregard of the men's basketball regulations. He hoped to land in the NBA. Not only did he fail to become the first Chinese NBA player, but he was abroad. Became a "basketball tramp" and has never been with the national team ever since.
returned to CBA to join midfielder Aoshen in 1998. Two years later, in a cba match against Shanghai Oriental Sharks (Yao Ming was still there), he was kicked out by the team because of two misses at the last minute. And the team began a long-term contract dispute.
did not join the Shanghai team until 2002, and was fired less than a year later, ending his career as a player. After
retired, with the rise of the domestic basketball network era, he successively commented on Sina and other media as a "basketball legend", and repeatedly criticized the "darkness" of the domestic basketball circle and even the national team using his own experience as an example.
But since he was turned out to argue with another commentator Pan Hai (yes, it was also from Yang Yi's company) on the Penguin Channel last year, he made the statement "Who said that Duncan is the number one power forward in history", it has basically been insulated from the platform. .
Ma Jian, a different kind of Chinese basketball
, he has his own talents and started his dream of entering the NBA early. In the end, he failed and wandered overseas.
He claims to be a famous player in men's basketball, but he is one of the rare Luthers in the hands of a country at his age who has not done anything for the country.
He prides himself on ill-fated, but he can conflict with the club and his colleagues wherever he goes, and his end is dismal. Z1z
thinks that he is the most unlucky genius player in China only by relying on a small video of dozens of seconds on the Internet. It is too low to underestimate the talents of Yi Jianlian and Song Tao.
thinks that he was dragged down by the times and the country just because he went to the United States, too much to ignore the difficulty of Wang Zhizhi and Yao Ming in opening up territory in the NBA. As a player of the same period as the "golden generation" of China's 96, how does
compare with Hu Weidong, Liu Yudong, and Sun Jun in terms of ability, contribution, personality, and reputation?
took advantage of the Internet era of domestic NBA broadcasts. He has been a commentator on several websites. According to reason, his professional experience should not be worse than the current Li Ke and Huo Nan. Why is he disappearing now?
In a word, he can't play NBA because of his ability (he has no major injuries in his career). But mixing so badly in the domestic basketball circle is a character issue.
Second, the "Yang Huahua"
Yang Yi, who has never stopped talking surprisingly, is probably the most miserable commentator on the entire network. Whenever the prediction is wrong, this picture will flood the Internet.
But there is one thing to say, his qualifications in the domestic basketball reporting circle and the level of news reporting are probably not questioned.
He started basketball reporting in 1998 and was one of the earliest basketball reporters in China. He successively worked in "Beijing Youth Daily", "Sports Weekly", and "Basketball Pioneer" (later returned to "Sports" as editor-in-chief). He started his own business in 2016 and his public account "Yang Yi Kanqiu" should be the mostIt is also the most successful new basketball media.
He has been involved in basketball commentary since 2001. He has worked for CCTV as a guest commentator for a long time. After he exclusively purchased the NBA copyright at the Goose Factory, he has been a guest commentator, and he often appears in the company. Pan Hai, Guan Weijia and Shen Zhiyu are all his company. of.
Yang Yi’s level of commentary is ignored, but the reality is that under the current circumstances, Yang Yi’s team has in-depth cooperation with the broadcast platform, and many reporters under his name who were previously engaged in writing work have been pushed to understand. First line. When
sees this, everyone should understand that Ma Jian and Yang Yi are torn apart this time. To put it bluntly, Yang Yi's team grabbed his job.
I have been a professional basketball player for decades, and now I can’t be disbanded and returned to the fields like the old guys I used to be, and I am a part-time coach and boss in the original club. Committing to marry as a commentary, you are still robbed of jobs by your group of young people, which is unbearable!
Originally, there is only one in the copyright collection that can broadcast NBA, and it is all occupied by you. Because I have not quarreled, you lost your jobs. Now it's hard to pick up a ready-made one (thanks to the Clippers' upset loss to the Nuggets), and still not full firepower?
Let’s talk about the third question. What kind of basketball commentary should the commentator sitting on the commentary stand be like? 3. What kind of basketball commentary do we need
Before discussing this issue, we must first clarify a problem, explains the game Is it the same thing as participating in a competition?
In today's professional sports framework, the level of refinement and standardization of each position is improving, but it involves players, coaches, referees, and team doctors who protect the front and back of a game. What about
? They may be on the sidelines or thousands of miles away, but what is certain is that whatever they do will not interfere with the progress of the game.
What do they do? A rough summary is that
provides information and provides the audience with the basic information and latest developments of both sides of the competition.
forecast summary, analyze and judge the comparison of strengths and weaknesses of the two sides before the game, deduct and comment on the results of the game and the possible process of style characteristics, and make comments and generalizations on the performance of both sides after the game.
explain and comment. Of course, the most important thing is to comment on the players’ performance on the field, the coach’s tactical arrangement and even the referee’s penalty scale during the game, and explain the game rules and background. When
is here, everyone should understand that as an NBA commentator, while having a deep professional basketball skills, language expression, writing ability and even personal charm are actually equally important.
Take the current NBA broadcast as an example. It is usually divided into three groups:
. One is a sideline reporter. The more famous female reporter Doris Booker (this year will become the first live female commentator in the NBA Finals), deceased The old SEG who is often "mossed" by Popovich.
The second type is courtside commentary, usually by a professional non-basketball commentator as the host. The most famous is the late "Voice of the Lakers" Zike Hearn, and then invite one or two nba coaches or celebrities For professional analysis, the well-known Yao Ming’s former coach Jeff Van Gundy, Cole’s predecessor in the Warriors Mark Jackson, and Pacers legendary shooter Reggie Miller are now doing this.
The third category is the commentators in the broadcast room. The most famous are TNT’s live treasure combination O’Neill Barkley and eapn’s "American Yang Yi" Stephen A. Smith and the famous reporter Bill Simmons. They only provide pre-match predictions and post-match comments, as well as participating in various special programs, such as the famous "TNT COURT". In order to increase the ratings, such commentators are mainly responsible for the effect of the program, so there are both Uranus superstars like O'Neill, and there are also super big mouths like Smith who have no professional player experience.
_So even if the United States has nearly 50 years of TV broadcasting experience, it will only further refine the reporting work outside the basketball court, but it has never required people with professional basketball experience to comment.
Thebasketball commentary is divided into two parts as the name suggests. It not only requires considerable basketball business knowledge, but also must be able to analyze and express. This even involves related professional fields such as broadcasting, hosting, and news. Not only requires them to have a wealth of basketball experience.
As everyone knows, because athletes have been targeting professional sports since they were young, most of their education and literacy levels have been restricted. This does not only refer to the domestic, but the so-called American players who come from college drafts are mostly unqualified bosses. For example, Kyrie Irving who thinks that "the earth is flat".
So except for a few players who are born with strong expression skills and have tactical thinking skills, most of them do not have the ability to interpret the game to the audience in front of the camera. And those players who are good at thinking, flexible in mind, and strong in communication skills are more inclined to change to coaches after retiring. They will only consider commenting for a living when they have nothing to do. This is why many coaches consider commenting on the sidelines after retirement. The reason for the game.
Therefore, although I also agree that "professional matters should be entrusted to professional people", but it does not mean that basketball commentary must be handed over to basketball professionals. He needs to select people with comprehensive qualities from a comprehensive perspective. To help the audience interpret the game and improve the effect of the program.
and Ma Jian’s expression is entirely out of selfishness, secretly changing the concept. According to his logic, the commentary of the game must be held by someone who has been a professional player or coach before it can be graded in order to improve the public's basketball level and awareness.
, let’s not say how many players rely on their natural intuition in the game. The tactical ideas are not only single but short-circuited. When playing, they can’t even understand the tactics and don’t understand them. Now they can understand the tactical arrangement and game progress of the NBA. And even if you understand, how many people have enough expressive ability to fully convey his feelings about the game to the audience?
Anyway, as a fan of James, I once listened to Ma Jianwen’s commentary, and James felt very embarrassed and hairy all over the audience.
Is this professional?
Yang Yi’s language is really prone to causing scolding and controversy on the Internet. The prediction is not 100% accurate, but his analysis of the game process, the grasp of the overall process, and even the accuracy of the language And humor is worthy of recognition. Besides, if the prediction was accurate every time, he would have been praised as a half fairy. The copyright monopoly platform of
will inevitably lead to the unity of style, and the industry ecology where a hundred flowers bloom and you catch up can best serve consumers. If the audience's dissatisfaction with the quality of the broadcast is attributed to individual commentators, let alone cure the root cause, or even cure the symptoms.
Step back ten thousand steps. If you don’t like it, you can change to the original soundtrack (provided that you understand it). If you don’t like it, you can skip it or watch it elsewhere. Isn’t he too sorry for his IQ to be easily used by a middle-aged Luther who is frustrated in his life and ill-intentioned?
