Everyone is familiar with the image of Lin Daiyu in " Dream of Red Mansions ", but the many actors of this classic character are uneven, and the gap can be seen by comparing them together.
"Two curves seem to be frowning but not frowning, and one pair of eyes that seem to be happy but not happy. The face brings sorrow to both cheeks, and the delicate affliction is a disease."
This is Cao Xueqin Teacher 2 comments and descriptions of Lin Daiyu.
It can be seen that Lin Daiyu's image is sentimental and charming, but as for the actors' acting skills we see now, it depends on the actors' acting skills.
Next, let’s follow the editor to see how these 9 old Babys interpret Lin Daiyu!
01 Wang Wenjuan2 Yue Opera
Let’s first talk about Lin Daiyu’s actor Wang Wenjuan in Yue Opera "Dream of Red Mansions". Perhaps most young people have never heard of her name, but she is a first-class Yue Opera actor in our country.
As a first-class artist in the country, she has created many characters that are deeply rooted in the hearts of the people. The most famous one is the 62 version of Lin Meimei performed by Wang Wenjuan, which is a classic in the minds of several generations.
She is good at expressing the inner heart of the characters and portrays complex emotions and entanglements to the fullest. As a national first-class Yue Opera actor, her acting skills are naturally nothing to say.
In terms of clothing, Wang Wenjuan's appearance may be a bit more gorgeous. As we all know, Lin Meimei is very arrogant and chaste. Perhaps it is more suitable for her to be cleaner or fairy-like clothes.
Wang Wenjuan's Lin Daiyu may be more realistic. She presented the characteristics of Daiyu , such as delicate and weak.
However, they still lack some of Lin Daiyu's unique temperament and do not show Daiyu's jealousy and agitated characteristics.
Wang Wenjuan's Lin Daiyu may make people feel pity, but it lacks the power of Lin Daimei.
So the most accepted person in the public is still Lin Daiyu played by Chen Xiaoxu . Compared with Wang Wenjuan, Chen Xiaoxu is a little weaker, and has a little more thoughts and eloquent attitude.
02 He Saifei 6 version of Yue Opera
Yue Opera performing artist He Saifei also played Lin Daiyu. She is beautiful, upright, grand and charming.
Her Lin Daiyu seems to be more bright and charming. Her smile is very charming, but the sunny smile does not seem to fit Lin Daiyu herself.
I have to admit that she is really beautiful and has the best appearance in all different versions of "Dream of Red Mansions".
However, He Saifei is also a first-class actor in in my country. Her acting skills are online and her singing skills are even more amazing. She can easily pick up the singing of Jia Baoyu or Lin Daiyu.
The Lin Meimei she plays is impeccable in terms of temperament. She expresses her emotions in a tactful way with singing style, portraying Lin Meimei's image very well.
But her Lin Daiyu always makes people feel that it is unique.
03 Chen Xiaoxu 87 CCTV TV series version
Chen Xiaoxu's 87 version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is the most successful and closest so far. No matter which direction it is in, it is the best of all versions.
This 87-version film and television drama can achieve such results not only in its music, costumes, and props, but also in one of the important reasons.
is amazing, actor Chen Xiaoxu's life seems to have some vague connection with Lin Daiyu.
Chen Xiaoxu not only has a similar personality to Lin Daiyu, but her behavior and words reveal a feeling of depression and sadness. She also talked about three coincidences between herself and Lin Daiyu.
Not only that, when facing choices and dissatisfaction, Chen Xiaoxu often reveals the strength and chastity of Daiyu's heart.
I still remember that Chen Xiaoxu ranked third in the audition competition with other actors. The director once asked her if she wanted to try other roles, but she stubbornly said: I only play Lin Daiyu.
"I am Lin Daiyu.If I play other roles, the audience will think that Lin Daiyu is playing the role of another girl. "
Chen Xiaoxu thinks she is Lin Daiyu. Whether in her past or present life, they have a close connection.
It is precisely because of Chen Xiaoxu's words that director Wang Fulin seemed to see the Lin Daiyu who was unwilling to live under someone else's house. He agreed to let her play the role of Lin Daiyu.
When Chen Xiaoxu came out from behind the scenes, everyone was stunned. Director Wang Fulin directly determined her role.
Chen Xiaoxu played Lin Daiyu vividly and vividly. Her every frown and smile was sad. She was sensitive and suspicious. She had a jealous and jealous temperament, but she grasped the standards and was still as windy. Fan, she loves to cry but is very strong inside.
Every frame seems to be living Lin Daiyu standing there, as if she is in our lives, right in front of us, Chen Xiaoxu has reached the state of selflessness and merged with Lin Daiyu into one.
In fact, before this, there was a dreamy link between Lin Daiyu in 87 and Lin Daiyu in 62. Chen Xiaoxu asked his senior Wang Wenjuan before playing Lin Daiyu. Wang Wenjuan praised her as a flower, and Chen Xiaoxu did have a good temperament.
She knows and communicates with Lin Daiyu, and she agrees that Lin Daiyu's burial behavior is the creation of art This is very consistent with her own ideas. In this way, she became the unforgettable Lin Meimei in the hearts of the audience with her own efforts.
This is the casting of the 1987 version of "Dream of Red Mansions", and the crew is also very attentive in terms of costume props, recruiting wise men across the country. The person who was selected as the head of the prop group of "Dream of Red Mansions" was Ma Qiang .
He is very talented in hand-made production. It can be said that the success of the 1987 version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is inseparable from his efforts. He consulted ancient books and designed and produced them himself.
plus the crew also has careful designs in terms of costumes, which can be seen from Lin Daiyu's clothes. The attentiveness of the clothing group.
Daiyu's clothes are very clean and fairy, mostly white or light colors, and the materials are mainly gauze, silk, silk, etc.
perfectly interprets her personality traits, and also shows the uninhabited side of Daiyu played by Chen Xiaoxu.
She is not playing Lin Daiyu, she is Lin Daiyu.
She is sentimental, delicate, restrained and implicit, and independent of the world. These are all Lin Daiyu and Chen Xiaoxu.
So the 87th edition of "Dream of Red Mansions" is better.
04 Tao Huimin 9 Beijing Film Series Movie Version
is also a film and television "Dream of Red Mansions", the 1989 movie version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is played by Tao Huimin, and she and Chen Xiaoxu have always been the point of debate among the audience.
Tao Huimin also has a very outstanding appearance. The topic of which she and Chen Xiaoxu are closer to Lin Daiyu and who act more like Lin Daiyu has never been put down.
Tao Huimin's appearance was unanimously recognized by the audience when the film reviews were broadcast. She is beautiful and has the beauty of classical and ancient charm.
She also has a smart, quiet and graceful temperament of a lady, but she lacks a lonely and helpless feeling.
The Lin Meimei she interprets is more layered, and she must taste it slowly before she can understand it.
Perhaps in appearance, Lin Daiyu in our hearts is Tao Huimin, but Chen Xiaoxu has made herself into the character in the play. "Similarity" is the key to Chen Xiaoxu's recognition and touching hearts.
Tao Huimin is like Lin Daiyu, and Chen Xiaoxu is Lin Daiyu.
05 Jiang Mengjie 0 version of the TV series
The most difficult thing to judge is Lin Daiyu played by Jiang Mengjie in the 10th version. She is actually lucky because she became famous in this work.
Under the 87 version of "Dream of Red Mansions" as a measure, this work will undoubtedly be torn a lot by the audience. Lin Daiyu is the core character, and Jiang Mengjie, who plays the heroine, will definitely be the first to be affected.
Under the rigid conditions such as the audience, Jiang Mengjie is acting for the first time, and she bears most of the pressure exerted by the audience.
Some people say that she has a classical temperament and is suitable for this role.
Some people say that the Lin Daiyu she plays is "Shou and Dai Fat".
In short, although everyone praises and criticizes Jiang Mengjie's Lin Daiyu, in fact, most viewers still cannot accept such an actor playing Lin Daiyu.
Jiang Mengjie's Lin Daiyu seems to be more lively, but she gives people a feeling of being very angry in the Jia family, and does not have the cleverness and eloquence of Lin Daiyu.
Lin Daiyu is delicate, but she has backbone. She will not allow others to bully herself, nor will she bully others.
and, "Liberty is like a delicate flower shining on the water, and action is like a weak willow to support the wind. The heart is more than a dry, and the disease is like a Xizi and three points better." This is a description of Lin Daiyu.
The role played by Jiang Mengjie looks too inconsistent. The Lin Meimei she performed in the role is round and smooth, and she seems to be unable to get involved with the weak Daiyu.
Lin Daiyu is spiritual, but these are not seen in Jiang Mengjie.
If it weren't for this drama, the audience might not have associated Jiang Mengjie with Lin Daiyu's character.
But putting aside these, actor Jiang Mengjie's acting skills are still remarkable. In addition, this 10-version work has a young focus - playing Qingwen Yang Mi , and playing adult Jia Baoyu Yang Yang .
is not only a gap in actors, but the 10th version has no attentiveness in background music, costumes and props, etc., and it has many loopholes, which has also led to a worse reputation of actor Jiang Mengjie. Of course, the proportion of her own reasons accounts for a larger proportion.
However, Chen Xiaoxu in the 1987 version of "Dream of Red Mansions" was not accepted by everyone. Naturally, some people think she is not beautiful enough and she is not suitable.
But through his own efforts, Chen Xiaoxu combined himself with Daiyu in the play and felt it with his heart. The final effect made the audience impressed.
10 version Lin Daiyu played by Jiang Mengjie was born in this era of the development of information on the Internet, and it will inevitably be censored and criticized by people all over the country.
In fact, Jiang Mengjie's appearance can actually be said to be somewhat suitable for the role of Lin Daiyu.
Jiang Mengjie's facial features are not bright and three-dimensional, but belongs to the type of small facial features and her face looks a little thin.
This also just highlights Daiyu's indifferent fame and fortune and independent personality.
Director Li Shaohong When explaining the reason when Jiang Mengjie was selected to play Daiyu, he said: is not very secular. This girl has many such very selfish and inadvertent things.
Another one is that her image is very personalized. This is what I think she has both. She is more out of the world and more classical.
director has unique insights into his casting.
In short, the 10th version of "Dream of Red Mansions" cannot match the classics of the 1987 version everywhere, which is not a preconceived sentiment.
In terms of props and costumes, the 87th version has largely restored the original work, while the 10th version of props is extremely unintentional.
For example, Daiyu buried flowers, the crew of the 10th edition of the crew casually used fake flowers, and the audience could see at a glance that it was really embarrassing.
Let’s talk about clothing styles. The 87 version of Lin Daiyu’s clothing design is mainly white and light colors, with plum, orchid and bamboo embroidered, which reflects Lin Daiyu’s arrogant personality.
to version 10, but the styling is very outrageous. The designer's illogical design and production, he doesn't know what his hairstyle is expressing, and his clothes are not apt.
This directly affected Jiang Mengjie's shaping of this character and left a strange impression on the audience.
This is why we always feel that the 10th version is not as good as the 10th version. Not only the actors, but the entire crew actually have a responsibility, perhaps the audience cannot understand their art.
Of course, these do not affect the audience's love for "Dream of Red Mansions" itself. In addition to the above remakes, in fact, there are also related works in Taiwan and Hong Kong.
06 Zhao Yongxin's 1983 TV series
Taiwanese artist Zhao Yongxin starred in the 1983 Taiwanese version of "Dream of Red Mansions", and she also played Lin Daiyu in the play.
Zhao Yongxin's appearance is amazingly beautiful. In that era when makeup technology is underdeveloped and in that era without beauty filters, Zhao Yongxin was incredibly beautiful.
After graduation, she was selected by the director because she was beautiful and starred in "The Elegant Drama Dream of Red Mansions" . This is her first TV series in her life.
This is also the first acting in Zhao Yongxin's life, and she also plays Lin Daiyu from "Dream of Red Mansions".
Although Zhao Yongxin's version of Lin Daiyu is not famous, her appearance is still somewhat similar to Daiyu, and her image is also very popular.
also because of this drama, Qiongyao fell in love with this aura girl, not sure whether it is because of her beauty or her acting skills.
This drama made Zhao Yongxin start the peak of her acting career. Zhao Yongxin was appreciated by Qiong Yao, and Qiong Yao began to promote her.
Of course, Zhao Yongxin did not disappoint Qiong Yao's expectations for her. She became popular. With her beautiful face and excellent acting skills, she also humbly learned from her seniors for advice, and she began to be well-known to the public.
Although Zhao Yongxin's achievements are inseparable from her own efforts, she is lucky. It can be said that God rewards her with food, and her interpretation is very smooth.
Of course, compared with the previous ones of Wang Wenjuan, Chen Xiaoxu and others, she did not have any surprisingly outstanding performances, which is just about shaping Lin Daiyu's image.
07 Zhang Yuyan 6 Taiwan China TV version
What I want to talk about below is also a Taiwanese version of "Dream of Red Mansions", but this is the 1996 version, and Taiwanese actress Zhang Yuyan plays the role of Lin Daiyu.
Lin Daiyu played by Zhang Yuyan is called the "most beautiful" Lin Daiyu, and the 96-TV version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is also a work that made her truly known to everyone.
Although she did not leave a deep impression on everyone like Lin Daiyu played by Chen Xiaoxu, Lin Daiyu played by Zhang Yuyan is also very unique.
There is always a kind of sorrow between her eyebrows and eyes, which is charming, and her weak temperament is also very consistent with Lin Daiyu.
08 Mao Shunyun 7 Hong Kong Good Video Edition
Mao Shunyun, who is different from Zhang Yuyan, played the Hong Kong version of "Dream of Red Mansions" in 1977.
Mao Shunjun once fell in love with Leslie Cheung . She was also called "The Most Beautiful Lin Daiyu in Hong Kong" at that time, but unfortunately, Mao Shunjun refused Leslie Cheung's proposal at that time.
When Mao Shunyun first debuted, her figure, temperament, age and other aspects were very consistent with the requirements of the role of Lin Daiyu.
She was a little round at that time. She laughed at herself as Fat Daiyu at that time. At the age of seventeen, she was ignorant and unable to play the feeling of Daiyu burying flowers, which made a lot of jokes.
But she seems to be more in line with the role of Daiyu at a young age, and her pure and beautiful appearance has also attracted a lot of fans.
However, she later left the title of "pure jade girl" and turned to become a comedian.
09 Zhang Aijia 7 movie version
If Mao Shunjun's Lin Daiyu is pure and innocent, then Zhang Aijia's Lin Daiyu has a little more beauty. The most noteworthy thing about the Hong Kong film version of "Dream of Red Mansions" in
77 is Jia Baoyu who was cross-dressed by Brigitte Lin . Brigitte Lin's heroic spirit and Mao Shunjun's beauty form a beautiful landscape.
Zhang Aijia's Lin Daiyu is beautiful, but she lacks the temperament that Lin Daiyu should have. Like Mao Shunjun, she does not have that melancholy temperament, nor does she feel weak.
or Sylvia Chang's life experience tells us why she can't play Lin Daiyu, because she is the opposite of Lin Daiyu. Lin Daiyu is "sad", she is "courage", and free.
Every Lin Daiyu has its own merits. They all have their own characteristics and use their own unique features to portray Lin Daiyu's different characteristics. In fact, every version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is worthy of our respect, and it is the sweat result of the actors and the staff behind the scenes.
