Nowadays, Core i7-12700H + RTX 3060 independent graphics and Ryzen 7 6800H + RTX 3060 independent graphics are the mainstream gaming laptop configurations chosen by more users. However, due to the current differences in hardware power consumption and the design of different products, Differences in aspects may cause products with the same configuration to have completely different experiences. Coupled with the coexistence of DDR4/DDR5 memory, PCIe 3.0/PCIe 4.0 solid state drives and , the experience difference between different products with the same configuration is even greater.
Therefore, we have collected 8 very popular i7-12700H+RTX 3060 independent graphics gaming notebooks on the market recently, as well as a very representative Ryzen 7 6800H+RTX 3060 independent graphics gaming notebook, through Hengping Let’s see how this mainstream configuration performs on different products.
declares in advance that all products in this Hengping review are purchased from JD.com and are not sent for testing by manufacturers. Therefore, any problems that occur with the products may be problems that consumers will actually encounter.
[Comparison results]
Without further ado, let’s look at the test results first, and then we will give separate purchase opinions on each product.
In terms of processor performance, the Ryzen 7 6800H processor equipped in the ASUS Tianxuan 3 Plus Ryzen Edition lags behind significantly in both single-core and multi-core performance. The Lenovo Savior Y9000P has the strongest overall performance, and the ASUS Tianxuan 3 Core Edition also performs very well. good.
ASUS Tianxuan 3 Plus Ryzen Edition has fully unleashed its graphics card performance. The three test scores of DMark are the best. However, in actual games, the Tianxuan 3 Core Edition has the best frame rate performance. This means that under the same configuration, the Core i7-12700H processor can improve the frame rate better than the Ryzen 7 6800H.
In terms of power consumption and temperature, the MSI Samurai 76 has the worst power consumption of single-baking GPU and dual-baking machines. The single-baking GPU is 104.551W, and the overall power consumption of dual-baking is only 129.93W. The power consumption of single-baking CPU is 104.551W. The best release is Acer Shadow Knight Qing, which reaches 94.99W. The best power consumption release of GPU single bake machine and double bake machine is Lenovo Savior Y9000P 2022. The GPU single bake machine reaches 139.411W and the double bake machine is 44.89W. +128.72W, full performance release. In terms of temperature, the best dual-baking machine is the Acer Shadow Knight Qing, while the temperature of the Shadow Elf 8 is relatively high
In terms of hard drive read and write performance, the PCIe 4.0 solid-state drive equipped with the Acer Shadow Knight Qing has the best performance level. Dell Game Box G15 and MSI Samurai 76 still use PCIe 3.0 solid-state drives, and the hard drive performance of Dell Game Box G15 is relatively poor among PCIe 3.0 solid-state drives.
However, there were serious problems with the Mechanical Revolution Aurora Pro during the testing process. The hard drive score was still abnormal after multiple debuggings, with the read and write speed less than 500MB/s. You should pay more attention when actually purchasing the machine.
In terms of screens, except for the Dell Game Box G15, HP Shadow Elf 8, and Mechanical Revolution Aurora Pro, the other models sRGB color gamut are 100%. In terms of brightness, the Savior Y9000P 2022 reaches 538.2nits, which is the best performance. In terms of color accuracy, the Savior Y9000P 2022 is also the best, with an average ΔE=0.83.
Overall, in terms of screen quality, the Mechanical Revolution Aurora Pro performed relatively poorly, while the Savior Y9000P 2022 performed best.
[Single product review]
Acer Shadow Knight·Qing
[Configuration and price]
Processor: Intel Core i7-12700H
Graphics card: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3060 (140W)
Memory: 16GB DDR4 3200MHz
hard drive: 512GB PCIe 4.0 solid state drive
Screen: 15.6 inches 2.5K/165Hz/100% DCI-P3 color gamut/IPS
Reference price: 7699 yuan
[Advantages and disadvantages]
Advantages:
Excellent screen quality
Strong hard disk reading and writing performance
Double oven temperature control is excellent
Disadvantages :
The lower border of the screen is too wide and looks a bit clumsy.
[Purchase Suggestion]
Performance: The CPU power consumption is fully released and the performance is quite satisfactory. Except for the excellent temperature control of the double oven, there is not much that stands out in other aspects. This is also in line with Shadow Knight Qing’s own positioning. In addition, this product performs well in terms of hard disk read and write performance. If you want to choose a product with a good overall experience, it is a good choice.
screen: 65Hz high brush, 2.5K resolution, which is quite consistent with the 15.6-inch screen size. Moreover, this product supports 100% DCI-P3 color gamut, and sRGB actually exceeds 100%. The evolution of the screen is obvious to all, and it can provide users with power Leveling experience.
interface: has a reasonable overall layout, and all commonly used interfaces are provided to users, but the design of the air outlet on the right side will affect the user's use to some extent. Price of
: The recent reference price of is 7699 yuan. Judging from its overall specifications, the price/performance ratio is quite good.
ASUS Tianxuan 3 Core Edition
[Configuration and Price]
Processor: Intel Core i7-12700H
Graphics Card: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3060 (140W)
Memory: 16GB DDR5 4800MHz
Hard Drive: 51 2GB PCIe 4.0 SSD
Screen: 15.6 inches 2.5 K/165Hz/100% DCI-P3 color gamut/IPS
Reference price: 8799 yuan
[Advantages and disadvantages]
Advantages:
Excellent performance release
Excellent screen quality
Highly recognizable appearance design
Disadvantages:
The bottom border of the screen is too wide. It looks a bit clumsy
The direction keys are of a half-height design, which is not very friendly to gamers
[Purchase Suggestions]
Performance: The comprehensive performance release of ASUS Tianxuan 3 Core Edition is almost impeccable, CPU, GPU single and double bake tests All have reached the ideal state. The CPU and GPU performance are fully released and the core temperature control is also good, but the fan noise will be relatively loud.
Screen: has the same 165Hz high refresh rate and 2.5K resolution display as the Acer Shadow Knight Qing. It is also 15.6 inches and supports 100% DCI-P3 color gamut, and sRGB actually exceeds 100%.
interface: The left interface is too crowded, and it seems quite messy after connecting network cables, HDMI, and power cords at the same time. There is also an air outlet design on the right side. Price of
: The recent reference price of is 8,799 yuan. In terms of cost performance, it is quite satisfactory. However, Tianxuan 3 Core Edition is currently one of the most worth considering models with the same configuration, and has no shortcomings in overall strength.
ASUS Tianxuan 3 Plus Ryzen Edition
[Configuration and Price]
Processor: AMD Ryzen 7 6800H
Graphics Card: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3060 (140W)
Memory: 16GB DDR5 4800MHz
Hard Drive: 51 2GB PCIe 4.0 SSD
Screen: 17.3 inch 2.5K/360Hz/100% sRGB color gamut/IPS
Reference price: 8499 yuan
[Advantages and disadvantages]
Advantages:
Large screen + high brush, excellent visual experience
Excellent graphics card performance release, good gaming experience
Good value for money
Disadvantages :
CPU power consumption release does not match the temperature, the power consumption is low, the temperature is high
The bottom border of the screen is too wide, it looks a bit clumsy
The direction keys are half-height design, not very friendly to gamers
[Purchase advice]
Performance : The CPU performance of ASUS Select 3 Plus Ryzen Edition is somewhat lagging behind. Especially when dealing with multi-core tasks, the shortcomings of CPU performance will be magnified, so it is not suitable for productivity applications that rely on multi-core and multi-threading features. GPU performance is excellent, so if you just play games, ASUS Tianxuan 3 Plus Ryzen Edition has a good price/performance ratio, but if it involves multi-core and multi-threaded applications, especially applications with heavy loads, there will be a certain degree of efficiency in terms of efficiency. shortcomings.
screen: 7.3-inch 360Hz high refresh screen effect is excellent, and the experience of playing games on a large screen is definitely better. However, the average color accuracy of this screen is low. Although the difference is not visible to the human eye, it is undeniable that it is weaker than several other products.
Interface: is the same as the Tianxuan 3 Core Edition. The left interface is too crowded, and it will be quite messy when the network cable, HDMI, and power cord are connected at the same time. In addition, there is also an air outlet design on the right side. One point to note here is that at this stage, due to the high power consumption of the CPU/GPU, the air outlet on the right side is no longer classified as a shortcoming in a strict sense, but will only affect the user experience to a certain extent. Price of
: The recent reference price of is 8,499 yuan. Since it is a 17.3-inch large-screen model and the graphics card performance is excellent, the price is quite competitive. If you simply play games, this machine is one of the first choices. If other heavy-load tasks are also involved, you need to consider the multi-core efficiency of the processor.
Dell Game Box G15
[Configuration and Price]
Processor: Intel Core i7-12700H
Graphics Card: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3060 (130W)
Memory: 16GB DDR4 3200MHz
Hard Drive: 512GB PCIe 3.0 SSD
Screen: 15.6 inches 1080p/165Hz/ 99% sRGB color gamut/IPS
Reference price: 7799 yuan
[Advantages and disadvantages]
Advantages:
Good CPU and GPU performance
Disadvantages:
PCIe 4.0 solid state drive is not upgraded and Poor hard disk performance
core temperature is too high when fully loaded
direction The key is a half-height design, which is not very friendly to gamers
[Purchase Suggestions]
Performance: The performance of the Dell Game Box G15 is somewhat polarizing. Both the CPU and GPU performance release are excellent, but the hard drive performance is really too much. , even if it is equipped with a PCIe 3.0 solid-state drive, the read and write performance has not yet reached high-end levels. It can be seen that in order to lower the price, some corners are cut in some configurations. In addition, the core temperature is too high when the performance is fully loaded. The CPU reaches 98°C when only 83W is fired. The efficiency of the cooling system needs to be improved.
Screen: The screen of Game Box G15 has reached the average level, with a 15.6-inch 165Hz high refresh rate, but the resolution is simply set to 1080p. For gamers, whether they need a resolution of 2K or above is a matter of opinion.
Interface:
Price: The recent reference price is 7799 yuan. It seems that the price is lower than other models with the same configuration, but considering that the hard disk and screen configuration have shrunk, the price does not seem so good.
HP OMEN Shadow Elf 8
[Configuration and Price]
Processor: Intel Core i7-12700H
Graphics Card: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3060 (115W)
Memory: 16GB DDR5 4800MHz
Hard Drive: 51 2GB PCIe 4.0 SSD
Screen: 16.1 inches 1080p/144Hz /99% sRGB color gamut/IPS
Reference price: 7999 yuan
[Advantages and disadvantages]
Advantages:
Double oven CPU + GPU power consumption release is in perfect condition
Excellent core temperature control under high load
Disadvantages:
graphics card power consumption shrinks
The direction keys have a half-height design, which is not very friendly to gamers.
The lower border of the screen is too wide and looks a bit clumsy.
[Purchasing Suggestions]
Performance: Although HP Shadow Elf 8 has perfect power consumption and excellent temperature control, I have to say that the 115W RTX 3060 must be a pity for users. The overall feeling of Shadow Elf 8 is very mediocre, with no obvious highlights and no obvious shortcomings. It is passable in all aspects, but not outstanding in all aspects. It would be fine if it were another brand, but as a product produced by , HP , it is still a bit regretful.
Screen: The screen effect of HP Shadow Elf 8 is also relatively mediocre. There are no bright spots and no shortcomings. The 1080p resolution can only be said to be a trade-off, and it is not enough to become a shortcoming of the product.
interface: The interface of this product also has the problem of accumulation on the left side. It will be very messy when all kinds of cables are plugged in. Moreover, the USB port on the left side is sandwiched between the network port and HDMI, which will be inconvenient when used at the same time. . In addition, it also has an air outlet design on the right side. Price of
: The recent reference price of is 7999 yuan, which is good value for money. The overall performance of Shadow Elf 8 is relatively mediocre. Friends who want stability and don’t mind the 115W RTX 3060 can buy it. After all, the overall quality of the Shadow Elf series is quite trustworthy.
Lenovo Savior Y9000P 2022
[Configuration and Price]
Processor: Intel Core i7-12700H
Graphics Card: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3060 (140W)
Memory: 16GB DDR5 4800MHz
hard drive: 512GB PCIe 4.0 solid state drive
screen: 16 inches 2.5K/ 165Hz/100% sRGB color gamut/IPS
Reference price: 8799 yuan
[Advantages and disadvantages]
Advantages:
Stable and reliable performance
Excellent temperature control
Excellent screen quality
Full-size arrow key design
Reasonable interface layout
Disadvantages:
has no obvious shortcomings
[Purchase Suggestion]
Performance: Lenovo Savior Y9000P 2022 still maintains excellent performance release, the overall power consumption of CPU + GPU is close to 175W, and the core temperature is controlled below 80°C. This is enough to be proud of Heroes
screen: The screen of this product is even more outstanding, with a high brightness of 538.2nits, an average ΔE of only 0.83, and a 16-inch 2.5K resolution 165Hz high refresh screen, giving users everything they want.
interface: interface has rich configuration and reasonable layout. But it also has a right-side air outlet design. Price of
: The recent reference price of is 8,799 yuan. Judging from its comprehensive quality, as long as the budget is sufficient and you can buy it, it is a no-brainer.
Mechanical Revolution Aurora Pro
[Configuration and Price]
Processor: Intel Core i7-12700H
Graphics Card: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3060 (140W)
Memory: 16GB DDR5 4800MHz
Hard Drive: 512GB PC Ie 3.0 SSD
Screen: 15.6 inches 2K/165Hz/ 98% sRGB color gamut/IPS
Reference price: 8599 yuan
[Advantages and disadvantages]
Advantages:
Good CPU/GPU performance adjustment
Reasonable interface layout
Disadvantages:
There is a problem with quality control. The hard disk test score is extremely low
when it is fully loaded. The CPU power release does not match the temperature, and the temperature is too high
[Purchase Suggestion]
Performance: Mechanical Revolution Aurora Pro has better overall performance, but the power consumption release of the processor is insufficient when the processor is baked alone, and the temperature is too high, and the cooling system There are some problems.
screen: screen performance is quite satisfactory, with no special highlights and no obvious shortcomings.
interface: The interface has a reasonable layout and rich types. It also has a right-side air outlet design. Price of
: The recent reference price of is 8,599 yuan. The actual average price is about 7,900 yuan. The price is artificially high. Friends who are interested in buying can wait patiently for full discount activities or coupons. Generally speaking, it is a relatively satisfactory choice, but you should pay attention to quality control issues including hard drive performance.
MSI Samurai 76
[Configuration and Price]
Processor: Intel Core i7-12700H
Graphics Card: NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3060 (105W)
Memory: 16GB DDR4 3200MHz
Hard Drive: 512GB PC Ie 3.0 SSD
Screen: 15.6 inches 1080p/144Hz/100 % sRGB color gamut/IPS
Reference price: 8499 yuan
[Advantages and disadvantages]
Advantages:
Processor single-core/multi-core performance is good
No right air outlet design
Disadvantages:
The CPU temperature is too high when is under full load.
is not upgraded. PCIe 4.0 SSD
overall power consumption is poor
[Purchase Suggestion]
Performance: The performance of MSI Samurai 76 gives the impression that the processor performance is improved at all costs, but the result is that the CPU + GPU are in a high load state at the same time At this time, the power consumption cannot be fully released due to temperature issues, which also results in that although the CPU scores are good, it does not feel smooth enough in actual applications.
screen: The screen performance is quite satisfactory. The configuration of 1080p/144Hz is actually a bit outdated. This also applies to the previous 1080p/144Hz models.
interface: Generally speaking, there is no problem with the configuration of the interface. Everything that should be given is given, and the design of the air outlet on the right side is avoided. This is a good point. Price of
: The recent reference price of is 8,499 yuan. The price-performance ratio is average, because Tantan is the savior at this price. There is Tianxuan 3 at the same price, and the price competitiveness is almost 0.
Hengping summary:
Combined with the above performance test results, we finally give the test item quality ratio and recommended star rating of the 8 participating products for reference:
Hengping description:
. Test score collection method: This Hengping evaluation is based on the principle of fairness, and all test results follow the "first impression principle." That is, after unboxing and activating the system, set the product to the optimal operating state (turn on high-performance mode, turn on independent graphics direct connection, etc.), and take the first test result as the result. Good is good, bad is bad. No adjustments and retesting are required.
. Product selection instructions: This Hengping planning and product selection start time is March 28, so the product selection is mainly based on the first batch of 12th generation Core and Ryzen 6000 processor gaming laptops. After April The products launched are not included in this Hengping series.
. Purpose of Hengping: This Hengping aims to solve three questions: "Is it true that the performance of the 12th generation Core is better than Ryzen 6000?", "Is it true that different mold designs will affect processor performance? ?”, “Is it true that different processor performance affects the number of game frames?” These three issues have been elaborated on in three articles respectively, and this article is a Hengping review article with the main direction of product purchase recommendations. references.
