Opinion|Yoon Suk Yeol's kowtowing to the US and Japan: what can humiliating diplomacy achieve?

2023年05月08日22:53:08 教育 1132

After more than 50 days, leaders of Japan and South Korea have resumed their"shuttle diplomacy" with reciprocal visits.

Opinion|Yoon Suk Yeol's kowtowing to the US and Japan: what can humiliating diplomacy achieve? - 天天要聞

Fumio Kishida, the Prime Minister of Japan, will visit Seoul for a two-day visit on May 7th and 8th, marking the first visit by a Japanese Prime Minister to South Korea in 12 years. This follows South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol's visit to Tokyo in March, despite criticism and public pressure at home for what many saw as "humiliating diplomacy".

Since March, Yoon's handling of historical disputes between South Korea and Japan, as well as his comments on Japan, have sparked outrage at home. For example, he decided to use private funds to compensate Korean victims of forced labor in Japan, and said in an interview that"I cannot accept the notion Japan must kneel because of our history 100 years ago". Some critics accused him of"kowtowing" to Japan and even suggested he should"naturalize" and move to Japan.

Despite the domestic opposition, Yoon seems determined to push forward. On April 27th, he expressed his loyalty to the US-Japan-Republic of Korea Trilateral Partnership in a speech at the US Congress, citing the growing nuclear and missile threat from North Korea.

Opinion|Yoon Suk Yeol's kowtowing to the US and Japan: what can humiliating diplomacy achieve? - 天天要聞

According to media reports, on May 3rd, Yoon met with Takeo Akiba, the Director-general of Japan's National Security Council, who relayed the message that Kishida's decision to visit South Korea was a gesture of appreciation for Yoon's"determination". This"determination" refers to Yoon's willingness to make significant concessions on the issue of Korean forced labor during World War II, despite domestic political pressure.

In particular, Kishida's visit has been met with high expectations from the Korean public regarding this issue. But in Japan's view, the matter was already settled with the signing of the 1965 Treaty on Basic Relations between Japan and the Republic of Korea. The treaty included an agreement in which Japan provided 300 million dollars in free aid and 200 million dollars in loans to South Korea, which also covered compensation for laborers. Therefore, Japan no longer recognizes the individual compensation claims of Korean forced labors.

Moreover, despite what many believe to be a significant concession by the administration of President Yoon, right-wing forces in Japan are still not satisfied. They believe that recognizing South Korean organizations as compensation representatives for the laborers is tantamount to admitting individual compensation claims by Korean laborers. They are demanding that South Korea remove the Comfort Women Statues and not pursue further Japanese responsibility.

In light of these issues, it seems unlikely that Kishida will apologize for historical disputes during his visit to South Korea.

Opinion|Yoon Suk Yeol's kowtowing to the US and Japan: what can humiliating diplomacy achieve? - 天天要聞

Additionally, the dispute over the Dokdo/Takeshima Islands has caused great rifts between the two nations, and there is no easy solution in sight. Even with the US's help in mediating security issues, South Korea and Japan still have diverging interests. Therefore, it is too early to expect any significant progress in terms of territorial and security issues.

In terms of the economic agenda, both South Korea and Japan have recently agreed to restore each other's"white list" status, meaning they will offer each other trade privileges and remove related restrictions. However, analysts say that just as South Korea and Japan are completely dependent on the US for security issues, they are unlikely to be able to make independent decisions in the economic, especially high-tech, field. It remains to be seen whether Kishida's visit will bring any economic benefits to South Korea.

觀點評論|尹錫悅向美日「叩頭」,屈辱外交能換來什麼回報?

日韓領導人時隔50多天實現互訪,兩國「穿梭外交」正式重啟。

Opinion|Yoon Suk Yeol's kowtowing to the US and Japan: what can humiliating diplomacy achieve? - 天天要聞

岸田文雄將於5月7日至8日對首爾進行為期兩天的訪問,這將是日本首相時隔12年再次訪韓。此前的3月,韓國總統尹錫悅曾頂著國內批評其「屈辱外交」的輿論壓力訪問過東京。

今年3月以來,尹錫悅對韓日歷史爭議問題的處理以及多次涉日言論,例如決定自籌資金幫日本賠償韓國勞工受害者,接受採訪時稱「無法接受日本須為歷史下跪」等等,都在韓國國內引燃怒火,反對派直接炮轟,日本沒跪,反倒是尹錫悅先跪了。民眾甚至在韓媒報道下留言讓尹錫悅「歸化去日本吧!」

然而,即便國內怎麼反對,種種跡象表明,尹錫悅已經是鐵了心打算一條道走到黑了。4月27日,他在美國國會發表演說時就大表「忠心」,稱要強化韓美日三邊同盟,以應對日益緊迫的朝鮮核導威脅。

媒體報道稱,3日,尹錫悅會見了來訪的日本國安保障局局長秋葉剛男,後者傳話稱,岸田拍板提前回訪韓國,就是要回報尹錫悅的決斷,所謂「決斷「意指其不惜承受國內政治壓力,在二戰勞工問題上向日本作出重大原則性讓步。

秋葉剛男口中的「回報」,也確實是韓國輿論對岸田此訪的極大期待,但是,這個問題之所以爭議這麼多年,就是因為在日方看來,半個多世紀前簽署的《日韓請求權協定》,當年日方曾向韓方支付了3億美元無償援助和2億美元貸款,其中包括支付給勞工的補償金,所以問題已解決,日方不再承認韓國個人的索賠權。

此外,即便外界認為尹錫悅政府作出極大妥協,實際上,日本政界右翼勢力仍不滿意,認為岸田內閣認可韓國財團代為補償勞工,等於承認了韓國勞工有個人索賠權,他們還要求韓方拆除慰安婦少女銅像並不得再追究日本責任。

綜上,可以想見,想在歷史爭議問題上讓岸田跑到韓國「致歉」,似乎可能性不大。

除了前述歷史爭議以外,韓日兩國圍繞獨島(日本稱「竹島」)的分歧巨大,矛盾難以化解;哪怕是在美國極力撮合下的安保問題,韓日雙方其實也是同床異夢。所以,期待岸田此行能在領土與安全問題上對韓國有所「回報」,也為時尚早。

此外,就經濟議程而言,韓日都在近期同意恢復將對方納入「貿易白名單」,也就是要互賦貿易優惠,解除相關限制。但分析認為,正如在安保領域完全受制於第三方也就是美國,韓日兩國在經濟尤其是高科技領域,能不能自己說了算都是問題,更別說讓岸田為韓國帶來什麼經濟福利了。(更多新聞資訊,請關注羊城派 pai.ycwb.com)

撰文 | 冷爽翻譯 | 劉佳慧

來源 | 羊城晚報·羊城派

責編 | 戚美青

校對 | 趙丹丹

教育分類資訊推薦

暑假圖書館爆滿背後:拉開孩子差距的三大關鍵因素 - 天天要聞

暑假圖書館爆滿背後:拉開孩子差距的三大關鍵因素

暑假圖書館爆滿背後:拉開孩子差距的三大關鍵因素上周日,我去圖書館寫稿時被眼前的景象震撼:各個閱覽室座無虛席。小學生們專註地寫著暑假作業,高中生認真研讀高二課本,還有孩子鑽研模型設計書籍。這一幕讓我深刻意識到:真正拉開孩子差距的,往往是在學校
黃海剛到畢節六中講授思想政治理論課 - 天天要聞

黃海剛到畢節六中講授思想政治理論課

7月7日,區委副書記、區長黃海剛到畢節六中為學校師生代表講授思想政治理論課。區人民政府黨組成員陳果,區直有關部門分管負責同志,畢節六中師生代表參加。授課現場黃海剛強調,要深入學習貫徹習近平總書記在貴州考察時的重要講話精神,牢記習近平總書記諄諄教誨、殷殷囑託,堅定不移聽黨話、感黨恩、跟黨走。要全面貫徹黨...
濰坊青州市:公益課堂點亮孩子繽紛假期 - 天天要聞

濰坊青州市:公益課堂點亮孩子繽紛假期

來源:【青州融媒】暑假來臨,濰坊青州市開設豐富多彩的暑期公益課堂,讓孩子們收穫知識與快樂。在青州市益都街道旗城社區,大學生志願者帶領孩子們通過共讀繪本、互動遊戲、情景模擬等方式,了解隱私保護與安全知識,提升自我保護意識。
湖北省第九屆高校青年教師教學競賽開賽 - 天天要聞

湖北省第九屆高校青年教師教學競賽開賽

7月9日,湖北省第九屆高校青年教師教學競賽決賽動員大會在中國地質大學(武漢)舉行。本次決賽匯聚了來自全省54所高校的145名優秀青年教師代表,他們將在7月10日至11日的兩天時間裡,分成文科、理科、工科、醫科、思想政治課等5個專項組,展開教
這樣的「端姐」,誰能不喜歡? - 天天要聞

這樣的「端姐」,誰能不喜歡?

在武漢市第一初級中學金雅校區,學生見到徐端,都會親熱地喊她「端姐」「老徐」。她懂孩子的心,樂於跟學生「打成一片」,是學生的良師,也是益友。徐端(右二)和學生在一起。記者劉嘉 攝跟著「端姐」學數學有很多樂趣,她能把數學課講得像脫口秀一樣好玩。
米東區開展學生軍訓教官培訓 - 天天要聞

米東區開展學生軍訓教官培訓

(米東區融媒體中心記者:安銳報道)近日,米東區人武部集中組織學生軍訓教官培訓。米東區退役軍人、基幹民兵積極報名參加此次培訓及資格認證,為即將到來的學生軍訓任務做好充分準備。
英語學習新賽道:奇速英語,開啟你的辭彙逆襲之旅 - 天天要聞

英語學習新賽道:奇速英語,開啟你的辭彙逆襲之旅

英語學習新賽道:奇速英語,開啟你的辭彙逆襲之旅在英語學習的漫漫長路上,辭彙量就像基石,決定著英語能力這座高樓能蓋多高。很多同學都在為記單詞發愁,不是背了就忘,就是面對枯燥的單詞書提不起興趣。