Guan Yu and Zhang Liao are both famous generals in the Three Kingdoms at the end of Han Dynasty. They both lived in the same era, but they were in different camps. Guan Yu was in Liu Bei's camp and was the leading general under Liu Bei. He guarded Jingzhou and played a unique role. Zhang Liao is one of Cao Cao's five good generals. He is in charge of Cao Cao's eastern front and guards Hefei. He has a good record.
Guan Yu and Zhang Liao are both ranked sixty-four generals in Wumiao. If Guan Yu is the first general in the Three Kingdoms, will Zhang Liao be convinced? So, who is the better of the two? Use a set of data to compare.
One, personal offensive ability.
When solving the siege of the White Horse, Zhang Liao and Guan Yu went together. Guan Yu rushed into the Ten Thousand Horse Army and beheaded Yuan Shao General Yan Liang, who was also the enemy general at the time. No one Yuan Shao could resist Guan Yu’s attack. .
"The Legend of the Three Kingdoms Guan Yu": Shaoqian general Yan Liang attacked East County prefect Liu Yan at Baima, and Minister Cao Zhang Liao and Yu were the vanguards. Seeing Liang Jungai, Yu sees Liang Jungai, spurs the spurs among the crowds, beheads his head and returns. As the generals can't be the one, he solves the Baimawei.
In this game, Guan Yu performed outstandingly, Zhang Liao performed mediocre, no record of his record in history books, therefore, in this round, Guan Yu won.
Of course, it does not deny Zhang Liao's offensive ability. During the conquest of Liucheng, Cao Cao awarded Zhang Liao the coach's flag, and Zhang Liao rushed into the enemy's line to kill Shan Yudun.
"The Three Kingdoms Zhang Liao Biography": Cong Zheng Yuan Shang Yu Liucheng, died and the captives, Liao persuaded Taizu to fight, very energetic, Taizu Zhuang, self-held Liao. Then hit it, broke it, and smashed the list.
But when he played with Guan Yu, his performance was mediocre. Therefore, Guan Yu was slightly better.
Second, defensive ability.
When Liu Bei was blocked from Yizhou, Zhuge Liang, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun and others entered Sichuan, leaving Guan Yu to guard Jingzhou for eight years. Neither Cao Cao nor Sun Quan dared to attack Jingzhou. Therefore, Guan Yu was able to stand alone and his defensive ability no doubt.
"The Legend of the Three Kingdoms Guan Yu Biography": The first master of Xiding Yizhou, and the worship of Yu Dong oversee Jingzhou.
When Zhang Liao was guarding Hefei, Sun Quan led an army of 100,000 to attack. At that time, Le Jin and Li Dian were guarding Hefei together with Zhang Liao. There were only 7,000 defenders. In the end, the three generals defeated Sun Quan.
"Three Kingdoms Zhang Liao Biography": The Taizu confiscated Sun Quan and returned Liao Yu Lejin, Li Dian and others to Hefei.
Although Zhang Liao won, but Guan Yu won this round, because there were two famous players Le Jin and Li Dian in this battle, not Zhang Liao alone. Guan Yu guarded Jingzhou, and there was no other famous general to help. Cao Cao and Sun Quan dared not attack.
Third, the best military record.
Guan Yu's best record is the Flooded Seventh Army, Megatron China.
In the autumn of the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an (219 years), Guan Yu led his army to attack Fancheng north, Fancheng defender Cao Ren lost to Guan Yu, and stayed the same. Cao Cao sent the Seventh Army to the Forbidden Governor to rescue him. As a result, he encountered autumn rain and the Han River surged. , Guan Yu led his army to attack the Ban, and the Seventh Army was annihilated. He himself was captured and Pound was killed. Guan Yu won a brilliant victory, and it was a huge shock to China, and Cao Cao was so frightened that he wanted to move the capital to avoid the edge of the switch.
"The Legend of the Three Kingdoms Guan Yu Biography": Twenty-four years, the first ruler is the King of Hanzhong, the former general is worshipped by Yu, and the festival is off. At this age, Yu led the crowd to attack Cao Renyu Fan. Cao Gong was dispatched to help benevolence. In autumn, there was a heavy rain, the Han River overflowed, and the Seventh Army was not supervised by the forbidden place. Ban Yu Yu, Yu cut General Pound again. The Liang, Jia, and Lu Hun group pirates or received the Yuyin number to support the party, and the feathers shocked China. Cao Gongyi moved to Xu Du to avoid Qi Rui.
Zhang Liao's best record is Megatron Xiaoyaojin, and he almost captured Sun Quan.
Sun Quan led an army of one hundred thousand to attack Hefei, but was defeated by Zhang Liao, Le Jin, and Li Dian with seven thousand men. Zhang Liao led a death squad of 800 men into Sun Quan’s army and ran into Sun Quan’s army. Sun Quan was so scared that he ran to a dirt mountain. Not dare to come down, when they retreated, Zhang Liao and others led the army to pursue them, and almost captured Sun Quan alive. Sun Quan and Ma jumped off the bridge to escape. Zhang Liao was shocked by Xiaoyaojin, so that the children in Jiangnan did not dare to cry at night when they heard Zhang Liao's name.
《"Three Kingdoms Zhang Liao Biography": Liao Fu also broke through and pulled out the rest. Power is invincible, no one dares to be. From the beginning of the war to the middle of the day, the Wu people took their breath and also repaired their defenses. The power to stay in Hefei for more than ten days, the city cannot be pulled, but retired. Liao led the army to pursue and several regained power.
is also the best record, but from the point of view of the results and influence, Guan Yu won, because Guan Yu’s Megatron China shocked the entire Central Plains, while Zhang Liao was just Megatron Xiaoyaojin, with no influence Shang Guan Yu.
Although Guan Yu finally failed and defeated Maicheng, it was because he used his own strength to fight against the elite forces of Wei and Wu, and there was no reinforcement to help each other, plus the surrender of the generals. This was a failure. If Guan Yu With the help of two famous generals, they will certainly not fail.
Fourth, Guan Yu will lead the navy, but Zhang Liao does not have the ability to lead the navy.
As everyone knows, Guan Yu can fight on land and will bring naval forces. At the beginning, Liu Bei defeated Dangyang. It was Liu Bei who led hundreds of naval warships to meet Liu Bei and went to Xiakou together.
"The Legend of the Three Kingdoms Guan Yu Biography": Cao Gong determined Jingzhou, the first master was Fan Jiang to cross the river, don't send Yu to take hundreds of ships to Jiangling. Cao Gong chased to Dangyang Changban, the first master of oblique fun Hanjin, suitable for the feather boat, to Xiakou.
And when the Seventh Army was flooded, Guan Yu led the navy to defeat the Seventh Army and captured Yu Jin himself. Therefore, Guan Yu won.
From the above four aspects, Guan Yu is obviously better than Zhang Liao. Of course, it is not that Zhang Liao is not good. Zhang Liao is also a famous general and is very good at fighting. However, in terms of comprehensiveness, he is still slightly weaker than Guan Yu.
